
What players like:
Common complaints:
Gameplay feedback:
Performance notes:
Recommendations:
Other player notes:












Review evidence
Excellent humor and world-design: Many reviewers highlight the game's humor, comparing it favorably to previous Borderlands titles, especially Borderlands 3. The game world is vibrant and well-designed, with improved navigation and level design. Many found the gameplay loop addictive, with satisfying loot and character progression.
Satisfying gunplay and magic system: The game retains the core Borderlands gameplay while introducing new elements like spells and improved melee combat. Reviewers found the gunplay satisfying and the addition of spells a refreshing change from grenades. The combination of shooting and magic adds a new layer of strategy and fun to the combat.
Tiny Tina's chaotic DM presence: Tiny Tina's presence as the Dungeon Master is a major highlight, bringing a unique and chaotic element to the narrative. The game is full of references and parodies of tabletop RPGs, appealing to fans of D&D. The writing is amusing, with unexpected twists and turns that keep the gameplay fresh and exciting.
Enjoyable story and rewarding loot: The game provides an enjoyable story that lets you focus on killing and looting. Loot drops feel meaningful, making looting rewarding. The game is fun and mindless to play, and is forgiving, even for players not skilled at FPS games.
Familiar Borderlands-style gameplay: The game has a similar "game loop" and mechanics to Borderlands. The game features Torgue in the graphical style of Borderlands 3. The instance battles are quick to start and complete, providing accessible Borderlands-style combat.
Repetitive endgame, poor DLCs: Many reviewers criticized the endgame content, DLCs, and overall replayability. The Chaos Chamber and other endgame activities become repetitive and grindy, while the DLCs offer little substantial new content and are often considered overpriced. The game lacks a New Game+ mode and other features that would extend its longevity.
Lacks innovation and polish: Many reviewers felt the game lacked innovation and polish, feeling more like a DLC or reskin than a full-fledged title. The game reuses assets from previous Borderlands games, and many mechanics feel underdeveloped or poorly implemented. Some reviewers also noted the game felt rushed and unfinished.
Poor weapon variety and balance: Many reviewers expressed dissatisfaction with the weapon variety, balance, and overall gunplay. Weapons often feel weak, ineffective, and uninspired, with many being reskins of previous Borderlands games. Some weapon types are underpowered, while others are overpowered, leading to a lack of meaningful choices and a less enjoyable combat experience.
Tedious map and level design: The game's level design, map, and overworld mechanics were frequently criticized. The overworld map feels tedious and repetitive, while the level design is often convoluted and uninspired. The lack of vehicles and fast travel points exacerbates these issues, making exploration and navigation frustrating.
Limited build diversity/customization: Reviewers noted a lack of build diversity and meaningful character customization options. Skill trees are smaller and less impactful than in previous games, limiting the ability to create unique and effective builds. The game also lacks features like a damage calculator and loadout slots, making it difficult to optimize and switch between builds.
Core looter-shooter gameplay: The core gameplay loop revolves around shooting enemies, collecting loot, and character progression, similar to the Borderlands series. Players engage in quests, dungeons, and boss fights, with enemies and loot scaling to the player's level. Some reviewers found the gameplay loop simple and repetitive.
Flexible dual-class system: The game features a dual-class system that allows players to combine classes for build customization and experimentation. Each class has a skill tree, and multiclassing unlocks additional abilities and playstyles. However, some reviewers felt that the skill trees lacked depth.
Tabletop-inspired overworld map: The game features a tabletop-inspired overworld map for navigation, resembling a D&D board. While offering exploration and side quests, some find it repetitive due to limited tilesets and arena-style random encounters. The overworld serves as a central hub and a break between larger locations.
Spells replace grenades: Grenades have been replaced with spells that operate on a cooldown system, adding a magical element to combat. Players can use a variety of spells with different effects, similar to grenades in previous Borderlands games. The game also features melee weapons, crossbows, and magical wards.
Viable melee weapon options: The game features melee weapons, which are more useful than in previous Borderlands games, enabling melee-focused builds. However, some reviewers found melee weapons underpowered compared to guns, making melee classes less viable. Melee combat is a separate mechanic with its own features, offering interesting combinations.
Inconsistent, demanding PC performance: Performance is inconsistent and demanding. Many players report experiencing stutters, frame rate drops, lag, and crashes, even on capable hardware. Some suggest the game is not well-optimized, and requires settings adjustments or manual patching to achieve acceptable performance, while others report smooth performance.
Slow loading, autosave stutters: The game suffers from slow loading times for shaders and textures, impacting the initial startup and overall immersion. Additionally, frequent autosaving can cause performance hiccups.
Overwhelming, flashy visual effects: The game's flashy graphics, particularly the abundance of magic spells and particle effects, can be overwhelming and cause dizziness for some players. The visual clutter can also obscure visibility during combat, especially in multiplayer.
Multiplayer bugs and lag: Players have reported bugs in multiplayer mode, such as disappearing inventory images and incorrect item stats. Additionally, some users experience significant lag during online play, even with high-speed internet connections.
Extensive graphics tweaking needed: Players are spending significant time tweaking graphics settings to optimize performance, indicating optimization issues. Texture filtering and upscaling settings have a surprising impact on performance, with some maps exhibiting particularly bad surface optimization.
Buy on sale only: A common sentiment is that the game is only worth buying on sale. Many reviewers feel the full price is too high for the content offered, but a significant discount makes it a worthwhile purchase, especially for fans or those seeking a casual experience. Some even suggest specific price points.
Recommended for Borderlands fans: Many reviewers recommend the game specifically to fans of the Borderlands series, especially those who enjoyed Borderlands 2 or 3, or the Tiny Tina's Assault on Dragon Keep DLC. Some suggest newcomers might enjoy it as well, while others advise starting with earlier titles. Some reviewers express hope for a sequel.
Strongly negative opinions (review-bombing?): Some reviewers express strong negative opinions, stating they wouldn't enjoy the game even if it were free, regretting their purchase, or feeling they should be compensated for playing it. These reviews often lack specific details and may indicate review bombing.
Start with Borderlands 2/3: Some reviewers suggest that players new to the Borderlands franchise should start with Borderlands 2 or 3 instead of this title. They believe those games offer a better introduction to the series' core mechanics and overall experience. Some reviewers express hope that Borderlands 4 will be better.
More fun with friends: Several reviewers mention that the game is more enjoyable when played with friends in co-op mode. Playing with others enhances the overall experience and can make the game more fun. However, some reviewers report connection issues in 4-player co-op.
Borderlands meets high fantasy: The game blends Borderlands' signature art style, humor, and gunplay with a D&D-inspired high fantasy setting. Visually, it resembles Borderlands 3 but with a brighter, more diverse color palette. The game is set within a tabletop game in the Borderlands universe.
Inclusion of LGBTQ+ themes: The game features themes of prejudice and acceptance, with some reviewers noting a high proportion of LGBTQ+ characters. Some found the representation unbalanced, while others considered complaints about 'woke pandering' to be mostly ignorable.
Possible development issues: Some reviewers speculate that development issues, possibly related to the pandemic or studio practices, may have impacted the game's quality.
Missing New Game+ mode: The game lacks a 'True Fatemaker Mode' (New Game+), which may disappoint players looking for increased replayability with their existing characters.
Request for Turkish support: One reviewer requests Turkish language support to broaden the game's appeal to Turkish-speaking players.