- Memorable characters and exceptional voice acting
- Masterful quest design and impactful choices
- Exceptional story and immersive world-building
- Engaging and strategic combat system
- Timeless and highly replayable experience
- Some clunky combat and technical issues
Emotions
Players felt satisfied by the game's comprehensive high quality, including its engaging story, well-developed characters, immersive open world, and dynamic combat system. The extensive and varied side content, rewarding progression systems like Gwent, and excellent DLCs contributed to a lasting positive experience and high replayability, often leading to hundreds of hours of enjoyable gameplay.
Admiration stemmed from the game's status as a masterpiece and industry benchmark, praised for its stunning graphics, exceptional soundtrack, and profound narrative depth. Players lauded the intricate world-building, complex characters, and the impactful choices, often considering it one of the best RPGs or games of all time, showcasing CD Projekt Red's craftsmanship.
Excitement was generated by the game's gripping storyline, immersive world, and engaging gameplay that often hooked players from the start. The anticipation for discovering new content, challenging combat scenarios, and the prospect of future Witcher installments (especially Witcher 4) fueled a strong desire for continued engagement and replayability.
Frustration primarily arose from technical issues such as frequent crashes, poor optimization (especially with next-gen updates), and clunky controls for Geralt and Roach. Players also expressed annoyance with repetitive open-world tasks, inventory management, and certain combat mechanics, which sometimes hindered the overall experience.
Immersion was a key emotion, driven by the game's incredibly detailed and 'alive' open world, rich atmosphere, and emotional storytelling. Players felt deeply connected to the characters and the world, often forgetting reality and feeling personally involved in the narrative and consequential choices, making the experience feel like living an epic fantasy.
Verdict
Mostly positive
Summary
Positive 96% · Negative 4%. Score: 4 / 100
Positives:
- Players form deep emotional connections with the game's characters, from the complex protagonist Geralt to the richly developed main and secondary cast. The voice acting across multiple languages is consistently praised for bringing these personalities to life and enhancing immersion.
- The game is lauded for its incredibly well-written and diverse quests. Side quests, in particular, are frequently cited as surpassing main quests in other games, offering unique narratives, emotional depth, and often having significant consequences that enrich the overall experience.
- Players consistently praise the game's deep, emotional, and epic narrative, including both main and side quests. The world is described as vast, immersive, and meticulously detailed, with rich lore and a living atmosphere that encourages exploration and makes every location feel unique.
- Players emphasize the game's enduring quality, noting that it has aged exceptionally well, often surpassing newer titles. Its high replayability stems from impactful choices, diverse content, and the joy of rediscovering its rich world and stories, making it a game many return to repeatedly.
- A significant highlight is the game's system of meaningful choices and consequences. Players feel that their decisions, even in minor quests, genuinely impact the story, character fates, and the world, leading to morally complex dilemmas and high replayability.
Negatives:
- Many players found the combat system to be clunky, repetitive, and lacking depth, often devolving into simple dodge-and-attack patterns. Controls for Geralt and Roach were frequently criticized for being unresponsive, stiff, and leading to frustrating movement issues and accidental actions.
- The main story was often described as slow-paced, stretched out with filler, and less compelling than side quests. Dialogue was criticized for being excessive, sometimes unskippable, and lacking meaningful choices, leading to a disconnect from the plot and characters.
- A significant number of players reported frequent bugs, glitches, and crashes, even years after release and with next-gen updates. These issues ranged from minor visual hiccups to game-breaking problems that hindered quest progression and overall immersion.
- The open world, despite its size, often felt empty and unrewarding to explore, with many 'question mark' activities and side quests being repetitive fetch tasks. This led to a sense of tedium and burnout, especially for players attempting to clear the entire map.
- Players consistently found the inventory system to be messy, overloaded, and unintuitive. Managing a large number of items, finding specific notes, or organizing gear became a tedious and immersion-breaking chore.
Gameplay:
- The combat system is easy to learn but hard to master, combining swordplay, magic signs, and alchemy. Players can customize Geralt's abilities and equipment to suit various playstyles, from sword-focused to magic or alchemy builds, making each encounter strategic and engaging, especially on higher difficulties.
- The game offers a massive amount of content, with main story completion ranging from 40-100 hours and total completion (including side quests and DLCs) often exceeding 150-200 hours. Many players engage in multiple playthroughs due to the sheer volume of content, different difficulty settings, and impactful narrative choices.
- Player decisions throughout the game have significant and often unforeseen consequences, influencing character relationships, quest outcomes, and the overall ending of the story. This non-linear narrative encourages replayability to explore different paths and moral dilemmas.
