Propnight Review Summary

While its novel prop transform concept is fun with friends, the game suffers from poor servers, balance issues, matchmaking problems, a toxic community, and shut down without refunds.

Great with friends: A significant number of players mention the game is especially fun when played with friends or in co-op. It is described as a favorite social game, enhancing enjoyment through shared experiences.

Game widely considered fun: The majority of reviewers agree the game is fun, enjoyable, and immersive. Many describe it as thrilling, unique, and generally excellent, making it a highly praised title overall.

Novel and unique concept: Reviewers frequently praise the original and novel premise of the game, combining hide-and-seek with asymmetric multiplayer. The innovative concept and fresh mechanics are highlighted as key strengths.

Visuals and art praised: Many reviewers appreciate the game's visual style, noting beautiful maps and a pleasing cartoon art style. The graphics contribute positively to the overall experience.

Better than Dead by Daylight: Players consider the game more interesting and appealing than Dead by Daylight, citing better characters and a cuter, more laid-back atmosphere. It is recommended for fans of both prop hunt and DBD.

Game permanently shut down: Multiple clusters indicate the game was permanently shut down, leaving players unable to access the game they purchased, with no refunds or restoration options. This is the most critical issue, affecting the game's existence entirely.

Poor servers and balance: Players consistently report poor server stability and severe balance problems, with killers or survivors having unfair advantages depending on the patch. Specific issues like overpowered impostor killers and frustrating MMR systems worsen the experience.

Matchmaking and queue issues: Low player counts lead to extremely long queue times and ineffective matchmaking, with MMR pairings that are unfair. This is compounded by players avoiding the killer role, causing further delays.

Toxic player community: Toxic behavior, including insults and harassment in voice chat, is a major deterrent, especially for new players. This creates a hostile environment that drives players away.

Bugs and unfinished state: The game is described as unfinished with numerous bugs that directly affect gameplay, such as survivors incorrectly seeing gates open or being unable to repair generators. Lack of updates leaves these issues unfixed.

Hide-and-seek asymmetric multiplayer: The game combines hide-and-seek mechanics with asymmetric multiplayer, emphasizing both hiding and hunting. Players can either hide as survivors or hunt as the killer.

Asymmetric 4v1 horror gameplay: The game is an asymmetric multiplayer survival-horror experience where one killer faces four survivors. Each killer has unique abilities, and survivors can use items and obstacles to stun the killer.

Survivors transform into props: Survivors can transform into various environment props, such as chairs, crates, pumpkins, or small objects, to hide from the killer. This prop-hunt mechanic is a core gameplay feature.

Generator repair objectives: Survivors must repair generators to escape, a mechanic directly borrowed from Dead by Daylight. This objective drives the survivor gameplay loop.

Stun mechanic for survivors: Survivors can stun the killer using doors, items, or by jumping on top of them as a prop. This stun mechanic provides a counterplay option for survivors.

Optimization needs improvement: Multiple players note suboptimal performance, including frame rate caps at 60, network problems, and general lack of optimization. Even where the game runs better than a test server, further optimization is still needed.

Manual fixes for frame rate: A player provided workarounds such as editing configuration files and NVIDIA settings to disable V-Sync or uncap frame rate to improve performance. This shows there are manual fixes for optimization issues.

QTE input delay: Input delay is reported in quick-time events (QTEs), which can frustrate players and reduce responsiveness. This is a gameplay-specific issue affecting a certain mechanic.

Optimization good on some systems: One player notes good optimization and that the game works without a VPN, contrasting with others' performance complaints. This suggests performance may vary by system or region.

Graphics simple but bright: The graphics on Unreal Engine are described as simple but bright. This indicates visual style is clean but could be more complex.

Game unplayable, just nostalgia: Multiple clusters note the game is no longer playable due to server closures. It is only recommended as a nostalgic memory, not as an active game.

Avoid buying and refund: Several clusters advise against buying from this developer and recommend refunds. There is strong negative sentiment toward the developer's practices.

Buy only on sale: The game's value is questioned; some say it is not worth full price. It is recommended to buy only on sale or if you have extra money.

Best played with friends: The game is recommended for playing with friends, particularly in private matches. It is a fun activity for a few evenings but not for extended play.

Recommended for DBD fans: The game is repeatedly recommended for players who enjoy Dead by Daylight and prop hunt modes. It appeals to those who like asymmetric multiplayer and hide-and-seek gameplay.

Community fair range: $4.00 - $8.00.

The game is immediately fun when played with friends, but becomes less enjoyable over time due to tedious progression, poor matchmaking for beginners, and a disliked update that degrades the experience.

Friction: Friends required for fun; Poor beginner matchmaking; Lack of progression system; Tedious coin grinding; Disliked update ruining gameplay.

Unlock drivers: Playing with friends; Ignoring matchmaking rating; Muting random players; Avoiding the REBORN update.

Social Group Player: Group play, casual, MMR-agnostic. Motivation: Social fun and laughter with friends. Stance: buy.

Competitive Veteran: Competitive, solo or group, frustrated by imbalance. Motivation: Desire for fair competition and ranked progression. Stance: no buy.

Game shutdown without refunds: The game was shut down by its developers, with servers closed and no refunds offered, leaving purchased copies unplayable. The shutdown was abrupt and the community's requests for a peer-to-peer mode or code handover were ignored, with Discord servers deleted on shutdown day.

No refunds after shutdown: The game was shut down after a limited time without offering refunds, leaving players who paid with no compensation. This lack of refunds was a major point of frustration.

Prop hunt and horror mix: The game was described as a mix of Dead by Daylight and prop hunt modes from Garry's Mod or CS:GO, with a unique atmosphere that some found distinct from DBD. These comparisons highlight its niche appeal in the asymmetrical horror genre.

Comparisons to DBD: Reviewers made direct comparisons to Dead by Daylight, with some saying it was more interesting and had better characters, while others felt the atmosphere was different. Overall, the game shared the same genre but had a unique identity.

Regional player and language issues: The player base was largely from Japan and Korea, with some complaints about Korean players' behavior and a perceived priority on Western regions over CIS. The game lacked official Chinese localization, adding a language barrier.