Order of the Sinking Star Review Summary

Last updated: 2026-11-06
  • Creative and clever puzzle design
  • Unique and varied puzzle mechanics
  • Interlocking mechanics create aha moments
  • Poor visual clarity and grid readability
  • Timing elements feel out of place
  • Overworld navigation needs improvement
Order of the Sinking Star header

Emotions

Archetypes

Hardware

Windows 8-11GB VRAMpositiveWindows <8GB VRAM / <16GB RAMmixed

What players like:

Common complaints:

Gameplay feedback:

Performance notes:

Recommendations:

Other player notes:

Review evidence

Why players say this

Steam review verdict

Clever, varied, interlocking puzzles deliver satisfying aha moments, but poor visual clarity, misplaced timing elements, and clunky overworld navigation hold it back.

What players like

Best puzzle game ever: Many reviewers praise it as the greatest puzzle game they have played, often calling it a masterpiece and GOTY for puzzle enthusiasts. The consensus highlights exceptional design and overall quality.

Creative and clever design: Reviewers repeatedly highlight the creativity and cleverness of the puzzle design, with many calling it brilliant, ingenious, and expertly crafted. The puzzles are often noted as devious but fair.

Unique and varied puzzles: Each puzzle often introduces its own unique idea or trick, and there is a wide variety of mechanics and interactions. This uniqueness keeps the experience fresh and interesting.

Standout Sokoban game: It is frequently praised as one of the best Sokoban-style games ever made, setting a high bar for future games in the genre. The gimmick-driven design and completeness are highlighted.

Well-balanced difficulty curve: The difficulty progression is generally described as smooth and well-paced, starting easy and gradually increasing. This makes the game accessible yet challenging.

Common complaints

Poor visual clarity and grid readability: Many reviewers struggle to distinguish grid cells, paths, and interactive elements due to overly decorative art, fixed camera angles, and similar-colored tiles. This causes wasted time, missteps, and frustration even before solving puzzles.

Timing and action elements feel out of place: Real-time and timing-based puzzles, especially in the Skipping Stones sections, are widely criticized for being unfair in a turn-based puzzle game. Controls are not suited for precise timing, and slow-motion does little to alleviate frustration.

Overworld navigation and mapping issues: The main world map lacks features like dragging, zooming, and clear indicators for unsolved puzzles, making it hard to find objectives. Fast travel can be slower than walking, and players often get lost or waste time on inaccessible areas.

Story confusing and poorly delivered: Many reviewers find the narrative cryptic, vague, and hard to follow, with key information scattered across voice logs that are easy to miss or forget. The story often feels unfinished or disconnected from the puzzle gameplay.

Controls feel clunky and unresponsive: Movement and input handling are criticized for being sluggish, with input lag, overshooting, and poor feedback. Character switching is cumbersome, and keyboard controls are less convenient than a controller.

Gameplay and performance

Interlocking mechanics create aha moments: Players praise how different mechanics interact and combine to produce satisfying 'aha' discoveries, often requiring experimentation and lateral thinking.

Hundreds of distinct puzzle ideas: The game introduces many unique concepts and mechanics, ensuring that puzzles feel fresh and varied throughout the experience.

Large open world with themed regions: The game features a large open structure with multiple themed worlds and branching paths, allowing non-linear exploration.

Multiple characters with unique abilities: Playable characters each have distinct powers and rules, often combined within puzzles to create complex interactions.

Sokoban-style box-pushing foundation: The core game is repeatedly described as a Sokoban-like puzzle experience centered on pushing boxes, often expanded with additional mechanics and open structures.

High GPU and resource demand: Multiple reviewers report the visuals are pretty but expensive, with GPU usage maxing out and performance cost being extremely high. Some note the game is more demanding than expected for a puzzle game.

Fast startup and loading: Startup and loading are very fast, with the game booting in under a minute and skipping the menu straight into the puzzle. Fast travel on the map has zero load times.

Frame drops with dragon effects: Dragon breath particle effects cause noticeable frame drops in specific scenes, including one level dipping to 60fps and low-end devices falling below 20 FPS.

Minor optimization and glitches: Minor optimization issues cause occasional frame drops, and a few minor graphical glitches were encountered. Rendering issues with effects and lighting are also reported.

Performance improved since demo: One reviewer notes that performance improved from the demo. The game can be locked to 120fps on a high-end PC and runs great overall.

Recommendations

Ideal for puzzle enthusiasts: The vast majority of reviewers strongly recommend the game to anyone who enjoys puzzle games, with many calling it a must-play for genre fans.

Simply a must-buy: Many reviewers give unconditional buy recommendations, calling it a no-brainer purchase or a game you should definitely buy.

