Players experience frustration primarily due to technical issues like frequent crashes, freezes, and poor performance (e.g., lack of 60fps or 16:9 support). Gameplay mechanics such as the junction system, magic drawing, and Triple Triad are criticized for being overly complex, tedious, or poorly explained, leading to a steep learning curve and disrupted pacing.
Nostalgia is driven by personal connections to the game, such as childhood memories, long-term replayability, and emotional attachment to its story, characters, and music. Many players revisit the game as adults, reflecting on its impact during their formative years and appreciating its role in their gaming journey.
Disappointment stems from the remaster's poor execution, including unmet expectations for modern features (e.g., analog controls, voice acting), technical flaws (e.g., crashes, poor performance), and minimal improvements over the original. Players also criticize the removal of content (e.g., Chocobo World) and the game's failure to adapt to contemporary standards.
Satisfaction arises from the remaster's quality-of-life improvements, such as the 3x speed mode, visual upgrades, and added cheats, which enhance gameplay. Players also appreciate the timeless story, rewarding progression once mechanics are mastered, and the ability to revisit a classic with modern conveniences.
Players appreciate the game's unique mechanics (e.g., Junction system, Triple Triad), mature storytelling, and character depth. The remaster's preservation of the original art style and modern enhancements (e.g., speed-up feature) are also praised for making the game more accessible without compromising its identity.
Verdict
Mixed
Summary
Positive 68% · Negative 32%. Score: 32 / 100
Positives:
The remastered version is widely appreciated for its modern quality-of-life improvements, such as the 3x speed mode, enhanced graphics, and better controller support. These updates make the game more accessible and enjoyable for contemporary players.
The 3x speed mode and other speed-related features are praised for reducing tedious grinding and making the game more enjoyable, particularly for completionists or players revisiting the game.
The inclusion of cheats, such as max stats or invincibility modes, is appreciated for allowing players to tailor the difficulty to their preferences. This feature makes the game more accessible to a broader audience.
Players consistently highlight the engaging and deep combat system, particularly the Junction and GF mechanics, which become more enjoyable as they are mastered. The strategic elements and customization options are frequently mentioned as standout features.
The narrative, character development, and emotional depth of the story are frequently praised. Players highlight the unique and engaging plot, well-written characters, and the memorable romance between Squall and Rinoa as key strengths.
Negatives:
The remastered version of the game is criticized for its inconsistent graphics, with updated 3D character models clashing with low-resolution, untouched backgrounds. Players feel it lacks meaningful improvements and is overpriced for its quality.
The gameplay feels slow, grindy, and outdated compared to modern titles, with clunky mechanics, excessive encounters, and a lack of analog controls. Some systems, like magic drawing, are seen as tedious and poorly balanced.
The Junction system is widely criticized for being overly complex, tedious, and unintuitive, requiring frequent GF and magic swapping. Many players find it frustrating and poorly explained, especially at the start.
The game suffers from frequent crashes, freezes, and initialization errors, particularly on modern systems like Windows 10/11. It also lacks proper widescreen support and runs at low FPS (15-30).
The leveling and enemy-scaling system is flawed, as enemies adapt to the player's level, making grinding counterproductive. This creates frustration, especially for players unfamiliar with the mechanics.
Gameplay:
The GF (Guardian Forces) system is central to character progression, offering stat boosts, unique abilities, and magic refinement. Players equip GFs to unlock combat skills and customize builds, though the system requires strategic management of summon sequences and animations.
The game employs a turn-based combat system with the Active Time Battle (ATB) mechanic, emphasizing strategic depth through timing and ability sequencing. This hybrid approach distinguishes it from traditional turn-based RPGs.
Magic is a consumable resource extracted from enemies or world points, requiring strategic farming. The draw system’s constraints force players to balance spell usage and resource management, adding a layer of challenge.
Triple Triad is a popular side activity with evolving rules, offering practical benefits like powerful weapons and stat boosts. Its strategic depth and optional nature make it a standout feature for exploration and progression.
Enemies and bosses scale with the player’s level, creating a dynamic difficulty curve. While this prevents trivialization, it can lead to punishing gameplay if players grind excessively or misuse leveling mechanics.
Performance:
Many players report the game failing to launch, crashing frequently, or experiencing initialization errors, particularly on newer Windows versions. These issues significantly hinder gameplay accessibility.
The remaster receives mixed feedback on graphical improvements, with praise for updated character models but criticism for unchanged or blurry backgrounds and cutscenes. Performance issues like poor optimization and lack of modern display support are frequently mentioned.
The game is criticized for being locked to 15-30 FPS, especially during combat and cutscenes, with minimal improvements even on high-end hardware. The 3x speed boost feature is noted as a partial workaround.
While the game runs well on modern high-end hardware and handheld devices like the Steam Deck, it also performs adequately on older systems. However, stability varies across configurations.
Players encounter issues with full-screen/widescreen functionality, including unfixable zoomed-in displays and incompatibility with 16:9 resolutions. Poor optimization for modern monitors exacerbates these problems.
Recommendations:
The game is overwhelmingly recommended for fans of the Final Fantasy series, classic JRPGs, and those who prioritize story and nostalgia. Many reviews emphasize its appeal to longtime fans rather than newcomers due to its unique mechanics and emotional storytelling.
Multiple reviews suggest purchasing the game only during sales (e.g., 50% off) or for $20 or less, citing its value as limited at full price. This is especially true for non-nostalgic players or those less invested in the story.
The remastered version is recommended for first-time players due to modern hardware compatibility, accessibility, and quality-of-life improvements. However, purists or those familiar with the original may prefer the PS1 version or emulation.
Reviews frequently recommend modding the original PC version or using community mods (e.g., AngelWing) to improve visuals, resolution, or gameplay. The remaster is seen as less mod-friendly, making the 2013 version a fallback for modders.
While not universally recommended, the game is suggested for adults who disliked it as children, players who enjoy deep systems, or those seeking a timeless classic from an earlier era of gaming.
Miscellaneous:
Players highlight the use of mods (e.g., Ultima Mod) to address music and other remaster problems, despite legal risks and setup effort. Community resources like qhimm and McIndus are frequently cited as valuable support.
Players express dissatisfaction with Square Enix’s approach to the remaster, arguing it failed to distinguish between a remaster and a redesign/remake.
Criticism focuses on the remaster retaining PS1-era character models and environments, with minimal improvements over the original or PSP versions.
The remaster’s built-in cheat menu is noted as a controversial addition, with some players using it to bypass challenging content like final bosses.
Technical issues with the game launcher and file setup are reported as a recurring frustration, impacting the initial experience for players.