- Enjoyable naval combat with pirate theme
- Detailed ship customization and exploration
- Variety of quests and fantasy elements
- UI design flaws and poor tutorial
- Repetitive gameplay and clunky controls
- Poor boarding mechanics and overpowered enemies
Emotions
Players are frustrated by a variety of technical and design issues. The UI is frequently described as unintuitive and poorly designed, leading to a clunky and uncomfortable experience. Additionally, the game suffers from numerous bugs, glitches, and repetitive gameplay mechanics, including grinding tasks and poorly implemented combat and mission systems.
Players enjoy the game primarily for its fun and engaging gameplay elements. The open-world exploration, naval combat, and sea battles are frequently highlighted as enjoyable aspects. Many players also appreciate the straightforward pirate theme and the ability to play with friends and family.
Players express disappointment due to the game's repetitive and grinding gameplay, which lacks depth and complexity. The game's poor execution, unpolished feel, and lack of promised features contribute to this sentiment. Additionally, the game's poor translation and lack of optimization for PC further disappoint players.
Players are satisfied with the variety of gameplay elements and the overall quality of the game. The presence of different activities, customization options, and the game's depth contribute to this satisfaction. The game's graphics, combat system, and price are also mentioned as positive aspects.
Players are excited about the game's unique and engaging pirate theme, which includes naval combat and fantasy elements. The variety of ships, combat mechanics, and the open-world aspect contribute to this excitement. The game's overall quality and features are also highlighted as exciting aspects.
Verdict
Mixed
Summary
Positive 56% · Negative 44%. Score: 44 / 100
Verdict
Aggressive Monetization
Summary
The game's monetization strategy, particularly regarding its DLC, is a significant point of contention among users. While some find the game and its additional content to be reasonably priced, others feel that the DLC is overpriced and not worth the investment. This divide in perceived value, along with the focus on creating new DLC instead of fixing the game, indicates potential issues with the game's monetization approach. Score: 60 / 100
Top points
- Day-1 DLC - High
- Perceived Value - Medium
Verdict
Tinkering Required
Summary
The analysis of user feedback reveals significant issues with controller support and the user interface. Many users find the controller adaptation to be poor, making some operations nearly impossible to perform. Additionally, the user interface is frequently described as non-intuitive and difficult to navigate, leading to a frustrating user experience. Score: 50 / 100
Top points
- Controller Support - High
- User Interface - High
Positives:
- Players find the naval battles to be decent and enjoyable, with some even describing the combat as excellent. The game offers a satisfying experience in terms of ship combat.
- The game is widely appreciated for its pirate theme, offering a fun and straightforward experience for pirate game enthusiasts. It features everything expected in a pirate game and is recommended for fans of the genre.
- The game offers a heavy emphasis on ship customization, with hundreds of different combinations for customizing and upgrading ships. This feature is well-received by players.
- The game provides an open-world environment with a large map, allowing players the freedom to explore. This feature is highlighted as a significant aspect of the gameplay.
- The game features different types of ammunition, providing players with a variety of options for combat. This adds depth to the gameplay experience.
Negatives:
- The game's user interface is widely criticized for being non-intuitive, clunky, and frustrating. Players find the UI aesthetics unappealing and the overall design messy, leading to a poor user experience.
- The tutorial is often described as incomplete, confusing, and frustrating. Players feel that it lacks relevance and does not provide clear guidance, making it difficult to understand the game mechanics.
- The gameplay is often described as repetitive, boring, and tedious. Players find the quests monotonous and frustrating, leading to a lack of engagement.
- Controls are frequently criticized for being clunky, unbalanced, and unresponsive. Players also report issues with camera control and overall poor control settings.
- The boarding mechanics are criticized for being unintuitive, poorly designed, and clunky. Players find the rewards and overall experience of boarding uninteresting.
Gameplay:
- The game heavily emphasizes naval combat, including ship-to-ship battles and boarding mechanics. Players are engaged in various aspects of ship combat and navigation.
- Players can customize their ships in numerous ways, including flags, sail colors, hull designs, and various upgrades. This allows for a high degree of personalization and progression.
- The game includes a faction system with interactions and relationships, as well as a trading and commerce system. Players can engage in trading and manage their reputation with different factions.
- The game features a variety of quests and missions for players to complete. These quests are often handwritten and provide specific tasks for players to accomplish.
- The game incorporates fantasy elements, including magical sea battles and mythical creatures like the Kraken. These elements add a unique twist to the gameplay.
Performance:
- Players report a range of bugs and glitches, including game crashes, scene lock-ups, and occasional technical hiccups. Some bugs are specific, like water clipping through ships and issues with ship descriptions.
- The game is well-optimized and performs smoothly, even on low-end computers. Players appreciate the stable FPS and fluid gameplay.
- While many players praise the graphics, some reviews mention poor graphics and world design, as well as simple or outdated visuals.
- The game includes convenient features like auto-save, being alt-tab friendly, and having low storage requirements.
- There are reports of extreme bugs affecting save files, including enchanted items disappearing after closing and reopening the game.
Recommendations:
- The game is frequently recommended for its pirate-themed content, appealing to fans of pirate adventures, sailing, and naval combat. Many players highlight its value and engaging gameplay.
- Players recommend the game despite its rough edges, citing its value, gameplay, and features. The game is seen as a good purchase for its content and developer engagement.
- The game is praised for its combat mechanics and customization features, including vessel upgrades and adventure elements. These aspects are frequently mentioned as key strengths.
- The game receives positive recommendations in various languages, indicating a broad appeal and satisfaction among international players.
- The game is compared to other titles like Assassin's Creed Black Flag, Pillars of Eternity 2, and Risen 2, indicating that players are drawing parallels with other popular games in the genre.
Miscellaneous:
- -
No data available
