Medieval Crafter: Blacksmith Review Summary

Enjoyable and relaxing gameplay: Many players find the game enjoyable, relaxing, and fun. The gameplay is smooth and engaging, making it suitable for casual play.

Comprehensive blacksmithing simulation: The game offers a detailed and enjoyable blacksmithing experience. Players appreciate the depth and realism of the blacksmithing mechanics.

Satisfying crafting and mining mechanics: The crafting and mining mechanics are well-received, providing a satisfying and enjoyable experience for players.

Promising game with potential: The game shows great potential and has a promising concept, with players looking forward to future updates.

Immersive sound and visual effects: The game features fantastic sound design and detailed visual effects, enhancing the overall immersive experience.

Blacksmithing system issues: The blacksmithing system is criticized for being shallow and not challenging. Players find it more profitable to sell raw ores rather than crafting equipment, making the crafting process feel redundant and tedious.

Repetitive and grindy gameplay: Gameplay is criticized for being repetitive and grindy. Players find the tasks monotonous and the grinding unsatisfying.

No autosave feature: The game lacks an autosave feature, leading to lost progress. Players report that manual saving is required and that actions like sleeping do not save the game.

Rough around the edges: The game is described as having technical rough edges, likely due to its early access status. Players note that it feels less polished and unfinished.

Poor graphics quality: The game's graphics are described as crude, outdated, and misleading. Players report issues with text visibility and overall poor graphics quality.

Comprehensive Blacksmithing Simulation: The game features a detailed blacksmithing simulation, including first-person blacksmithing, managing a blacksmith shop, and various blacksmithing mini-games. Players can enjoy the blacksmithing process and crafting system in a fantasy setting.

Mining and Resource Gathering: Players can mine for minerals, explore, and gather resources. This includes entering mines at night to mine ore and melt it in the furnace, as well as managing mining assistants and refining resources.

Quest and Adventure Mechanics: The game includes quest-giving mechanics, adventure mechanics, and a quest rewards system. Players can complete quests and send adventurers on missions.

Engaging Gameplay Mechanics: The gameplay is noted for its depth, replayability, and enjoyment. However, some players find the gameplay duration and content repetitive.

Character Progression and Leveling: The game features a level progression system, including a hero leveling system, character progression, and an XP system for player leveling.

Performance and Optimization Problems: Frequent complaints about FPS drops, frame drops, lack of optimization, and performance issues, especially on higher settings. Some players also mention constant stress on the processor and graphics card.

Graphics and Visual Issues: Players report various graphics-related problems, including disappearing graphics, poor graphics quality, and specific issues like holes in the world and texture problems.

Game Crashes and Save Issues: The game crashes frequently, leading to data loss. There are also issues with save files not loading or saving properly, causing progress loss.

Various Bugs and Glitches: Players encounter numerous bugs and glitches, including wall clipping, issues with the Anvil, and errors preventing gameplay.

Settings and Configuration Problems: Some players face issues with graphical settings not saving and difficulties in setting the game to windowed mode.

Recommended for crafting and medieval fans: The game is highly recommended for players who enjoy crafting, resource management, and medieval-themed simulation games.

Buy during sale or post-early access: Players suggest purchasing the game during a sale or waiting until after the early access period if it is not on sale.

Praised for graphics, gameplay, and audio: The game is recommended for its high-quality graphics, engaging gameplay, and excellent audio.

Good change from regular shop management: The game offers a refreshing change for those tired of typical shop management games, providing a different experience.

Best simulator with active gameplay: Considered the best simulator game on the market for those who want more active participation rather than just passive watching.

Community fair range: $10.00 - $15.00.

Game completion: 10.0h.

Story completion: 8.0h.

Session length: 2.0h.

Players generally find the game fun and engaging from the start, particularly enjoying the crafting mechanics and sending heroes on quests. The tutorial helps ease players into the game quickly.

Reported time to anchor: 30m.

Friction: Repetitive tasks; Grinding; Lack of tool upgrades.

Chill Crafter: Casual and laid-back crafting and management. Motivation: Relaxation and casual gameplay. Stance: sale.

Achievement Grinder: Intensive grinding and repetitive tasks. Motivation: Completing achievements and progressing through the game. Stance: deep sale.

Fantasy Craft Manager: Strategic crafting and resource management. Motivation: Enjoyment of crafting and management mechanics. Stance: buy.

Steam Deck: The Steam Deck experience is marred by stability and performance issues. Users frequently encounter glitches, poor controls, frame drops, and freezing, which detract from the overall gaming experience. These technical barriers suggest that the game requires significant improvements to ensure a seamless experience on the Steam Deck.

Character dialogue inconsistencies: Players report mismatches between character dialogue text and their displayed facial expressions or portraits, causing confusion and immersion-breaking experiences.

Lack of weapon information: Players find it difficult to determine which weapons are suitable for their adventurers due to insufficient in-game information.

Unclear house design: The house design is criticized for being unclear, as it appears to be a hybrid between a shop and a house, which can be confusing for players.

NPC spawning and AI issues: There are reported issues with NPC spawning and their AI behavior, which can disrupt gameplay and immersion.

Manual saving required: The game requires manual saving, which some players find inconvenient and outdated compared to modern auto-saving features.