- Excellent level design
- Classic and Modern Sonic gameplay
- Impressive visuals and graphics
- Game length too short
- Control and gameplay problems
- High price concerns
Emotions
Players are thrilled by the engaging story, high-quality gameplay, and the remastered content of Shadow Generations. The ability to switch between Sonic and Shadow's stages, along with the improved mechanics and new challenges, has exceeded expectations and provided a fresh and enjoyable experience.
Players are frustrated by various technical issues, including performance problems, bugs, and poor controls. The difficulty in completing certain tasks, unskippable cutscenes, and the tedious process of achieving 100% completion also contribute to this frustration.
Players are satisfied with the improved boss fights, great soundtrack, and smooth controls. The overall polish, engaging gameplay, and the quality of both Sonic and Shadow campaigns contribute to a positive experience.
Players feel disappointed due to the game's short length, lack of content, and technical issues. The comparison to the original Sonic Generations and the feeling of a rushed product also contribute to this disappointment.
Players express joy in the engaging stages, great animations, and the overall high quality of the game. The emotional story and the fun gameplay mechanics, especially in Shadow Generations, contribute to a very enjoyable experience.
Verdict
Mostly positive
Summary
Positive 85% · Negative 15%. Score: 15 / 100
Verdict
Mixed Sentiment on DLC Pricing
Summary
The reviews for the game's DLC present a mixed bag of opinions. While some users find the DLC overpriced and not worth the cost, others express satisfaction and believe it is worth the price. There are also users who have mixed feelings, suggesting that the pricing could be better but still find value in the content. Overall, the sentiment leans towards a need for better pricing strategies to enhance user satisfaction. Score: 35 / 100
Top points
- Overpriced DLC - Medium
- Positive Feedback on DLC - Positive
- Mixed Feelings on Pricing - Low
Verdict
Tinkering Required
Summary
The analysis of user feedback for the Steam Deck experience of the game reveals several critical issues. The most prominent problem is related to Denuvo DRM, which causes crashes, performance hits, and restrictions on offline play. Additionally, there are mixed reports on the game's performance on the Steam Deck, with some users needing to adjust settings for optimal play. Control issues, particularly on PC, have also been noted. These issues collectively impact the user experience significantly. Score: 60 / 100
Top points
- Denuvo DRM Issues - High
- Performance on Steam Deck - Medium
- Control Issues - Medium
- Offline Play Restrictions - High
Positives:
- The game features well-designed levels with multiple distinct paths, offering both speed and platforming challenges. The level design is considered stellar and among the best in the series.
- Shadow Generations is highly praised for its overall quality, including well-made levels, beautiful cinematics, effective storytelling, and improved graphics and animations. It is considered better than Sonic Generations in many aspects and provides a proper conclusion to Shadow's arc.
- The game features impressive visuals and outstanding graphics. The visuals and art design are excellent, with a big visual upgrade.
- Shadow's game is praised for its character development and enjoyable gameplay. His story is well-expanded and considered one of the best since Sonic Adventure 2.
- The game features a great soundtrack that is highly praised by players. The music is described as excellent and phenomenal.
Negatives:
- Many players felt that the game was too short, with some completing it in around 4 hours. This lack of length contributed to a perception of low replayability and lack of gameplay value.
- There were numerous complaints about the game's controls, including issues with Modern Sonic's handling, Shadow's difficult powers, and overall awkward controls. Some players also found the boost mechanics weak and slow.
- Several reviews mentioned that the game was not worth its full price, with specific complaints about the $50.00 or $60.00 price tag. Some players also noted that the game was expensive even with discounts.
- Boss fights were described as slow, repetitive, and underwhelming. The final boss, in particular, was criticized for being boring and annoying.
- Players reported issues with the game's performance, including a lack of optimization for PC, no customization options, and a cap at 60 FPS. Some also mentioned that the game runs worse than the original.
Gameplay:
- Sonic Generations offers a great variation between classic and modern Sonic gameplay, featuring tight level design and revisiting the best moments of Sonic. It includes both classic 2D side-scrolling levels and fully 3D environments.
- Shadow Generations features enjoyable gameplay with specific mechanics and powers based on Shadow's alien DNA. The stages have tons of paths and Shadow feels great to control.
- Shadow Generations revisits old stages with improved gameplay mechanics, visuals, and stage design. It introduces new mechanics and abilities, enhancing the overall gameplay flow and replayability.
- The game includes multi-phase boss fights and well-designed challenges. Collectibles and challenges are available to unlock boss battles and other content.
- The game offers multiple routes and alternative paths in level design, providing a variety of gameplay experiences and enhancing replayability.
Performance:
- There are reports of optimization issues, particularly on lower-end systems, causing lag and performance problems.
- Many players reported that the game runs smoothly with a stable framerate, providing a good gaming experience.
- Several players expressed frustration with the 60 FPS limit, wishing for higher FPS options or noting that the limit can be bypassed with mods.
- Some bugs persist despite attempts to fix them by adjusting graphics settings, indicating deeper issues within the game.
- Some players experienced performance issues that were resolved by adjusting resolution and frame rate settings. These issues seemed to appear after a game update.
Recommendations:
- The game is highly recommended for fans of the Sonic franchise, including both new and long-time fans. It is seen as a worthwhile purchase for those who enjoy Sonic and platformer games.
- Many reviewers suggest purchasing the game only when it is on sale due to its high price. Specific recommendations include waiting for a 40-50% discount.
- The game is particularly recommended for fans of Shadow, with some reviewers suggesting it is worth buying just for the Shadow Generations content.
- Several reviewers generally recommend the game, highlighting its value and enjoyment. Some mention it is worth the price, especially if you haven't played the original Generations.
Miscellaneous:
- Many players fondly remember receiving Sonic Adventure as a gift, particularly around Christmas, and it holds a special place in their memories as a favorite game.
- Some players are expressing a desire to see Big the Cat included in the game, indicating a demand for this character.
- A few players feel that the game is more like downloadable content (DLC) rather than a full standalone game, comparing it to other entries in the series.
- There are suggestions from players on how to improve the design of the hub world, indicating a desire for better navigation or aesthetics.
- Some players mentioned receiving the game as a gift, which could imply it is a popular choice for gifting.
