Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter Review Summary

Enjoyable deduction system: The deduction mechanics are well-thought-out and make sense, providing an enjoyable challenge for players. The game features various deduction cases that require thoughtful analysis.

Engaging and varied puzzles: The game offers a range of puzzles that vary in complexity, from simple to challenging. Players appreciate the ability to skip puzzles if they find them too difficult or uninteresting.

Compelling storytelling: The game's story is engaging and well-told, with unexpected twists that keep players interested. The narrative is satisfying and holds together well.

Atmospheric Victorian London setting: The game successfully recreates the atmosphere of Victorian London, with detailed graphics and a richly atmospheric environment that immerses players in the setting.

Moral choices and detective experience: The game offers a satisfying detective experience with moral choices that challenge players to think about the consequences of their decisions. It is recommended for fans of detective games and those who enjoy solving cases.

Poorly designed puzzles: The puzzles in the game are inconsistent, some are too simple while others are overly complex. They are often seen as boring, illogical, and repetitive, relying too much on trial and error.

Weak and short cases: The cases in the game are described as weak, short, and not thought-provoking. They lack the quality and depth of previous games in the series, and some cases have vague or open-ended resolutions.

Clunky and poor controls: The game suffers from clunky, awkward, and non-intuitive controls that are difficult and uncomfortable to use. This makes the gameplay feel outdated and unsatisfactory.

Illogical plot and inconsistencies: The game's plot is criticized for being illogical and having inconsistencies. Characters often do not act logically, and there are issues with story coherence and character relationships.

Unnecessary action sequences: The game includes long, annoying, and unnecessary action sequences that are often unskippable. These sequences are seen as irritating and unsatisfactory.

Diverse puzzle-solving mechanics: The game offers a wide range of puzzles, from simple to complex, including mini-games and brain-teasing challenges. Players can enjoy a variety of activities such as investigations, interrogations, stealth, and action sequences.

Comprehensive clue investigation: Players are tasked with examining people and environments for clues, analyzing them, and using deductive mechanics to form conclusions. This involves careful observation and interaction with the environment.

Quick Time Events (QTEs): The game includes action-oriented gameplay with QTEs and unique challenges. These sequences are used for immersion and include mini-games and action sequences.

Engaging case investigations: The game features a variety of interesting cases with intrigue, each with a determined culprit and clear evidence. Players can investigate unusual crime scenes and enjoy a case-based structure.

Moral choices and consequences: Players can make moral decisions that affect case outcomes and narrative. The game features moral ambiguity and choices that matter in resolving cases.

Poor optimization and FPS issues: Players report low FPS, poor optimization, and framerate issues, indicating that the game does not run smoothly on many systems.

Graphics and technical issues: There are various graphics optimization issues and technical problems with graphics and controls, affecting the visual experience.

Frequent game crashes: The game often crashes or closes randomly, which disrupts the gameplay experience significantly.

Occasional stuttering: Players experience occasional stuttering and FPS drops, which can be severe at times and affect gameplay smoothness.

Positive feedback on performance: Some players report that the game plays very well, looks, and sounds good, indicating a positive experience.

Buy on sale: Many reviews suggest purchasing the game during a sale or discount period to get the best value for money. This is a common recommendation across multiple clusters.

Recommended for detective and mystery fans: The game is highly recommended for fans of detective stories, mystery lovers, and those who enjoy solving crimes. It is particularly suggested for Sherlock Holmes fans and those who enjoy detective fiction.

Recommended for specific audiences: The game is recommended for various specific audiences, including adventure fans, open-world game fans, those interested in Victorian England, and fans of the series by Frogwares.

Recommended with reservations: Some reviews recommend the game despite some issues or with certain reservations. It is suggested to know what you're getting into before purchasing.

Engaging storylines and gameplay: The game features engaging storylines and introduces new action and stealth gameplay elements. It also has well-designed environments that enhance the overall experience.

Community fair range: $3.70 - $12.00.

Game completion: 12.0h.

Story completion: 10.0h.

Session length: 4.5h.

The game offers immediate fun with the option to skip tedious elements, but the enjoyment may decrease as players progress through the cases due to frustrating puzzles and controls.

Reported time to anchor: 1h.

Friction: Tedious puzzles; Stiff controls; Repetitive gameplay elements.

Guided Beginner: Prefers games with clear instructions and assistance features. Motivation: Accessibility and ease of play. Stance: sale.

Sherlock Enthusiast: Enjoys immersive storytelling and thematic elements. Motivation: Thematic interest and love for detective stories. Stance: sale.

Puzzle Solver: Focuses on solving puzzles and enjoying the investigative aspects. Motivation: Engaging and challenging puzzles. Stance: deep sale.

Steam Deck: The game has significant stability issues, including frequent crashes and instability, which severely impact the user experience. Additionally, there are notable UI/UX issues, particularly with document readability and display problems. While some users report positive compatibility experiences, especially with older hardware, control and loading issues are also common complaints. Overall, the game requires considerable tinkering and has several technical barriers that need addressing.

Linux and Proton: The game demonstrates strong compatibility and performance on Linux via Proton and Steam Deck. Users report smooth gameplay with no significant issues, indicating a well-supported experience on these platforms.

External guides: The primary issues identified from user feedback include significant problems with bugs and navigation, as well as frustrations with game mechanics and the overall user experience. The bugs and navigation issues are particularly severe, impacting the gameplay experience significantly.

Complete all tasks for 100% completion: Players advise not to skip any tasks or activities if the goal is to achieve 100% completion of the game.

Lag issues have workarounds: Some players have experienced lag issues but mention that there are workarounds available.

Support for Ukrainian developers: Reviewers express their support for the developers due to their Ukrainian background.