Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord - War Sails
Last updated: 2025-11-27
- DLC offers exceptional value for some players.
- Critical bugs cause widespread unplayability.
- DLC largely perceived as overpriced, unfinished.
- Naval combat is buggy and repetitive.
- Story and tutorial are tedious, buggy.
- Suffers from significant performance problems.
Emotions
Players are primarily frustrated by numerous game-breaking bugs, crashes (especially on launch or during key missions), and persistent technical issues that make the game unplayable or impede progress. Poor design choices contribute significantly, including clunky ship controls, ineffective AI (for both allied units and enemies), tedious and overly difficult tutorial missions, and balancing problems with factions and troop types.
Disappointment stems from the perceived insufficient content and value for the DLC's price, with many feeling it offers too little for a high cost or is merely an unfinished update. Gameplay elements like repetitive naval battles, lackluster AI, and the state of the Nord faction often fall short of expectations, leading to a sense of unfulfilled potential for the game.
Players express satisfaction with the solid implementation of new naval mechanics, finding sea battles engaging and offering new tactical depth. The DLC is often seen as a valuable addition that enhances the overall game experience, bringing new possibilities, improved AI, and a sense of completeness to the world of Calradia.
Anger arises from critical bugs and crashes that render purchased content unplayable, leading to a strong feeling of being ripped off. Players are particularly upset by what they perceive as developer negligence—rushing an unfinished product, making poor design choices, and demonstrating a lack of proper testing or care for the game's quality.
Excitement is driven by the introduction of new mechanics like ships and naval combat, which offer fresh gameplay styles and strategic possibilities. Players are thrilled by the overall quality and potential impact of the DLC, viewing it as a significant, transformative addition that revitalizes the game and fuels anticipation for future content and modding opportunities.
Verdict
Mostly negative
Summary
Positive 39% · Negative 61%. Score: 61 / 100
Positives:
- Players overwhelmingly praise the DLC as a substantial, well-made addition that goes far beyond expectations. It significantly expands the game, adds new layers of depth, and offers excellent content for its price, making the base game feel more complete and refreshing.
- The DLC is seen as a 'must-try' for Mount & Blade fans, elevating Bannerlord to new heights and making it feel like a truly complete medieval 'land + sea' sandbox. It redefines the game's scope, adding much-needed fresh tactical layers and replayability.
- Players commend TaleWorlds for the evident effort put into the DLC and accompanying updates, noting the high quality and thoughtful implementation of new content. There is also appreciation for the reasonable pricing policy and continued support for the game.
- The game's enhanced dynamic nature, including new random events, contributes to a fun, chaotic, and engaging experience. These events add extra flavor and provide more options for player agency and enjoyment within the sandbox.
Negatives:
- The game, especially after updates and with the DLC, is plagued by severe technical issues including frequent crashes, infinite loading screens, and game-breaking bugs that prevent launch or progression. This renders the game unplayable for a significant number of players.
- The DLC is widely criticized as overpriced for its limited and low-quality content, often compared unfavorably to community mods. Players feel it was released in an unfinished, unpolished state after significant delays, leading to widespread disappointment and regret over their purchase.
- The core naval combat feature of the DLC is marred by numerous bugs, such as units getting stuck, unresponsive controls, and mission failures. Players find the combat slow, clunky, and repetitive, lacking strategic depth and becoming monotonous quickly.
- The new story campaign and tutorial missions are criticized for being excessively long, tedious, and repetitive, often forcing players through unskippable, drawn-out sequences. These elements are also highly bug-ridden, frequently breaking progression and frustrating players.
- The new Nord faction is consistently described as underpowered, with weak troops, poor equipment, and a lack of distinct identity or strategic advantages. Its design and balance are criticized as unfinished and unimpressive compared to other factions.
Gameplay:
- The DLC introduces significant naval combat, a new Nord faction, new islands, and associated mechanics, while the accompanying base game update also adds stealth, improved graphics, and general gameplay refinements. Players appreciate the base game improvements as much as the DLC content itself.
