- Significant improvements over predecessor
- Exceptional story and characters
- Player choices have major impact
- Clunky controls and UI
- Unbalanced, frustrating difficulty
- Frequent crashes and technical issues
Emotions
Players felt satisfied primarily due to the game's strong, captivating story, well-developed characters, and impactful choices. Significant improvements over the first game in terms of graphics, combat, and overall gameplay mechanics also contributed to a high level of enjoyment and replayability, often leading to a recommendation.
Frustration stemmed mainly from numerous technical issues such as bugs, crashes, and save loss, which often hindered progression. Players also struggled with clunky controls, an archaic or difficult combat system, and poor navigation/map design, especially when combined with high difficulty spikes or unfair boss mechanics.
Disappointment was frequently caused by the game's technical instability, including bugs, crashes, and optimization issues, which detracted from the overall experience. Players also expressed dissatisfaction with the clunky or outdated combat, perceived linearity, and a story that sometimes failed to meet expectations or felt too short, especially when compared to other Witcher titles.
Excitement was generated by the game's epic and engaging story, complex decisions with impactful choices, and significant graphical improvements over its predecessor. The high replayability due to branching paths and the anticipation for future installments, particularly The Witcher 3, also contributed to this emotion.
Players appreciated the game's crucial role in the Witcher series narrative, its influence on The Witcher 3, and its overall quality, especially considering its age. The strong, thoughtful plot, memorable characters, and significant improvements in graphics and gameplay over the first game were also highly valued.
Verdict
Mostly positive
Summary
Positive 77% · Negative 23%. Score: 23 / 100
Positives:
- The game is widely regarded as a massive leap forward from The Witcher 1 in almost every aspect, including graphics, combat, gameplay mechanics, stability, and overall polish. These improvements laid crucial groundwork for the success of The Witcher 3.
- Players consistently praise the game's narrative as epic, captivating, and rich with unexpected twists and complex moral choices. The characters are frequently highlighted as well-written, fascinating, and memorable, contributing significantly to the game's immersive and mature RPG experience.
- A standout feature is the game's branching narrative, where player decisions genuinely matter and lead to drastically different story paths, locations, characters, and multiple endings. This system of morally ambiguous choices significantly enhances replayability and immersion, making players feel the weight of their actions.
- The combat system, while initially challenging, becomes highly enjoyable and rewarding once mastered. It emphasizes strategic thinking, requiring players to utilize dodges, blocks, signs, traps, and alchemy, offering a more dynamic and technical experience compared to its predecessor and even, for some, its successor.
- Despite its age, the game's graphics are consistently praised for being beautiful, detailed, and holding up remarkably well. The art style, environmental design, and cinematic presentation contribute to a visually impressive and immersive world.
Negatives:
- Players consistently report that the game's controls, movement, and user interface are clunky, unresponsive, and unintuitive. This includes issues with character movement, interaction with objects, and menu navigation, making the overall gameplay experience feel like a chore.
- The game suffers from significant difficulty imbalances, with early game and boss fights often being excessively hard, even on lower settings. This is compounded by enemies acting as 'HP tanks' and a combat system that feels unfair, leading to frequent deaths and a lack of satisfaction.
- A major concern is the game's instability, characterized by frequent crashes to desktop, especially during saving, loading, or entering new areas. Many players also report compatibility issues with modern hardware and operating systems, making the game difficult or impossible to run without workarounds.
- Many players find the game's story to be too short, rushed, and overly focused on political intrigue rather than Geralt's personal journey or monster hunting. The world is perceived as linear and small, lacking the open-world freedom and exploration opportunities of other Witcher titles.
- The game's save system is a significant source of frustration, with frequent crashes occurring due to an accumulation of save files. Players often lose progress, and the system itself can cause performance issues, requiring constant manual management of save data.
