Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure Review Summary

Last updated: 2026-11-18
  • Improves on first game
  • Refined and polished UI
  • Excellent idle game
  • Substantial early access content
  • Missing Chinese localization
  • Insufficient new content
Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure header

Emotions

Archetypes

Hardware

Windows <8GB VRAMpositive

What players like:

Common complaints:

Gameplay feedback:

Performance notes:

Recommendations:

Other player notes:

Review evidence

Why players say this

Steam review verdict

It improves on the first game with a refined, polished UI and plenty of early access content for an excellent idle experience, though new content feels thin and Chinese localization is missing.

What players like

Improves on first game: Many reviewers highlight that the game improves on the first game in almost every way, including being bigger, more fun, and generally better.

Refined and polished UI: The interface is frequently praised as more refined, cleaner, and visually polished than the first game's, with a beautiful and organized new UI.

Generally positive reception: Reviewers express overall enjoyment and satisfaction, calling it an amazing, very good, or genuinely well-made game.

Excellent idle game: Players consider it one of the best idle games, great for AFK and long-term play, and true to the idle incremental genre.

Substantial early access content: Reviewers note that despite being in early access, the game is packed with content and feels like a complete experience.

Common complaints

Missing Chinese Localization: Players frequently report that the game lacks official Chinese language support, with some noting that the existing localization is incomplete or hidden.

Insufficient New Content: Many reviewers feel the sequel lacks meaningful new content compared to the first game, with some calling it a rehash or a worse version.

UI Issues and Clunkiness: The user interface is criticized for being clumsy, messy, and having a learning curve, with some specific problems like unclickable elements.

Unfinished Early Access State: The game is perceived as unfinished, with many features marked 'coming soon', missing content, and placeholder assets.

Performance and Optimization Issues: The game is laggy, has high GPU usage, and stutters when switching screens, requiring optimization.

Gameplay and performance

Idle incremental genre: The game is consistently described as an idle/incremental game with passive income and AFK mechanics. It is designed for background play with periodic check-ins.

Progress and resource collection: Progression involves gathering resources, grinding, and completing tasks. Players see numbers increase and unlock new content over time.

RuneScape-inspired progression: The game features skill-based progression adapted from RuneScape, with endless leveling up to level 99. It is often described as a 2D OSRS-style idle game.

Variety of skills: The game includes a wide range of skills such as hunting, ranching, fishing, and cooking. Each skill has its own activities and progression.

Background and AFK play: The game is designed to run in the background while players do other things. It supports various playstyles from fully idle to active.

Excessive RAM and GPU usage: The game reportedly consumes around 2GB of RAM and spikes GPU usage to 97%, with 50-70% attributed to the game even while other titles run. This indicates heavy resource consumption that may strain lower-end systems.

Smooth performance for some: A portion of players report no technical issues, bugs, or noticeable problems, describing the game as running well. This contrasts with reports of lag and stuttering from other users.

Frequent screen-switching stuttering: Players report stuttering that occurs frequently when switching between screens. This performance hiccup disrupts the flow of gameplay during navigation.

Persistent high latency online: Users report high latency that persists even when using a VPN. This suggests underlying network or server issues rather than local connectivity problems.

Laggy on launch: Players describe the game as very laggy when first opened. The sluggish startup experience affects initial impressions.

Recommendations

Recommended for idle game fans: The game is highly recommended for players who enjoy idle or incremental games. It appeals to those looking for a rewarding AFK experience.

Worth the price and grind: Many find the game worth its affordable price and the time invested. It offers a fulfilling long-term progression experience.

Appeals to Melvor fans: Players who liked the first Melvor Idle game are likely to enjoy this sequel. It is recommended for fans of the original and those who want more of the same.

RuneScape theme attracts fans: The game is recommended for RuneScape fans due to its similar theme and mechanics. Those who enjoy RuneScape's skilling and progression will find it appealing.

Wait for updates or bundle: Several players suggest waiting for more content or updates before purchasing. Others recommend waiting for a bundle with the base game and DLC.

Buying context

Game completion: 600.0h.

The game is praised for rewarding long-term progression, but early friction from RuneScape-dependent tutorials, a slow start, UI learning, and steep early-midgame costs delays enjoyment for some players. It tends to click after investing in several skills or overcoming the UI curve, while some reports describe immediate fun or say it never wins over players who disliked the first game.

Friction: Tutorials assume familiarity with Oldschool Runescape or Runescape 3 rather than teaching mechanics.; Progress is very slow at the start.; The new UI has a slight learning curve.; Shop upgrades and automation are too steep in the early midgame relative to gold income.; Farming patch upgrades feel too expensive early.; Hunting and ranching do not interact enough in the early game..

Unlock drivers: Investing in four different skills to increase yield or reduce tick time.; Getting past the new UI learning curve..

Player profiles

AFK-First RuneScape Veteran: Runs the game passively on a second or third monitor, stacks long idle sessions, and occasionally checks in to adjust activities; some multibox multiple accounts. Motivation: Keep a RuneScape-style account grind advancing without giving it active attention, so progress continues while they work, play other games, or AFK elsewhere. Stance: buy.

Melvor Idle 1 Franchise Loyalist: Long-haul incremental progression: repeat and optimize familiar skill and mastery loops, compare everything against the first game, and commit for hundreds of hours across patches. Motivation: Continue and upgrade a progression loop they already invested hundreds to thousands of hours in, trusting that early-access content will be fleshed out over time. Stance: buy.

Idle Progression Completionist: Goal-stacks skills and mastery challenges, mixes idle gathering with active play, and values customization, loadouts, and systems depth over moment-to-moment combat. Motivation: Chase long-term goals, unlocks, and mastery buffs in a relaxed single-player loop that is less punishing than an active MMO grind. Stance: buy.

Platform notes

Across the provided Windows <8GB VRAM cohort, feedback is positive: the game is reported to run well, though one user notes high GPU usage alongside other games.

Windows <8GB VRAM: positive. The cohort reports the game working well, with the only caveat being unusually high GPU usage from Melvor Idle 2 alongside other games.

Extra review signals

Monetization: Reviews explicitly mention no microtransactions.

Other review notes

Better visuals than predecessor: Reviewers highlight significant visual improvements over the first game, including more polished graphics and preferred visual presentation. Animations and sound effects are also noted as additions.

Early access development noted: Reviewers frequently mention that the game is in early access and still in development, with expectations of more content, modes, and mods. A demo was available prior to early access.

Compared to RuneScape: Several reviewers compare the game to RuneScape and Old School RuneScape, often noting its theme or describing it as a boiled-down, single-player 2D version.

Demo and playtest available: Reviewers mention that a demo and playtest were available before release, and some played the demo before purchasing the full game. The demo version differs from the actual game.

Sequel to Melvor Idle: Multiple reviews identify the game as a sequel or variant of the first Melvor Idle, calling it a fantastic follow-up. It is explicitly described as a sequel to Melvor Idle.