The Sinking City Remastered Review Summary

Last updated: 2026-07-06
Review summary
  • Excellent Lovecraftian atmosphere
  • Satisfying detective gameplay
  • Engaging and interesting story
  • Combat is clunky and unresponsive
  • Remaster has major technical issues
  • Gameplay is repetitive and boring
The Sinking City Remastered header

Categories

Open-World ExplorationInvestigative GameplayLovecraftian HorrorAtmospheric HorrorDetectiveAction-AdventureMultiple EndingsPsychological Horror

Emotions

Archetypes

Hardware

Windows 12-15GB VRAMpositiveWindows 8-11GB VRAMnegative

Snapshot History

Positive
Negative
285
66%
34%
438
60%
40%
Sample precision
Helpful reviews
88%
Unhelpful reviews
12%
Protest reviews
1%
Positive points
930
Negative points
1021
Gameplay points
537
Perf. points
95
Rec. points
222
Misc points
2
Point
Excellent Lovecraftian atmosphere
Description
The Lovecraftian atmosphere, lore, and references are consistently praised, with many players highlighting the thick, oppressive atmosphere and authentic portrayal of cosmic horror. This is the most frequently mentioned positive aspect.
Importance
57%
Satisfying detective gameplay
Description
The game is praised as a detective investigation game with a Lovecraftian twist, featuring satisfying detective and puzzle mechanics. The combination of detective gameplay and horror is a key selling point.
Importance
45%
Engaging and interesting story
Description
The main story is described as interesting, engaging, and well-told, with both narrative and environmental storytelling receiving high marks. Players find the story compelling despite some noting it is not entirely unique.
Importance
35%
Good side quests and cases
Description
Side quests and side cases are generally well-received, with many being memorable and having their own stories. Some specific quests, like the Throgmorton quest, are highlighted as particularly good.
Importance
31%
Solid and functional gameplay
Description
The gameplay is considered functional and solid, with the game being good overall despite minor bugs. Players find it enjoyable and addictive.
Importance
24%
Engaging Mind Palace mechanics
Description
The Mind Palace investigation mechanics, used for organizing clues and making deductions, are highly engaging and make players feel like real detectives. This is a standout feature of the gameplay.
Importance
21%
Improved visuals in remaster
Description
The remastered version is noted for having better graphics and visuals, as well as fixing many issues. The visual upgrade is considered worth it, enhancing the overall experience.
Importance
17%