Players expressed satisfaction due to the game's high-quality narrative, particularly its revelations and contributions to the Fate franchise, and its ability to deepen appreciation for other works. The Steam version's convenience, full voice acting, multi-language support, and quality-of-life features also significantly contributed to player contentment.
Admiration stemmed from the game's perceived quality as a masterpiece, especially regarding Nasu's writing and the literary depth of the narrative. The quality of the remaster and strong character development, particularly for characters like Bazett, also garnered significant praise.
Joy was primarily caused by the game's release on Steam and the official English localization, making it more accessible to a wider audience. Players also found joy in seeing their favorite characters, especially in the game's happy, slice-of-life setting.
Disappointment arose from missing content, specifically the absence of Capsule Servant and R18 content, as well as the lack of Russian localization. Some players also felt let down by the game being perceived as merely an HD upgrade rather than a more substantial remaster.
Excitement was driven by the prospect of future Type-Moon releases and the long-awaited official release of the game. Specific in-game elements like the Hanafuda game and certain character scenes also generated enthusiasm.
Verdict
Mostly positive
Summary
Positive 84% · Negative 16%. Score: 16 / 100
Positives:
Players are highly satisfied with the Steam release, praising its HD remaster, quality-of-life features, and official localization, especially the English and Chinese versions. The overall presentation and accessibility are considered excellent.
The game excels in character portrayal, allowing players to see beloved characters like Saber, Rin, Sakura, and Illya in new, heartwarming ways. New characters like Caren and Bazett are also highly praised for their development and impact.
Many players consider this game to be a masterpiece by Nasu Kinoko, often citing it as his best work or a peak in his writing. It's seen as a crucial and beloved entry in the Type-Moon and Fate franchises, significantly expanding its lore.
The game serves as a perfect extension and bittersweet epilogue to Fate/stay night, offering a refreshing slice-of-life perspective. It delves deeper into characters, reveals hidden truths about the Holy Grail, and balances lighthearted moments with darker scenes.
The game offers a substantial amount of content, including numerous mini-games and unlockable features. The individual slice-of-life scenes are particularly enjoyable, adding to the overall replayability.
Negatives:
Players are disappointed by the lack of R18 content, specifically noting that the Steam version is a censored port of the PS Vita release. This significantly impacts their enjoyment and perceived value of the game.
Many players feel the game is merely an HD re-release or simple port of the PSP version, with minimal new content. This perception, combined with the 90 yuan price, leads to a feeling that the remaster lacks sincerity.
The game features only one automatic save slot, which can be problematic. Players are frustrated that mistakes or missed story flags can force a complete restart, as there are no quick save options.
Some players express a general sense of disappointment and a lack of enthusiasm for the game. They feel it has lost much of the charm present in the first installment.
Players are frustrated by the need to complete 'dead ends' in the plot to progress the main story, especially without the helpful 'Taiga Dojo' feature from the first game that guided them through plot mistakes.
Gameplay:
The game features a complex, multi-perspective narrative set over a four-day cycle in Fuyuki City. Players explore slice-of-life scenes with familiar characters while gradually uncovering the truth behind a new Holy Grail War.
Fate/hollow ataraxia is a direct sequel to Fate/stay night, taking place six months after the original. It was originally released in 2005 as a fan disc, and this version is a remastered edition.
The game features a large cast of characters, including fan favorites from Fate/stay night like Saber, Rin, and Sakura, alongside new characters and the Himuro trio, allowing players to see their true natures.
Performance:
Players are experiencing various technical issues, including audio lag, black screens when using the keyboard, and slow window switching. These problems suggest significant compatibility and performance issues that hinder the overall gameplay experience.
Recommendations:
Many players emphasize that this game is a direct sequel to Fate/Stay Night and should only be played after completing all routes of the original visual novel. Playing it beforehand will spoil major plot points and diminish the experience.
Overall, players highly recommend this game, considering it a must-play experience. They suggest that even though it contains many extra elements, it is well worth the time and investment.
Some players expressed a strong desire for Type-Moon to release Tsukihime Remake on Steam. This indicates a demand for more of Type-Moon's visual novels on the platform.
One player specifically highlighted the inclusion of Matou Sakura as a reason to purchase and experience the game. This suggests that character presence can be a significant draw for fans.
Miscellaneous:
Many players are expressing a strong desire for an 18+ version of the game, indicating that the current content might not fully satisfy their expectations. Some are even holding off on playing until such a patch is available.
One player, a long-time FGO fan, expressed happiness about a large in-game currency bonus for an anniversary. They also made a somewhat unusual request for players to stop playing FGO to encourage new scriptwriting.
Some reviewers, despite previous stances or self-identification as fans of related series, acknowledge that the game appeals strongly to Type-Moon enthusiasts. This suggests the game successfully targets its core fanbase.
A common issue reported by players is that Shirou's voice is muted by default in the game settings. This leads to confusion and a less immersive experience until players manually adjust the audio settings.
Some players noted similarities to the EXTRA series or inquired about the release of Fate/Extra Record. This indicates an interest in the broader Type-Moon universe and connections between titles.