- Excellent multiplayer with friends, core social deduction
- Unique Western theme, engaging outlaw role
- Limited content, poor value for money
- Low player count, dead servers reported
- Frequent bugs and performance issues
- Role imbalance and unfairness issues
Emotions
Players frequently experience frustration due to a range of technical issues including game-breaking bugs, frequent crashes, poor performance (low framerate, lag), and persistent connection problems. Additionally, frustration stems from poor game design elements such as imbalanced gameplay, inconvenient interfaces, unplayable tutorials, and particularly, the inability to find matches or other players due to low player counts and long queue times. The presence of cheaters and a lack of reporting options also significantly contribute to player frustration.
Satisfaction primarily arises from the game's social aspects, with players highly enjoying playing with friends and the overall social experience. The game's concept, fun gameplay, and unique matches also contribute to satisfaction. Players appreciate good value for money, the absence of bugs, and customization options, leading to a positive overall experience.
Disappointment is largely driven by the game's technical state and low player count, which often prevents players from finding matches or enjoying the multiplayer experience. Poor game quality, including boring or repetitive gameplay, bad controls, and flawed execution, also leads to disappointment. Microtransactions and the perception of wasted money further contribute to this emotion, especially when the game's fun is short-lived or friends dislike it.
Joy is almost exclusively tied to the social experience of playing the game with friends. Players find immense enjoyment and laughter when engaging in multiplayer sessions, particularly with voice chat. The core gameplay experience itself, when shared, also contributes to this positive emotion.
Excitement is generated by intense matches, the game's cool concept, and the tension inherent in its detective and social deduction mechanics. Playing with friends amplifies this excitement, leading to competitive 'rage' and hilarious scenarios. The potential of the game and the unique tricks available to outlaws also contribute to an exciting gameplay experience.
Verdict
Mixed
Summary
Positive 59% · Negative 41%. Score: 41 / 100
Positives:
- The game is highly praised for its multiplayer experience, especially when played with friends. It consistently delivers fun, laughter, and engaging moments, making it an ideal party game.
- The game offers a unique take on the social deduction genre, requiring players to pay close attention to details and deduce or deceive. It provides distinct challenges and rewards for both the Sheriff and Outlaw roles, enhancing cognitive skills.
- The game features smooth, responsive controls and balanced gameplay across various modes, including intense 1v1 and strategic 2v2 matches. Its fast-paced, skill-based nature contributes to a highly engaging experience.
- Playing as the Outlaw is frequently cited as more enjoyable due to the tension and unique abilities that allow for creative deception. Both roles offer distinct and engaging experiences.
- The inclusion of AI bots for offline play and various settings to balance matches is appreciated. Players suggest expanding bot support to more modes for a better single-player experience.
Negatives:
- Many players feel the game offers insufficient content for its price, leading to quick boredom and a sense of wasted money. The gameplay loop is perceived as repetitive, and the overall experience lacks depth, especially for solo players.
- A significant issue is the extremely low player count, making it difficult to find matches and leading to a 'dead game' feeling. This severely impacts the multiplayer experience, forcing players to rely on bots or large friend groups.
- Players report numerous technical issues, including frequent crashes, disconnections, severe lag, and inconsistent frame rates. These bugs significantly hinder gameplay and make the game unplayable for some.
- There are concerns about game balance, particularly regarding the Sheriff and Outlaw roles. Some players feel the Sheriff is underpowered or has difficulty identifying Outlaws, while others find the Outlaw role too strong or too weak depending on the situation.
- The game has a steep learning curve, making it challenging for new players to understand mechanics and roles. The UI is also noted as needing improvements for better clarity.
Gameplay:
- The core gameplay loop involves Sheriffs identifying Bandits disguised as NPCs by observing their behavior and task completion, while Bandits aim to complete objectives without being caught. Hints are provided via mailboxes, but Sheriffs must be careful not to shoot innocents.
- The game is a social deduction title set in a pixel-art Wild West environment. It is frequently compared to games like Among Us and Spy Party due to its deception and hidden role mechanics.
- Player feedback on difficulty is mixed, with some finding it easy and others very hard. There's a suggestion that the Sheriff role needs balancing or the Outlaw role needs more downsides.
- The game supports various player counts, with suggestions that it plays better with 4 or more players. There's also a mention of a 3v3 mode and its potential for chaos.
- A critical loss condition for Sheriffs is shooting an innocent NPC, leading to their elimination. Bandits lose if they are shot by a Sheriff.
Performance:
- There is conflicting feedback regarding game performance. Some players report poor optimization and server issues, while others state the game runs well even on low-end systems. This suggests performance may be inconsistent or dependent on specific hardware/server conditions.
Recommendations:
- The game is highly recommended when played with a group of friends, especially for social or party-oriented gameplay. Solo play is generally not advised, as the experience is significantly diminished without a pre-made group.
- Despite mixed feedback, a notable portion of players highly recommend the game, often giving it perfect scores and considering it a fair purchase. This suggests a strong positive experience for some, particularly those who find its niche appealing.
- Players who enjoy deduction games, social deception, or party games similar to Among Us or Town of Salem will likely find this game appealing. It offers a casual, fun experience without being overly competitive.
Miscellaneous:
- Players are eager for more content, including new maps, characters, and game modes, to enhance replayability and extend the game's longevity. There's a strong desire for continued development and updates to address current limitations and expand the core experience, with some hoping for a sequel to improve on these aspects.
- Players have specific suggestions for new game mechanics, quality-of-life improvements, and balance adjustments. These include ideas for new game modes, changes to sheriff visibility, and adjustments to notification systems, indicating a desire for deeper and more refined gameplay.
- Players frequently mention the need for a larger player base to improve matchmaking and overall game experience. The game is seen as more enjoyable when played with friends, highlighting a potential reliance on social play and the need for better player retention.
- Players are looking for improvements in game balance and the overall game experience. There's also a suggestion to incorporate AI into queues for tasks, which could help with player population issues or provide more dynamic gameplay.
- Feedback on technical aspects is limited but positive regarding bugs. There are mentions of beta features like lobby joining and specific server connection methods, along with a note about potential copyright issues with in-game ambience.