- The game's side quests and Witcher contracts are exceptionally well-written, often rivaling main storylines in other games in terms of depth, emotional impact, and moral complexity. They are not mere filler but offer unique stories, character development, and meaningful rewards.
- The central narrative revolves around Geralt's urgent search for his adopted daughter, Ciri, who is pursued by the Wild Hunt. This quest is emotionally resonant, with player choices significantly impacting Ciri's destiny and the overall conclusion of the saga.
Performance:
- Player experiences with technical stability and bugs are varied. While many report a smooth, well-optimized experience with only minor visual glitches, others encountered serious issues like frequent crashes, game-breaking bugs, and performance degradation, especially after the next-gen update. Most minor issues are often resolved by updates or simple restarts.
- The game, particularly with next-gen updates and ray tracing, can be quite demanding on PC hardware. While it can run on mid-range systems with adjusted settings, achieving high frame rates and maxed-out graphics, especially with ray tracing, often requires a powerful CPU and GPU.
- The next-gen update significantly enhanced graphics with features like ray tracing, improved textures, and lighting, bringing the visuals closer to modern standards. However, this update also introduced performance issues and crashes for some players, with ray tracing being particularly demanding and sometimes offering only marginal visual improvements.
- Ray tracing, while visually enhancing, is a major source of performance drops and crashes, even on high-end GPUs. Many players recommend disabling it or switching to DirectX 11 for a more stable experience, indicating poor optimization for this specific feature.
- Roach, the player's horse, is occasionally subject to minor, often humorous, glitches such as teleporting into objects, freezing in odd positions, or appearing in unexpected locations.
Recommendations:
- Players overwhelmingly recommend this game, frequently calling it a masterpiece and one of the best RPGs or even games of all time. Many express a desire to erase their memory to experience it for the first time again, highlighting its profound impact and unforgettable nature.
- The game is consistently praised for its captivating story, deep narrative, complex characters, and richly detailed, immersive open world. Players often describe it as an 'interactive epic' or a 'world you live in,' emphasizing its ability to draw them in for hundreds of hours.
- The game's expansions, particularly 'Blood and Wine' and 'Hearts of Stone', are considered essential and are highly recommended. Many reviewers suggest purchasing the Complete Edition or Game of the Year Edition for the full experience, often noting the excellent value.
- Many players recommend playing on higher difficulties like 'Pain and Suffering' or 'Death March' for a more challenging and rewarding experience, especially for achievement hunters. They also advise taking time to explore and not rushing the main quest to fully appreciate the game's magic.
- Despite its high quality, many players advise waiting for a sale to purchase the game, especially the Complete Edition. They note that the game frequently goes on deep discounts, offering exceptional value for the vast amount of content.
Miscellaneous:
- Players consistently praise the game's meticulously crafted, vast, and immersive open world, filled with detailed environments, diverse locations, and a living ecosystem. The storytelling is highlighted as a masterpiece, with deep characters, mature themes, impactful choices, and side quests that often rival the main narrative in quality and emotional depth. This combination creates an unparalleled sense of adventure and immersion.
- Many players express profound emotional connections to the game, often replaying it multiple times over many years and wishing they could experience it for the first time again. The game's ability to draw players back, its long playtime (100+ hours for base game, 200+ for completionists), and its lasting impact on players' lives are frequently mentioned.
- Geralt of Rivia is lauded as a perfectly written protagonist—cynical yet empathetic, gruff yet loyal. His personal quest to find Ciri, intertwined with political intrigue and moral dilemmas, forms the emotional core of the game. Players connect deeply with Geralt and his relationships, often making choices based on his character, and many are introduced to the Witcher universe through his story.
- Many players are introduced to the Witcher universe through the game, which often inspires them to read Andrzej Sapkowski's original books. Conversely, some players come to the game after reading the books or watching the Netflix series, enhancing their understanding and emotional connection to the lore and characters.
- The romantic choices, particularly between Triss and Yennefer, are a significant and often difficult aspect for players. These relationships are deeply explored, with characters having distinct personalities and arcs, leading to varied emotional outcomes based on player decisions.
Similar games
Blend with other games
97%The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings Enhanced Edition
97%The Witcher: Enhanced Edition Director's Cut
95%Gothic® 3
94%Kingdoms of Amalur: Re-Reckoning
94%Kingdom Come: Deliverance II
94%Kingdom Come: Deliverance
94%Cyberpunk 2077
94%Avowed
93%Dragon's Dogma: Dark Arisen
93%Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
93%Fable - The Lost Chapters
93%Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon