The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall Review Summary

Last updated: 2026-05-07
  • Daggerfall Unity enhances overall gaming experience.
  • Engaging gameplay with massive open world.
  • Deep character customization and strong modding community.
  • Controls are difficult and dated.
  • Dungeons are frustrating, tedious and repetitive.
  • Original game is clunky, buggy and unstable.
The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall header

Emotions

Archetypes

What players like:

Common complaints:

Gameplay feedback:

Performance notes:

Recommendations:

Other player notes:

Review evidence

Why players say this

What players like

Daggerfall Unity enhances experience: Daggerfall Unity is frequently praised for modernizing the game, providing stability, mod support, and quality-of-life improvements. It is highly recommended for both new and experienced players.

Engaging and fun gameplay: The gameplay is described as rewarding, engaging, and fun. Players enjoy the game's design, soundtrack, and replay value.

Massive open world: The game features an enormous open world with vast wilderness, procedurally generated cities, and dungeons, offering players total freedom and immersion.

Highly regarded RPG: The game is often cited as one of the best RPGs ever created, offering a traditional and in-depth role-playing experience.

Deep character customization: The game offers a detailed and in-depth character creation system, allowing for a wide array of customizable character appearances and classes.

Common complaints

Controls are difficult and dated: Many players find the controls hard to learn, unconventional, and clunky. The control scheme is often described as difficult to master and frustrating, which can make the game challenging to play.

Dungeons are frustrating and tedious: Dungeons are frequently criticized for being confusing, repetitive, and unnecessarily long. Players find them tedious and disorienting, which can lead to frustration.

Original game is clunky and buggy: The original version of the game is often described as clunky, janky, and buggy. Players report that it feels broken and poorly optimized without external patches.

Quests are repetitive and boring: Quests and side quests are often described as monotonous, dull, and repetitive. This can make the gameplay feel tedious and unengaging.

Game is frustrating and unforgiving: The gameplay is described as challenging, unforgiving, and frustrating. Players find it difficult and not very forgiving.

Gameplay and performance

Open-world gameplay: The game offers a vast open world with freedom to explore and interact with various elements. The world is described as massive and immersive.

Extensive character customization: Players can customize their characters in great detail, including choosing race, class, stats, skills, and special strengths/weaknesses. This deep customization affects gameplay significantly.

Complex and varied dungeons: The game features large, maze-like dungeons that are procedurally generated, offering a variety of challenges and complex layouts. Players appreciate the intricate designs and the unpredictability of these dungeons.

Quest variety and complexity: The game offers a variety of quests, including time-sensitive quests and complex plotlines. However, some quests can be repetitive or templated.

Procedurally generated content: The game includes procedurally generated quests, dungeons, towns, and a large world. This feature enhances replayability and exploration.

Daggerfall Unity improves performance: Daggerfall Unity enhances the game's performance, making it run smoothly on modern systems and devices. It is often recommended for better gameplay experience and stability.

Frequent crashes and bugs: The game is reported to crash often and contains numerous bugs, affecting gameplay stability. These issues are prevalent in both the original and Unity versions.

Original version is unstable: The original DOS version of the game is noted for its instability and numerous bugs, making it difficult to play without issues.

Outdated and problematic graphics: The game's graphics are considered outdated and of low quality, which can detract from the overall experience. Some reviews mention that the graphics can be visually unappealing.

Game may not launch: Some users report issues with the game not launching at all, which can be a significant barrier to playing.

Recommendations

Daggerfall Unity recommended: Many players recommend using Daggerfall Unity for a better and more stable experience, often suggesting specific mods to enhance gameplay. This version is praised for its modern controls, quality-of-life improvements, and mod support.

Mods enhance experience: Players suggest using various mods to improve the gaming experience, including specific mods like DREAM, Enhanced Sky, and others. Mods are recommended for better graphics, immersion, and overall gameplay.

Game recommended despite flaws: Many players recommend the game for its rich and immersive experience, despite some flaws. It is often suggested to try the game for its historical value and unique gameplay.

Recommended for hardcore fans: The game is highly recommended for hardcore classic CRPG fans and those who enjoy old-school RPGs. It is suggested for players who appreciate the Elder Scrolls series and retro gaming.

Specific gameplay tips: Various gameplay tips are provided, such as rebinding controls, avoiding certain enemies, and using console commands. These tips aim to improve the gameplay experience and help players navigate the game more effectively.

Buying context

Community fair range: $10.00 - $20.00.

Game completion: 100.0h.

Story completion: 40.0h.

Session length: 3.0h.

The game initially hooks players but becomes tedious due to its complexity and repetitive tasks. Fun starts after overcoming the steep learning curve and initial tutorial dungeon.

Reported time to anchor: 3h.

Friction: Complex controls and UI; Repetitive quests; Overwhelming amount of content; Steep learning curve.

Player profiles

Hardcore RPG Enthusiast: Deep exploration, character customization, and engaging with complex game systems. Motivation: Mastery of complex game mechanics and immersive roleplaying. Stance: buy.

Elder Scrolls Historian: Exploratory, with a focus on understanding the lore and history of the game world. Motivation: Exploring the roots and evolution of the Elder Scrolls series. Stance: sale.

Retro Gaming Nostalgic: Adaptive, focusing on the enjoyment of retro mechanics and aesthetics. Motivation: Nostalgia and appreciation for classic gaming experiences. Stance: deep sale.

Platform notes

Steam Deck: The analysis of user feedback for the Steam Deck experience reveals several key themes. Control issues are a significant concern, with many users finding the controls outdated and difficult to use. Graphics quality is also a notable issue, as the visuals are considered outdated even for the time of the game's release. On a positive note, the game is reported to work well with the Unity conversion and supports mods, which enhances flexibility and ease of play. However, the need to install additional software like Unity to improve controls adds an extra step that users must take. Overall, while there are some positive aspects, the control and graphics issues present notable barriers to a seamless gaming experience.

Extra review signals

Mod reliance: The analysis of user feedback indicates that while many users recommend various mods for graphical enhancements, gameplay modernization, and quality of life improvements, there is no widespread consensus on the game being unplayable without these mods. The most significant reliance is on Daggerfall Unity, which is seen as a major upgrade that fixes many issues and enables further modding.

External guides: The user feedback highlights significant issues with bugs and technical problems, a steep learning curve, and a heavy reliance on external resources like wikis and guides. These factors contribute to a challenging and often frustrating user experience.

Other review notes

Fraudulent credit issues: There are mentions of credit fraud associated with the game, which could be a significant concern for potential buyers.

Modify default controls: Players recommend changing the default control configuration, particularly for adjusting the mouse settings to 'view' for better gameplay.

Language requirement for players: Players emphasize the necessity of speaking English to fully understand and enjoy the game.

Scaling or flying over walls: A tip provided by players about scaling or flying over city walls at night, likely as a strategy or exploit.

Use fast travel: Suggestion to use player-controlled fast travel, which can enhance the gaming experience by reducing travel time.