- Naval combat primarily focuses on close-quarters boarding actions using hooks and ladders, with ranged weapons also being effective. Players desire more strategic fleet control, the ability to launch sea sieges, and direct attacks on villages from water, as current sea battles are limited to port cities and lack detailed troop command options.
- The new Nord faction is Viking-themed, populates a snowy northern region, and introduces new armor, weapons, and trade goods. Their military relies heavily on diverse melee infantry units with throwing weapons, but notably lacks cavalry, and makes extensive use of various ship types like longships, benefiting from speed bonuses.
- The game introduces ships and new naval skills (Mariner, Boatswain, Shipmaster) through a dedicated campaign and tutorial missions, including specific ramming mechanics. Ship management involves acquisition costs, potential damage from environmental hazards, and various upgrade possibilities, although the initial tutorial experience can be frustrating for some players.
- Several reviewers provided initial feedback after only an hour or a day of play. While some noted a lack of major bugs and expressed support for the game, this indicates these are early impressions rather than in-depth analyses, reducing the confidence in detailed feedback.
Performance:
- The game suffers from poor optimization, resulting in sudden FPS drops, inconsistent frame rates, stuttering, and severe lag, particularly in naval battles or after recent updates/DLCs. Players note terrible GPU utilization, mouse lag (especially in 21:9 resolution or naval battles), and significantly longer loading times. Some also suspect memory leaks.
- Players reported issues with audio timing, such as battle music disappearing during fights or epic soundtracks playing inappropriately during dialogue sequences. This disrupts the intended atmosphere and immersion.
Recommendations:
- A predominant theme is the game's unpolished state, riddled with bugs, performance issues, and a lack of refinement. Players are strongly advising waiting for official patches, performance optimizations, or community-made mods to fix these problems.
- Player sentiment on purchasing the DLC is divided. Many recommend it for long-term fans or its new features, but frequently advise waiting for sales, price drops, or bug fixes due to concerns about the full price not matching the current quality.
- The DLC is primarily recommended for dedicated fans of the base game, those seeking new content after extensive play, or players with a specific interest in naval mechanics, strategy, and management. It may not satisfy casual players or those hoping for a "fix" to underlying base game issues.
- A notable portion of the community expressed strong dissatisfaction, with several players either requesting or considering refunds for the DLC. This is primarily attributed to the game's current technical issues and perceived poor value for money.
- Many players advise against playing the guided storyline or tutorial, suggesting that focusing on the sandbox mode provides a superior experience. This indicates potential issues with the narrative, pacing, or onboarding elements of the story content.
Miscellaneous:
- There is an overwhelming expectation that the modding community will be crucial for the DLC's success, with players anticipating modders to fix issues, update content, and add missing depth. Many are excited to see what new elements modders will create, hoping they will complete the experience the developers started.
- After a long wait, players express mixed sentiments regarding developer communication and update cadence, hoping TaleWorlds will consistently support and expand the add-on. There's a strong call for developers to prioritize core game improvements over solely paid content and to actively listen to community feedback to rebuild and maintain trust.
- Players desire a broader range of content and features, including additional elements like armor smithing, more unique factions (e.g., Egyptian/Aserai, China-inspired), and culturally distinct armor designs. Specific requests also include enhanced naval customization options, more natural river appearances, and faction-specific buffs, such as making Nords stronger at sea.
Similar games
Blend with other games
95%Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord
95%Crusader Kings III: Tours & Tournaments
94%Total War: WARHAMMER III
94%Cult of the Lamb: Woolhaven
93%Crusader Kings III
93%Stronghold Crusader: Definitive Edition
93%Knights of the Crusades
93%Surviving Mars: Relaunched
93%ZEPHON
93%Total War: PHARAOH
93%Windward Horizon
93%Workers & Resources: Soviet Republic - Early Start