- Unparalleled stealth sandbox gameplay experience
- Addictive, in-depth Mother Base management
- Exceptional sound design and soundtrack
- Fragmented, unfinished main story narrative
- Repetitive mission objectives and design
- Empty open world, underwhelming antagonists
Emotions
Players felt satisfied by the game's exceptional stealth action gameplay, open-ended missions, and innovative mechanics like the Fulton system. They also praised its engaging story, cinematic quality, excellent graphics, and high replayability, often considering it a masterpiece and a strong continuation of the series. The game's optimization, even on lower-end hardware, and the freedom to build a Private Military Company further contributed to this positive experience.
Disappointment stemmed primarily from the game's incomplete and often fragmented narrative, particularly in Chapter 2, which led to a feeling of an unfinished story and unresolved plot points. Repetitive missions, an empty open world, and cumbersome base-building mechanics also contributed to this sentiment. Players felt the game didn't live up to the series' traditional storytelling standards or its full potential due to perceived external development issues and cut content.
Admiration was frequently directed towards the game's unparalleled stealth action gameplay, tactical freedom, and deep mechanical design, often hailed as revolutionary. Reviewers praised its stunning visuals, cinematic cutscenes, and the FOX engine's performance. Hideo Kojima's vision and ability to redefine the stealth genre, along with the game's enduring quality and attention to detail, also inspired significant admiration.
Excitement arose from the game's engaging, open-world stealth mechanics, offering insane freedom and tight controls that led to a highly addictive experience. Players were thrilled by the gripping story, unexpected plot twists, and the abundance of customization options and companions. The high cinematic quality and replayability also generated enthusiasm for new and returning players.
Frustration was caused by repetitive missions, excessive grinding for resources and upgrades, and a perceived unfinished story. Players also cited issues with clunky PC controls, intrusive UI elements, and technical problems like game-breaking bugs or long loading times. Monetization practices, particularly related to MB Coins and FOBs, and the inability to play offline for a single-player game, further annoyed players.
Verdict
Mostly positive
Summary
Positive 87% · Negative 13%. Score: 13 / 100
Positives:
- Players consistently praise the immense freedom in mission approach, diverse tactical options, and highly reactive AI. This creates an engaging, open-ended stealth experience where every playthrough feels unique and rewarding due to deep mechanics and a vast arsenal of tools.
- The game is lauded for its overall polish, visual fidelity, and robust performance that holds up remarkably well years after release. Players find it an incredibly fun and addictive experience with strong replayability and exceptional technical optimization, even a decade later.
- The game is seen as a pivotal entry in the Metal Gear Solid series, praised for its innovative approach and masterful direction by Hideo Kojima. It's often considered the best in the franchise and a compelling introduction for newcomers, enriching the saga's lore and representing Kojima's visionary farewell.
- The game's narrative is highly praised for its engaging plot, intricate twists, and exploration of dark, philosophical themes like war, identity, and revenge. Its cinematic presentation and emotional depth leave a lasting impression on players.
- The Mother Base progression and management system, including Fulton extraction and equipment development, is highly engaging. It provides a rewarding sense of growth and strategic depth, fostering player immersion as they build and customize their private army and develop technologies.
Negatives:
- A prevalent issue is the story's incomplete and disjointed nature, especially in the second half and the ending. Many players feel key plotlines are unresolved, crucial content (like Mission 51/Chapter 3) was cut, and the narrative suffers from turbulent development and the departure of Hideo Kojima, falling short of the series' cinematic depth.
- The game is heavily criticized for its repetitive mission structure, especially in Chapter 2, which often reuses earlier missions with minor modifications or increased difficulty. This leads to a strong sense of grind, with many main and side missions feeling like filler that doesn't advance the story.
- The game's vast open-world maps (Afghanistan and Africa) are frequently described as empty, monotonous, and lacking diverse interactions or dynamic events. Traversal often feels tedious, with unscalable mountains and repetitive outposts, diminishing the sense of a living world.
- The main antagonist, Skull Face, is widely considered underdeveloped, lacking the charisma and screen time of previous series villains, with his characterization often relegated to audio logs. Similarly, boss fights are frequently described as bland, uninteresting, and lacking the epic impact expected from the franchise.
- Many players are frustrated by the heavy reliance on optional audio cassette tapes to deliver crucial story exposition and character backstories. This method is seen as tedious, risks players missing vital context, and dilutes the traditional cinematic storytelling experience of the series.
Gameplay:
- Players enjoy extensive freedom in mission approach, allowing for everything from intricate stealth and non-lethal takedowns to aggressive, all-out combat. The game provides a rich arsenal of weapons and unique gadgets, like tranquilizers and the Fulton system, encouraging creative tactical solutions.
