
What players like:
Common complaints:
Gameplay feedback:
Performance notes:
Recommendations:
Other player notes:
Review evidence
A blast with friends and full of potential, but abandoned by devs, buggy, and poorly optimized to the point of unplayability.
Game is highly enjoyable: A substantial number of reviewers described the game as very good, enjoyable, or even the best they've played. This indicates strong overall satisfaction.
Game has great potential: Many reviewers praised the game's concept and potential, noting it could be excellent. This sentiment was frequently expressed across multiple reviews.
Fun with friends: Players consistently reported that the game is much more enjoyable when played with friends or partners. The social aspect significantly enhances the experience.
Modding community extends life: The modding community is praised for keeping the game fresh and alive with constant changes. This contributes to long-term engagement.
Game abandoned by developers: The game was abandoned by its developers, often during Early Access, with no further updates or support. This is the most frequently cited issue, indicating a complete halt in development.
Game is buggy and unplayable: Players report numerous bugs, glitches, and crashes that make the game unstable and often unplayable, even on high-end systems. The game is described as a buggy, broken mess with poor optimization.
Official servers are closed: The official servers have been shut down, making the game unplayable in its intended online mode. Players are left with no official servers to join, forcing them to rely on single-player or modded alternatives.
Single player mode is broken: The single-player version of the game is broken and unplayable due to fatal errors and other issues. This is a significant problem for players who cannot or do not want to play online.
Sailing and ocean exploration: Players frequently mention sailing across an open ocean, navigating to islands, and engaging in sea adventures. This core gameplay loop is highlighted as a major feature of the game.
Base building mechanics: The game includes a robust base building system with foundations, walls, and claiming land. This is a common feature noted by many players, emphasizing the construction aspect.
Ship building and customization: Players can build and customize ships to their liking, which is a standout feature. The ability to design ships freely is frequently praised and considered a key part of the gameplay.
Animal taming and breeding: The game allows taming and breeding animals, similar to ARK. This mechanic is mentioned alongside farming and ship building, indicating a diverse set of activities.
Naval combat with cannons: Ship-to-ship combat with cannons is a significant feature, including PvP on ground and at sea. This adds a strategic layer to the sailing experience.
Poor optimization widespread: A large number of reviews highlight the game's poor optimization, with players experiencing low FPS, stuttering, and slow rendering even on high-end PCs. The performance issues are described as extreme and catastrophic, affecting gameplay significantly.
Server lag and instability: Players frequently encounter server lag, rubber-banding, disconnections, and high ping, which are especially problematic in PvP and at launch. Server issues have prevented many from entering the game and cause frequent rollbacks and desync.
Frequent crashes reported: Many players report the game crashing frequently, including to desktop, during small movements, and in various scenarios like traveling, dying, or placing machines. This issue is severe enough to make the game unplayable for some, especially on Xbox.
Do not buy: Many reviewers strongly advise against purchasing the game, citing it as a waste of money and time. The game is described as a bad purchase not worth any price, even on sale.
Not worth full price: The game is considered overpriced, with reviewers suggesting it is not worth buying at full price. Waiting for a sale is frequently recommended as a better option.
Use private servers: Players recommend using unofficial, private, or modded servers for the best experience, as official servers are considered problematic. This is especially advised for those playing with friends.
Community fair range: $0.00 - $10.00.
Session length: 8.0h.
The game initially frustrates players but becomes enjoyable once they get used to it, especially when playing with friends or with mods. However, some players find the fun drops after the tutorial or never clicks solo.
Friction: early frustration; clunky controls; critical bugs; solo boredom; multiplayer restrictions; tutorial island.
Unlock drivers: getting used to the game; playing with friends; mods; private servers; progression.
The Hopeful Veteran: Tries both PvP and PvE, but spends time monitoring updates and enduring bugs. Motivation: Hope for the game to realize its potential despite developer neglect. Stance: deep sale.
The Excluded Soloist: Attempts to play solo or with a small group, focusing on PvE and building, but is constantly thwarted by grind and griefing. Motivation: Desire for a solo survival experience that the game fails to provide. Stance: no buy.
The Co-op Sandbox Sailor: Plays on PvE servers or private modded servers with friends, focusing on building, farming, and sailing, often adjusting rates to reduce grind. Motivation: Cooperative building, sailing, and exploration in a PvE environment with friends. Stance: sale.
The Windows <8GB VRAM cohort reports severe instability, including freezing, loading failures, and continuous crashes.
Windows <8GB VRAM: negative. Users report freezing on respawn, difficulty loading into the game, and continuous crashes.
Monetization: The game is widely perceived as a cash grab, with evidence of pay-to-win assets and a paid pseudo-DLC. Players also report that the developers abandoned the game after early access, reinforcing the predatory monetization concerns.
Compared to ARK Survival: The game is frequently compared to ARK: Survival Evolved, with many noting it feels like a stripped-down or re-skinned version. Some reviewers consider it worse, while others find it better in certain aspects.
Community keeps game alive: The modding community and private servers are the only things keeping the game alive. Without them, the game would be completely dead due to lack of official support.
Should be removed from store: Some reviewers believe the game should be removed from the Steam store or made free, given its abandoned state. This reflects frustration with the game's continued sale despite being unplayable.