Players report widespread technical issues with the port, including frequent crashes, poor optimization, and bugs that disrupt gameplay (e.g., disc errors, save file corruption). Many also criticize clunky controls, repetitive stealth mechanics, and tedious sections like the bomb disposal or sniping segments, which are exacerbated by outdated design choices.
The game is praised for Hideo Kojima's visionary storytelling, thematic depth, and innovative gameplay mechanics, which blend cinematic presentation with philosophical commentary. Players highlight its cultural impact, character development (e.g., Raiden), and technical achievements for its era, such as sound design and narrative twists.
Reviewers reflect on personal connections to the game, often tied to childhood memories or its release in the PS2 era. Many revisit it after years, appreciating its timeless qualities, historical significance, and the emotional resonance of its story and mechanics compared to modern titles.
The port's poor quality—including unaddressed bugs, lack of modern features (e.g., native controller support), and subpar optimization—fails to meet expectations, especially given the original's acclaim. Some also express dissatisfaction with the story's complexity, outdated graphics, or Konami's perceived neglect of the re-release.
Players are struck by the game's prophetic themes about digital culture, AI, and societal control, which feel eerily relevant decades later. The narrative's depth, late-game revelations, and ambitious storytelling are frequently cited as groundbreaking and thought-provoking.
Verdict
Mixed
Summary
Positive 73% · Negative 27%. Score: 27 / 100
Positives:
The game is widely praised for its enhancements over the first installment, including refined mechanics, responsive controls, and new features like first-person aiming and lethal/non-lethal options. These upgrades contribute to a more polished and enjoyable experience.
The narrative is celebrated for its depth, complexity, and foresight, tackling themes like AI, censorship, and misinformation that remain relevant today. Its layered plot and twists are often described as ahead of their time.
The game sets a high standard for stealth gameplay with intelligent enemy AI, interactive environments, and multiple strategic approaches. These elements create a dynamic and immersive experience.
Despite its age, the game's themes, storytelling, and mechanics continue to resonate with players. Its ability to predict modern societal issues adds to its enduring appeal.
The game excels in cinematic presentation, voice acting, soundtrack, and fourth-wall-breaking techniques. These elements contribute to a deeply engaging and memorable experience.
Negatives:
The game's controls and visuals feel outdated by modern standards, with awkward remapping from older hardware and a lack of polish in graphics. This affects immersion and accessibility for newer players.
Gameplay is frequently interrupted by long, unskippable cutscenes (e.g., 40-minute segments) with poor audio mixing. Players criticize the imbalance between gameplay and narrative, feeling it disrespects their time.
The narrative is described as overly complex, incoherent, and filled with philosophical jargon. Players struggle with pacing, unclear plotlines, and excessive exposition, making the story hard to follow.
Players express disappointment over Raiden replacing Solid Snake for most of the game, calling him boring or poorly integrated. The bait-and-switch from the marketing frustrated many fans.
Players encounter critical 'disc read' errors (even in digital versions) that prevent progression, often during key story moments. These issues force restarts and can erase hours of progress.
Gameplay:
The game uses fixed or top-down camera perspectives, which some players find restrictive but others appreciate for its retro design. Level design is tailored to these angles.
The game is heavily story-driven, featuring deep themes, character development, and cinematic cutscenes. Players highlight its philosophical and dialogue-driven narrative, though some criticize lengthy cutscenes.
The game emphasizes stealth mechanics, including hiding in environments (e.g., cardboard boxes), patrolling enemies, and alarm systems. Players frequently mention the systemic depth and fluid controls, though some note control issues affecting stealth.
Players control Solid Snake initially but transition to Raiden, a newcomer. This shift is polarizing, with some praising Raiden’s character development and others criticizing the departure from Snake.
The game features immersive details like hiding in lockers, manipulating environments (e.g., knocking on walls), and small interactions (e.g., shooting ice). These elements add depth to gameplay.
Performance:
Disc read errors and save file corruption are widespread, particularly in cutscenes or when switching devices. These issues force players to replay sections or manually fix saves, especially with Steam Cloud sync.
Players report unacknowledged controllers, forcing keyboard use, and problems with Steam Input on Deck. Alt-tabbing or switching modes (e.g., Alt+Enter) often triggers crashes or freezes.
The PC port suffers from rendering bugs, missing features (e.g., borderless fullscreen), and resolution locks (initially 720p). Mods are frequently required to address performance, visuals, and compatibility issues.
Native resolution support is limited (initially 720p), with higher resolutions requiring AMD FSR upscaling or mods. Issues like broken geometry, screen noise, and monitor display glitches persist.
Audio compression issues, static sound, and desynchronization plague the game, often due to outdated codecs or porting oversights. These problems disrupt immersion and gameplay clarity.
Recommendations:
The game is overwhelmingly recommended by reviewers, especially for those who played the first game or are new to the series. It is praised as a must-play experience despite minor flaws.
Reviewers consistently advise playing *Metal Gear Solid 1* before this game to fully grasp the story and appreciate its narrative depth. This is critical for newcomers to the franchise.
The game is highly recommended for fans of stealth mechanics, cinematic storytelling, and the *Metal Gear* saga, offering a unique and thought-provoking experience.
The game’s story is praised for its emotional depth, philosophical themes, and relevance to modern society, making it a standout experience in gaming history.
Many reviewers recommend playing the PS2 version or using an emulator (e.g., PCSX2) instead of the Steam port due to technical issues, better performance, and fewer bugs.
Miscellaneous:
Reviews reflect personal connections to the series, including multiple purchases, modding experiences, and reflections on its impact over 20 years. Some players mention platinum achievements or long completion times.
Players describe the game as transcending typical gaming experiences, calling it a 'masterpiece' and a 'vehicle' for deeper narrative immersion. The artistic and postmodern evolution of the series is frequently highlighted.
The narrative explores information control, Big Data, and real-world parallels, including a lecture by Kojima on these topics. Players engage with its commentary on societal and political issues.
The game intentionally references and parallels *Metal Gear Solid 1*, with players noting replaying older titles to appreciate the design choices. This reinforces the series' continuity and thematic depth.
The recent port is labeled a 'cash grab' due to perceived lack of effort, with players requesting a proper re-release instead. Pricing and discount issues further fuel dissatisfaction.