DYSMANTLE: Underworld Review Summary

Last updated: 2026-04-22
  • DLC highly recommended for fans
  • Fast travel between campfires
  • Enjoyable gameplay experience
  • Confusing and convoluted map design
  • Repetitive and tedious gameplay
  • Lack of new content
DYSMANTLE: Underworld header

Emotions

Archetypes

What players like:

Common complaints:

Gameplay feedback:

Performance notes:

Recommendations:

Other player notes:

  • -

    No data available

Review evidence

Why players say this

What players like

DLC highly recommended: Players consistently praise the DLC, describing it as great value for money and an enjoyable experience overall.

Fast travel between campfires: The fast travel feature between campfires is highlighted as a useful and time-saving addition that enhances the base game.

Enjoyable gameplay experience: Players find the overall gameplay experience enjoyable, including the main content and the added quests and stories.

Large new map added: The DLC introduces a large new map, providing a fresh and expansive area for players to explore.

Satisfying to complete: Players find the DLC satisfying to explore and complete, adding to the overall enjoyment of the game.

Common complaints

Confusing and convoluted map design: Many players found the map difficult to navigate, often describing it as confusing, convoluted, and maze-like. The design was criticized for being small, cramped, and tedious to explore.

Lack of new content: Players expressed disappointment with the lack of new bosses, monsters, and achievements. The DLC was seen as not offering enough new content to justify its price.

Repetitive and tedious gameplay: The gameplay was criticized for being long, tedious, and repetitive. Players felt that the DLC lacked innovation and interesting gameplay mechanics.

Annoying and difficult enemies: Players found some of the new enemies to be annoying and difficult to deal with, requiring specific weapons or strategies to defeat.

Disappointing compared to base game: Many players felt that the DLC was disappointing compared to the base game, lacking the charm and spark that made the original game enjoyable.

Gameplay and performance

New features and content: The update introduces a variety of new features, including weapons, gear, story content, and building options. These additions enhance gameplay and provide players with more tools and activities.

Enemy strategy requirements: Enemies now require specific strategies and weapons to defeat, adding a layer of complexity to combat. This includes enemies with armor that needs specific weapons to break.

Map design issues: The map design has been criticized for being confusing and convoluted, making navigation difficult and frustrating for players.

RPG and progression systems: The update enhances RPG elements and progression systems, providing more depth and options for character development and gameplay progression.

Skill and recipe updates: Players can unlock new skills and learn new recipes, which adds depth to the progression system and gives more options for character development and crafting.

Minor bugs reported: Some players have reported encountering minor bugs while playing the game. These issues, although not game-breaking, can affect the overall gaming experience.

Recommendations

DLC recommended for fans: The DLC is highly recommended for fans of the base game and adventure lovers. It is suggested to get the DLC during a new playthrough to fully enjoy the new features.

Avoid or wait for updates: Some players advise against buying or supporting the DLC in its current state. They suggest waiting for patches and updates to fix major issues and bugs.

Requests for future content: Players have expressed interest in future DLCs adding more to the game's history and introducing new maps, features, weapons, and stories. There are also suggestions for adding difficulty levels and multiplayer options.

Buy on sale: Many players suggest purchasing the game or DLC on sale for a better price. This indicates that while the content is valued, it might not be worth the full price for everyone.

Start new save for DLC: To fully integrate and enjoy the DLC, players recommend starting a new game save. This allows the new content to blend seamlessly with the overall playthrough.

Buying context

Community fair range: $20.00 - $30.00.

Game completion: 90.0h.

Story completion: 10.0h.

The game starts fun with a good progression system but can become tedious due to repetitive tasks; multiplayer significantly enhances the experience.

Reported time to anchor: 1h.

Friction: Repetitive tasks; Tedious traversal; Fighting the same enemies repeatedly.

Unlock drivers: Multiplayer; Cooperative play; New link towers.

Player profiles

Franchise Fan: Committed and frequent player of the developer's games. Motivation: Loyalty to the game franchise and developer. Stance: no buy.

Explorer: Enjoys exploring and trying out new features and areas. Motivation: Exploration and discovery of new content. Stance: sale.

Completionist: Systematic and thorough, aiming to complete all tasks and collectibles. Motivation: Completing all game content and challenges. Stance: deep sale.

Extra review signals

Monetization: The DLC for Dysmantle has received mixed reviews. While some players appreciate the additional content and find it worth the price, others feel that it introduces pay-to-win mechanics and offers poor value for money. The pay-to-win elements, such as enhanced planting and the ability to plant mana beads, are particularly concerning as they can significantly impact the gameplay experience. Additionally, the hotfix that restricts these features to DLC owners has soured the experience for some players, making them feel forced to purchase the DLC to fully enjoy the base game. Overall, the DLC has left a portion of the player base dissatisfied and considering stopping play altogether.