- Immersive survival mechanics core gameplay
- High replayability and build variety
- Strategic and rewarding combat system
- Steep learning curve without guidance
- Clunky and unresponsive combat controls
- Unforgiving difficulty and harsh penalties
Emotions
Players frequently cite clunky, repetitive, or punishing mechanics as major sources of frustration. Key issues include excessive walking, repetitive tasks, and unforgiving combat that often requires external guides or excessive grinding. Bugs, such as lost progress, disappearing items, and glitches, further exacerbate the frustration, making the game feel unpolished and tedious.
Players experience satisfaction after overcoming the game's steep learning curve and mastering its mechanics. The sense of accomplishment comes from strategic planning, overcoming challenges, and feeling that progress is earned. Features like deep build customization, rewarding exploration, and co-op multiplayer enhance this emotion, especially when players discover unique synergies or complete difficult quests.
The game's unique survival mechanics, immersive world, and emergent storytelling create excitement. Players enjoy the thrill of exploration, discovery of hidden content, and the unpredictability of events like weather changes or dynamic encounters. Co-op multiplayer and the anticipation of sequels or mods also contribute to this emotion, as players look forward to new adventures and shared experiences.
Disappointment stems from unmet expectations, particularly regarding the game's polish, depth, and value. Players criticize the empty or repetitive world design, lack of modern conveniences (e.g., fast travel), and poor execution of ambitious ideas. Technical issues, such as bugs, connectivity problems, and unfinished-feeling content, further contribute to the sense that the game fails to deliver on its potential.
Players enjoy the game's unique blend of survival, exploration, and RPG mechanics, particularly when these elements work harmoniously. Co-op multiplayer, creative problem-solving, and the freedom to experiment with builds or strategies are frequently cited as highlights. The game's immersive design, such as lack of hand-holding or realistic survival mechanics, also enhances enjoyment for those who appreciate its old-school approach.
Verdict
Mixed
Summary
Positive 72% · Negative 28%. Score: 28 / 100
Positives:
- The game is praised for its deep and immersive survival elements, such as hunger, thirst, temperature, and disease management. These mechanics are well-integrated into the gameplay, creating a unique and challenging experience that blends survival with RPG and exploration.
- Players highlight the game's high replay value due to diverse playstyles, character builds, and faction quests. The flexibility in skills, equipment, and magic systems encourages multiple playthroughs and experimentation.
- Combat is described as challenging but fair, requiring preparation, stamina management, and strategic thinking. The stagger system, buffs, and varied combat styles add depth and satisfaction once mastered.
- The world is praised for its deep lore, emergent storytelling, and immersive environments. Exploration and faction involvement generate personal narratives, making the world feel alive and interconnected.
- The game's co-op and split-screen features are highly praised for making the experience more enjoyable and strategic. Playing with friends adds depth to survival, combat, and exploration, making challenges more manageable and fun.
Negatives:
- The game lacks tutorials or hand-holding, making the initial experience overwhelming for new players. Many report needing external guides or excessive trial-and-error to understand mechanics, leading to early frustration and potential quitting.
- Players consistently report that the combat feels mushy, unresponsive, and overly reliant on spam attacks rather than skill. Mechanics like hitboxes, animations, and enemy AI are criticized for being unintuitive and poorly implemented, leading to frustration.
- The game is described as punishing, with harsh consequences for mistakes (e.g., losing gear, enslavement, or permanent quest failure). Early-game difficulty spikes and lack of recovery options alienate casual or new players.
- Quests are criticized for being overly repetitive (e.g., fetch tasks), poorly explained, or timed without clear limits. Many feel the main story devolves into monotonous messenger quests with little depth or reward.
- The game world is described as large but hollow, with sparse content, bland NPCs, and few side quests or interactive elements. Players report feeling underwhelmed by the lack of depth in exploration or lore.
Gameplay:
- The game heavily features survival elements like hunger, thirst, temperature management, and crafting, which are repeatedly emphasized as central to gameplay. These mechanics are detailed and frequently cited as defining the experience.
- Combat is described as methodical and punishing, resembling Dark Souls with stamina management, dodging, and blocking. This system is a major point of discussion and often compared to other hardcore action RPGs.
- Character growth is tied to skill trees, magic systems, and item-based progression rather than levels. The magic system, in particular, is noted for its ritualistic and combination-based mechanics.
- Inventory and backpack mechanics, including weight limits and loot management, significantly impact gameplay. Players must strategize about what to carry and when to drop items.
- The game lacks traditional RPG conveniences like quest markers or hand-holding, requiring players to plan, take notes, and experiment to progress. This design choice is praised for its immersion.
Performance:
- The game suffers from optimization problems, requiring high-end hardware (e.g., GTX 1660) for stable performance on medium settings. This limits accessibility for players with lower-spec systems.
- Players report frequent desynchronization, lag, and disconnection problems in cooperative and online multiplayer modes, disrupting gameplay. These issues suggest network or server-side bugs that need addressing.
- Frequent crashes and save file corruption force players to restart the game or lose progress, severely impacting the experience. This is a critical stability issue.
- Players encounter bugs causing item loss or requiring backup saves to restore progress, such as the backpack bug. These issues disrupt gameplay and immersion.
- While some players report smooth performance on high settings, others note the game is optimized for low-end PCs with a 'potato mode.' This indicates inconsistent optimization.
Recommendations:
- The game is highly recommended for players who enjoy challenging, open-ended RPGs with survival mechanics, deep crafting, and immersive exploration. It appeals to fans of classic RPGs like Morrowind, Gothic, and Risen, as well as those who prefer unguided, systems-driven gameplay.
- The game is explicitly not recommended for casual players, those who dislike punishing mechanics, or those seeking fast-paced, guided, or easy gameplay. It requires patience, perseverance, and a willingness to learn complex systems.
- Combat is described as clunky but rewarding for players who invest time in learning mechanics, preparing gear, and using strategic planning. Armor with movement bonuses and spare equipment are often recommended.
- The gameâs survival elements (e.g., hunger, thirst, and resource management) are polarizing. Some players enjoy the added challenge, while others find them tedious or poorly implemented, detracting from the overall experience.
- The game is best enjoyed in co-op with a friend, as it can make the difficulty more manageable and add to the immersion. However, some players find co-op less enjoyable due to design flaws or repetitive mechanics, making solo play preferable for them.
Miscellaneous:
- Players are frustrated by the developers' practice of renaming editions to include DLCs, perceiving it as a tactic to force additional purchases. This has led to skepticism about future editions and pricing strategies.
- Players widely recommend using mods to address quality-of-life issues, suggesting that the base game lacks certain conveniences or optimizations. Mods are seen as essential for a smoother experience.
- Players frequently express a wish for future updates to include pack animals, which would enhance inventory management and gameplay logistics. This feature is seen as a valuable addition for long-term exploration.
- Players highlight the game's focus on discovery, wonder, and appreciation of its world, praising its ability to evoke a sense of exploration and immersion in an unknown environment.
- Some players have repurchased the game across different platforms (e.g., PS4, Steam) or gifted it to others, indicating strong loyalty and satisfaction with the core experience.