Gameplay:
- The game features highly impactful branching story paths, primarily driven by a major choice in Chapter 1 to side with Roche or Iorveth. This decision drastically alters subsequent chapters, characters, locations, and quests, encouraging multiple playthroughs to experience the full narrative and different outcomes. Player choices have significant consequences throughout the game, leading to various endings.
- Playtime varies significantly, from 20-40 hours for a single story path to 60-100 hours for 100% completion, which often requires multiple playthroughs. The game's difficulty is highly customizable, ranging from very easy (story-focused) to extremely challenging (permadeath 'Insane' mode), with a common observation of an inverse difficulty curve where the beginning is harder than the end.
- The central plot revolves around Geralt of Rivia being framed for regicide and his quest to clear his name and recover lost memories. He becomes embroiled in complex political intrigues, conspiracies, and the hunt for the true kingslayer, navigating morally ambiguous choices.
- The combat system is a significant departure from the first game, adopting a more dynamic, action-oriented, and tactical approach. It requires preparation with potions, oils, and bombs, and involves dodging, blocking, strong/light attacks, and signs. While initially challenging, it becomes more fluid and enjoyable with practice, serving as a precursor to The Witcher 3's combat.
- The game features a semi-open world divided into distinct, moderately large chapters rather than a fully open map. While offering exploration within these areas, it is more linear than its successor, The Witcher 3, with limited ability to revisit previous chapters.
Performance:
- While the game can run on a wide range of modern PCs, including low-end systems and handhelds like the Steam Deck, some users still experience performance issues, including FPS drops and micro-freezes, especially with certain settings enabled. The game's older engine can be demanding.
- Ubersampling is a graphics setting that significantly degrades performance, even on high-end systems, making stable 60 FPS difficult to achieve. Disabling it is widely recommended for better frame rates.
- The game generally runs well on Steam Deck, with some users reporting excellent performance. However, initial setup may require adjusting settings in desktop mode or configuring controller inputs.
- Some modern CPUs with many cores/threads can cause launch issues, requiring users to disable specific cores or threads to get the game to run.
- Players report slow loading times, particularly for save/load screens and menus, which can worsen with a large number of save files or unlocked items. Deleting old save games can alleviate this issue.
Recommendations:
- Given its age, many reviewers suggest purchasing The Witcher 2 during sales, where it is often available at a very low price, making it an excellent value for its content.
- The Witcher 2 is widely praised as a deep, mature, and complex RPG with a strong plot, impactful choices, and a captivating atmosphere. It's considered a must-play for fans of narrative-driven dark fantasy and classic RPGs.
- Many players recommend The Witcher 2 as a crucial entry for understanding Geralt's full story and the lore before playing The Witcher 3. It's seen as a bridge between the first and third games, enhancing the overall saga experience.
- A significant number of players advise playing The Witcher 2 before The Witcher 3 to fully appreciate the story and character development, warning that playing the third game first might diminish the experience of the second due to dated mechanics.
- While acknowledged as a great game for its time, many reviews note that The Witcher 2's mechanics and graphics have aged. Players are advised to have patience and be willing to overlook these imperfections to enjoy the rich story.
Miscellaneous:
- Many players express a strong desire for CD Projekt Red to remake the entire Witcher trilogy, especially given the game's age and technical issues. There is also significant anticipation for the upcoming fourth Witcher game, particularly if it features Ciri.
- Released in 2011, the game's graphics and overall presentation show their age. While some players overlook this, many recommend using graphics mods, upscaling mods, and adjusting in-game settings like Bloom and SSAO to improve the visual experience.
- For players seeking alternative language options, fan-made patches are available, such as a comprehensive Simplified Chinese localization that includes font enlargement and corrections.
- The game features mature themes, including nudity and sex scenes, making it suitable for adult audiences. Its story is rich with complex political turmoil and extensive dialogue, adding depth and immersion, often compared to a season of 'Game of Thrones'.
- The central plot revolves around Geralt of Rivia being falsely accused of assassinating King Foltest of Temeria. The game follows his quest to clear his name and uncover the true culprit, while also dealing with his memory loss from the first game.