- A core gameplay loop involves managing and expanding Mother Base, the player's operational hub. This includes recruiting soldiers, developing new gear, and allocating resources. The system extends to competitive FOB (Forward Operating Base) missions where players can invade or defend bases, adding a strategic multiplayer layer.
- This installment marks a significant shift for the Metal Gear Solid franchise, prioritizing open-world gameplay and mechanics over its traditional heavy cinematic storytelling. While offering crucial narrative context within the series timeline, its distinct style makes it accessible to newcomers and a different experience for veterans.
- Players commit extensive hours, often 40-100+ for completion, due to the game's breadth of content and the need to develop Mother Base. Many noted an average to heavy grind, especially when pursuing 100% completion or repeating missions for resources.
- Enemies dynamically learn and adapt to player tactics, acquiring new gear like helmets for headshots or night-vision for night infiltrations. This intelligent AI constantly challenges players, demanding frequent changes in strategy and experimentation with different approaches.
Performance:
- Players consistently praise the game's exceptional optimization, allowing it to run smoothly on very low-end PCs, integrated graphics, older consoles (like PS3), and modern handheld devices such as the Steam Deck. This broad compatibility makes the game accessible to many users.
- The game defaults to a 60 frames per second cap, a common feature for console ports. Players report that this limit can be successfully bypassed by modifying a configuration file, enabling higher refresh rates for those with compatible monitors.
- Despite its release date, the game's Fox Engine is consistently lauded for its ability to deliver stunning visuals, including high detail in environments, realistic animations, and effective lighting. The graphics are considered to hold up well against contemporary titles.
- While some players praise the game as bug-free, others report significant technical problems. These issues include critical bugs causing loss of game progress, platform-specific black screen problems on Linux, and persistent file validation errors on Steam.
- Users with high-end PC setups consistently report rock-solid performance, achieving steady, high frame rates at maximum settings. Critically, these players experience no stutters, frame drops, or screen tearing even after hundreds of hours of gameplay.
Recommendations:
- Players overwhelmingly rate the game highly, considering it a must-play title and a masterpiece despite its flaws. Many describe it as an unforgettable experience worth the full price.
- While many consider the game worth its full price, it is often recommended to purchase it during a sale. The Definitive Experience version is specifically advised for its inclusion of the Ground Zeroes chapter.
- It's strongly recommended that players complete Metal Gear Solid V: Ground Zeroes before starting The Phantom Pain, as it serves as an essential prologue to the main story.
- Some feedback indicates the PC experience may not be polished, with some users recommending against buying it. For those determined to play, modding is suggested to address issues like resource grinding and to explore different playstyles.
Miscellaneous:
- Despite its position late in the Metal Gear saga, many players found MGSV to be an accessible and captivating introduction to the franchise. It successfully drew in newcomers, inspiring them to explore the rich lore and older titles, effectively becoming a gateway to the broader Metal Gear universe.
- Reviewers often noted that a deep understanding of the extensive Metal Gear lore is crucial for fully appreciating and comprehending MGSV's intricate plot, especially Chapter 2. Many resorted to external resources or prior series knowledge to overcome initial confusion, indicating the story can be less accessible to those unfamiliar with the franchise's history.
- The game is praised for its intricate plot twists and exploration of profound themes such as identity, loss, and the nature of a hero's legacy, epitomized by the revelation of Venom Snake. It delves into the moral ambiguity of Big Boss and how the player embodies his legend, resonating deeply with fans of complex storytelling in the Metal Gear universe.
- Players consistently report investing hundreds of hours into the game, engaging in multiple playthroughs, and even repurchasing it across different platforms years after its initial release. This demonstrates exceptional long-term appeal and replayability, with many still finding new content or reasons to revisit the game.
- Released nearly a decade ago, MGSV is widely regarded as an enduring classic, with its gameplay mechanics and thematic depth holding up remarkably well against contemporary titles. Many players return to it years later, appreciating its quality in contrast to current industry trends.
Similar games
Blend with other games
97%METAL GEAR SOLID 3: Snake Eater - Master Collection Version
97%METAL GEAR SOLID 2: Sons of Liberty - Master Collection Version
95%METAL GEAR SOLID - Master Collection Version
95%METAL GEAR SOLID Δ: SNAKE EATER
93%Metro Exodus
93%HITMAN™ 2
93%HITMAN™
93%Sniper Elite 3
93%Sniper Elite 5
92%Reverse Collapse: Code Name Bakery
92%Alpha Protocol™
92%The Last of Us™ Part II Remastered