Call of Cthulhu® Review Summary

Last updated: 2026-02-17
  • Engaging and intriguing story
  • Immersive atmosphere
  • Poor animations and graphics
  • Linear and monotonous experience
  • Poorly designed stealth sections
  • Uninspired and repetitive gameplay
Call of Cthulhu® header

Emotions

What players like:

Common complaints:

Gameplay feedback:

Performance notes:

Recommendations:

Other player notes:

  • -

    No data available

Review evidence

Why players say this

What players like

Engaging and intriguing story: The game features a compelling and well-rated story with interesting plot twists and engaging narrative. The story is fun, intriguing, and can captivate many players.

Immersive atmosphere: The game offers a carefully crafted and immersive atmosphere that contributes to the overall experience. The atmosphere is well put-together, disturbing, and eerie, enhancing the horror elements.

Enjoyable gameplay: The game provides enjoyable gameplay mechanics and an overall entertaining experience. It includes diverse gameplay elements such as stealth, chase, puzzle-solving, and shooting.

Fun and logical puzzles: The game features puzzles that are fun to solve and not too complicated. The puzzles are logical, satisfying, and add to the investigative gameplay.

Good adaptation and introduction: The game is a solid adaptation of Lovecraft's universe and serves as a good introduction to his works. It is recommended for fans and accessible to those unfamiliar with Lovecraft.

Common complaints

Poor animations and graphics: The game is criticized for its poor animations and outdated graphics. Character models and cutscenes are particularly noted for their low quality and awkwardness.

Linear and monotonous experience: The game is criticized for its linear gameplay and monotonous puzzles. Players find the overall experience boring and uninteresting due to its lack of non-linearity and weak puzzle design.

Poorly designed stealth sections: Stealth sections are described as confusing, tedious, and poorly designed. Players find them frustrating, unnecessary, and poorly implemented with inconsistent AI.

Uninspired and repetitive gameplay: The gameplay is described as limited, uninspired, and repetitive. Players find it tedious, boring, and lacking in variety and innovation. The RPG elements are also criticized for being poorly implemented.

Slow pacing and underwhelming ending: The game is criticized for its slow pacing, particularly at the start, and an underwhelming ending. Players find the overall pace to be either too slow or too hectic, leading to a lack of action.

Gameplay and performance

RPG and skill progression: The game features RPG elements with a progression system, skill point allocation, and a skill tree that affects story outcomes.

Investigative and narrative-driven gameplay: The game focuses on investigation, dialogue, and interaction with clues and characters. It is a story-driven experience with a slow pace, emphasizing detective work and choices.

Linear and choice-based narrative: The game offers a linear narrative with choice-based gameplay, focusing on story and decisions.

Exploration and interaction: Gameplay involves exploring environments, interacting with objects, and engaging in dialogues.

Detective and RPG hybrid: The game combines detective gameplay with RPG elements, including investigations and character development.

Dated graphics quality: The graphics quality is considered poor and dated by many players. This includes issues with graphical quality in cutscenes and general visual appearance.

Compatibility issues with newer CPUs: The game crashes frequently on newer CPUs, particularly Intel 10th generation processors or newer, indicating compatibility issues with modern hardware.

Compatibility issues with Windows 11: The game has compatibility issues with the current version of Windows 11, leading to crashes and improper functioning.

Optimization issues: The game has optimization issues, with some players reporting poor optimization while others find it well-optimized. This indicates mixed experiences regarding performance.

Visual and graphical bugs: Players report visual stuttering and various graphical bugs, affecting the overall visual experience of the game.

Recommendations

Recommended for Lovecraft fans: The game is highly recommended for fans of H.P. Lovecraft's work, the Cthulhu mythos, and Lovecraftian themes. It is seen as a good investment for those who enjoy psychological horror and the Lovecraftian universe.

Worth buying on sale: The game is considered worth buying, especially when it is on sale. Many players suggest waiting for a sale to purchase the game.

Comparisons to other games: The game is compared to other titles like 'The Sinking City' and Telltale adventure games. Some players recommend trying out 'Gloomwood' or playing 'The Sinking City' and 'Dark Corners of the Earth' instead.

General recommendations: The game is recommended by many players, especially to those who haven't played it yet. It is highly recommendable and worth considering if it is on sale.

Recommended for mystery and RPG fans: The game is suggested for fans of mystery, RPG, choices, and Lovecraftian themes. It is also recommended for those looking for an easy-to-pick-up mystery horror game and those who value detective work and horror elements.

Platform notes

Steam Deck: The game experiences significant issues with frequent crashes and network connectivity problems on the Steam Deck. However, many users also report a positive experience with good performance and controller support. The graphical quality is noted to be dated by some users.

Extra review signals

External guides: The game suffers from significant technical issues, including bugs that disrupt gameplay and require external fixes. The overall gameplay experience is considered mediocre and not particularly challenging. Additionally, there is a notable dependency on walkthroughs to complete the game, indicating that players often need external guides to progress.