Great for Sokoban fans: Reviewers highlight that the game is essentially a Sokoban-style puzzler and strongly recommend it to anyone who enjoys block-pushing puzzles.

Considered a masterpiece or GOTY: Multiple reviewers enthusiastically call the game a masterpiece, their game of the year, or even the best puzzle game ever made.

Worth the time and money: Reviewers affirm that the game is worth playing and worth the investment, with some giving it a perfect score.

Buying context

Community fair range: $20.00 - $30.00.

Game completion: 100.0h.

Story completion: 37.0h.

Session length: 4.0h.

Endgame: 80.0h.

A slow-burn puzzle experience: early scope, difficulty, and tutorial-light design can delay the hook, but enjoyment rises once mechanics click and begin combining. Some players report smooth, tutorial-free absorption sooner, so the profile is mixed.

Friction: Slow-burn opening that can deter players seeking immediate payoff; Main hook takes time to get going; Early puzzles feel daunting; Tutorial-light or uneven explanations; early solution lookups; Huge scope and many mechanics can feel like an extended tutorial.

Player profiles

Sokoban Puzzle Veteran: Long focused sessions, deep mechanic experimentation, and seeking out harder overworld and meta puzzles. Motivation: To solve a large volume of challenging, interconnected puzzles and experience repeated eureka moments. Stance: buy.

Jonathan Blow Auteur Devotee: Attentive, design-literate play that values meta structure, philosophical themes, and hand-crafted puzzle logic. Motivation: To support Jonathan Blow and Thekla and experience their authored design philosophy and craftsmanship. Stance: buy.

Casual Brain-Teaser Player: Short sessions, following gentle onboarding, and avoiding extreme puzzle difficulty. Motivation: Relaxed brain exercise and accessible puzzle solving without hardcore pressure. Stance: sale.

Platform notes

Across the six largest Windows cohorts, the 16GB+ VRAM group is consistently positive, while lower-VRAM and mid-range configurations are mixed: playable on many systems but with recurring frame drops, stutter in overview views, and optimization complaints.

Windows 8-11GB VRAM: positive. Most reports are positive, with smooth high-frame-rate play at 1440p and good optimization, though one user reported repeated crashes after the intro.

Windows <8GB VRAM / <16GB RAM: mixed. Several low-end systems run the game acceptably, but other users report high GPU load, frame drops in the overworld and specific puzzle sections, and optimization issues.

Windows 12-15GB VRAM / 16-31GB RAM: mixed. Some users get around 90 fps, but others report low frame rates, poor AMD optimization, GPU usage spikes, and coil whine at quality settings.

Steam Deck: The Steam Deck experience is broadly playable but not fully seamless. Most reviews praise smooth handheld performance, fast startup, and good visuals, yet a recurring cluster reports overworld and map-view frame drops, occasional crashes, one save-file loss on Deck, missing fullscreen behavior in desktop mode, and some need to force specific Proton builds. No external launcher or anti-cheat barrier is evident, and small-text complaints are not present in the evidence. The appropriate classification is Tinkering Required rather than Broken.

Linux and Proton: The Linux/Proton feedback is predominantly positive. Users on Fedora, Pop!_OS, CachyOS, Void Linux, and Steam Deck report successful launches and strong performance, including 4K 120 FPS on suitable hardware. A minority mention needing a specific Proton version such as Proton 10.4 or GE-Proton 10-34, and some describe past Linux/Proton crashes that were fixed by updates. Overall, the game works well on Linux with minor Proton-version adjustments and some low-end hardware performance tuning.

Extra review signals

External guides: The dataset is dominated by a puzzle game's guide and walkthrough discourse. Reviewers complain that unnamed levels are hard to search, in-game guidance is weak, and mechanics can appear without explanation, all of which create dependence on external instructional content. Positive comments also center on learning through play and avoiding walkthroughs. There is no substantive farming, inventory/crafting, or navigation/bug-fix dependency, so the strict hierarchy places the dataset at Tier 3.

Other review notes

Frequent Witness comparisons: Reviewers constantly compare the game to The Witness, noting similarities in pacing, design, and puzzle structure, often favorably.

Vast scope and size: The game is described as massive, sprawling, and endless, with a huge amount of content and secrets.

Created by Jonathan Blow: The game is made by Jonathan Blow, the creator of Braid and The Witness, and is often described as his magnum opus.

Ten-year development cycle: The game reportedly took ten years to develop, a fact frequently mentioned in reviews.

Over 100 hours of content: Many reviewers note over 100 hours of playtime, with some spending 150 hours for full completion.