Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments
Last updated: 2026-01-26
- Exceptional Sherlock Holmes immersion and atmosphere
- Innovative deduction mechanics with strong narrative
- Engaging and varied cases with emotional impact
- High-quality voice acting and writing
- Frequent crashes and technical instability
- Unclear clues and clunky controls
Emotions
Frustration29%Satisfaction17%Disappointment10%Enjoyment10%Appreciation5%
- Sample precision
- Helpful reviews
- 55%
- Unhelpful reviews
- 44%
- Protest reviews
- 0%
- 70%Helpful reviews with positive sentiment
- 30%Helpful reviews with negative sentiment
- Positive points
- 865
- Negative points
- 567
- Gameplay points
- 726
- Perf. points
- 166
- Rec. points
- 120
- Misc points
- 15
| Point | Description | Importance |
|---|---|---|
Positive emotional and cerebral impact
| The game encourages critical thinking, self-reflection, and emotional engagement. Players feel a sense of achievement and immersion, making it a rewarding experience for fans of detective stories and logic puzzles. | 91% |
Engaging and varied cases
| The game features six independent, well-crafted cases with unique narratives, twists, and moral choices. Each case offers variety in tone, structure, and difficulty, keeping players invested throughout. | 87% |
Innovative deduction mechanics
| The deduction system encourages critical thinking, allowing players to connect clues, form hypotheses, and draw conclusions. The non-linear paths and moral choices add depth and replayability to the gameplay. | 85% |
Exceptional Sherlock Holmes immersion
| The game effectively captures the essence of Sherlock Holmes, with well-portrayed characters, Victorian London settings, and engaging deduction mechanics. Players feel like they are embodying the famous detective through logic, observation, and storytelling. | 85% |
Strong narrative and atmosphere
| The game excels in storytelling, with richly imagined Victorian London settings, atmospheric music, and immersive world-building. The narrative captures the spirit of Sherlock Holmes' original works while adding modern twists. | 84% |
High-quality voice acting and writing
| The voice acting is top-notch, with authentic British accents and well-written dialogue. The characters, particularly Holmes and Watson, are brought to life with depth, humor, and emotional resonance. | 82% |
Detailed and immersive environments
| The game features beautifully constructed scenes of Victorian England, with detailed locations like 221B Baker Street and atmospheric settings that enhance immersion. The visuals, though aged, still hold up well. | 82% |
Balanced and accessible gameplay
| The game offers a mix of casual and challenging gameplay, with well-balanced puzzles, mini-games, and moral choices. Features like skip options, first/third-person views, and hints make it accessible to a wide range of players. | 28% |
Moral choices with consequences
| Players can make impactful decisions at the end of each case, such as pardoning or convicting criminals. These choices add emotional weight and replayability, allowing players to shape Holmes' character and the story's outcome. | 11% |
Thoughtful quality-of-life features
| The game includes helpful features like skip options for mini-games, first/third-person view toggles, and loading screen clue analysis. These additions improve accessibility and reduce frustration for players. | 6% |
Replayability through multiple endings
| The game offers multiple endings per case, allowing players to explore different outcomes based on their choices. This feature adds replay value and encourages experimentation with deductions and moral decisions. | 5% |
Toby the dog as a fun addition
| The inclusion of Toby, Sherlock Holmes' dog, as a playable character adds a unique and enjoyable element to the gameplay. Players appreciate the novelty and charm of controlling Toby during investigations. | 2% |