
What players like:
Common complaints:
Gameplay feedback:
Performance notes:
Recommendations:
Other player notes:












Review evidence
The DLC offers massive content, great value, and ocean exploration, but it is extremely buggy, crashing often at startup and on AMD GPUs.
DLC praised for massive content: The dominant theme across many clusters is that the DLC delivers an enormous volume of content, frequently compared to or exceeding full games. Reviewers repeatedly emphasize that it is well worth the price and a huge improvement to the overall experience.
Excellent value for the price: Many reviewers highlight that both the game and the DLC offer a huge amount of content for their price, making them highly worth it. The value proposition is a recurring theme.
Base game is fun and huge: The main game itself is considered extremely fun, enjoyable, and already massive in content. Reviewers note it was pleasant even before the DLC and offers over 100 hours of gameplay.
Beautiful sea and underwater world: The visual depiction of the ocean, both above and below the surface, is repeatedly described as beautiful and incredible. Exploring these environments is considered pleasant and fascinating.
Expansion is great and fairly priced: Reviewers describe the expansion as awesome and mind-blowing, and consider its pricing fair relative to what it offers. The overall sentiment toward the expansion is highly positive.
DLC is extremely buggy: Players report that the DLC is riddled with bugs, crashes, and clipping issues. Many feel the DLC was released without proper testing.
Crashes on startup: The game crashes immediately upon launching or loading, making it impossible to enter the game. This affects both base game and DLC users.
Many general bugs: The game is described as full of bugs and errors, with some players noting that issues persist or have worsened after updates.
Game unplayable due to bugs: Technical issues have made the game completely unplayable for many players, who describe it as broken.
DLC breaks base game: Installing the DLC has corrupted saves and rendered both the DLC and the base game unplayable. Players report crashes when loading saves after purchasing the DLC.
Ocean exploration added by DLC: The DLC introduces a large ocean area that players can explore by ship, significantly expanding the map compared to the base game. This includes sailing and underwater exploration as new mechanics.
Ship sailing and naval combat: Players can sail ships on the ocean, engage in naval battles with friendly and enemy ships, and even sink enemy vessels. Ship building is also a feature, allowing players to construct their own ships.
Open world exploration: The game is set in a large, detailed open world that can be freely explored. The DLC further expands the map, making it several times larger than the base game.
Main story and quests: The game has a main storyline with quests, cutscenes, and progression leading to an ending. The DLC adds new storylines for all three playable characters.
Underwater diving and exploration: The game includes diving mechanics that allow players to explore the underwater world, including the deep sea floor. This is part of both the base game and the DLC.
AMD 9000 series GPU incompatibility: The game fails to launch or run on AMD 9000 series GPUs after the DLC update, with multiple reports confirming the issue. This affects a broad user base and renders the game unplayable on these cards.
Crashes during specific gameplay actions: Players experience crashes when resurrecting, entering Pailune or Drake's Fall Castle, fast traveling, sailing to the island, or after 25 bales. These progression-blocking crashes are frequent.
Terrain and texture bugs on AMD: Terrain geometry bugs and stretched landscape textures occur on AMD cards like the 9070 XT, sometimes extending 50-100 meters upward. Rolling back drivers to version 26.8.1 fixes the issue.
Poor optimization and stuttering: The game suffers from poor optimization, stuttering, and freezes in open areas, and feels sluggish to many players. Performance issues occur even on high-end hardware.
Graphics corruption on Radeon GPUs: Severe graphics corruption, including broken backgrounds and visual glitches, occurs on Radeon GPUs after installing the DLC. The issue affects multiple users and persists despite patches.
DLC offers excellent value: Many reviewers strongly recommend the DLC, citing its large content volume relative to price. It is described as worth the money, a steal, and comparable to or better than many full games.
Wait for bug fixes: Multiple reviewers advise waiting for patches before playing or buying due to bugs. Some suggest waiting a week, a month, or for a day-one patch to sort out issues.
Base game highly recommended: Reviewers give the base game positive recommendations, including a 10/10 score and GOTY praise. It is recommended for fans of the series and for RPG, MMO, story, or casual players.
DLC is mediocre or avoid: A minority of reviewers criticize the DLC as mediocre and not worth the asking price. They advise against buying it, especially for those who liked the base game.
Recommended for specific playstyles: Reviewers recommend the game or DLC for players interested in ship building, custom house building, new storylines, or exploration. Fans of open-world exploration and the base game's exploration aspect are specifically mentioned.
Community fair range: $30.00 - $60.00.
Game completion: 100.0h.
Story completion: 5.5h.
Session length: 0.5h.
Some players find the content worthwhile within their first few hours, while others report the DLC adds little and introduces frustrating systems. The strongest direct evidence points to immediate enjoyment, with mixed negative reports treated as friction rather than a clear later turn.
Friction: Unfleshed-out DLC systems with no real progression; Impossible to gift multiple items at once, making it a slog; Repeated sailing would take forever without docks.
Unlock drivers: Docks provide a core progression loop that avoids long sailing.
Immersive World Explorer: Explores the new ocean biome above and below water, discovers map content, and roleplays within the world. Motivation: Losing themselves in a large, living world through exploration and roleplay. Stance: buy.
Content-Value DLC Buyer: Samples broad expansion features and evaluates content volume against cost. Motivation: Getting a large amount of map, story, and systems for a low DLC price. Stance: buy.
Shipbuilding Base Builder: Focuses on naval progression and building or shop management rather than only story content. Motivation: Engaging with shipbuilding, property buying, and management systems. Stance: buy.
The reported performance is uneven across VRAM cohorts: the 12-15GB Windows group is dominated by crashes and severe FPS drops, while the 16GB+ and 8-11GB groups show a mix of working cases and serious stability or image-quality problems; the <8GB group has only a positive initialization and save-loading report.
Windows 12-15GB VRAM: negative. Multiple users report crashes on launch or loading, repeated crashes after fast travel, and a major FPS drop in the DLC compared with the mainland.
Windows 16GB+ VRAM: mixed. One Mac user reports major optimization and image-quality gains, but a Windows user reports save-load crashes across old and new drivers.
Windows 8-11GB VRAM: mixed. Some users report large FPS gains and stable high frame rates with DLSS, while others report save-load crashes, driver-related launch failures, and severe image-quality blurring.
Steam Deck: The filtered reviews show a severe stability regression: multiple users report that the game no longer launches, crashes on entry, or crashes when loading saves after an update or DLC. Driver changes do not resolve the AMD-related failures, and one user says the game previously ran perfectly. A single positive note about frame-generation flexibility does not offset the launch-blocking issues, so Steam Deck friction is high.
Monetization: The filtered reviews focus on a paid DLC/expansion and player willingness to support future content. They describe the DLC as high-value traditional expansion content and do not provide direct evidence of real-money gacha, loot boxes, pay-to-win, confusing currency, FOMO shops, or base-game microtransactions. Mentions of possible paid costumes are hypothetical requests, not current monetization evidence.
Expansion sold separately: The product is explicitly described as an expansion or DLC for the base game, sold as a separate paid addition. Some note it is part of the game's release structure.
Frequent updates and bug fixes: The game receives constant patches and content updates, with developers actively fixing issues. Reviewers note quick responses to bugs and ongoing support.
Positive comparisons to other games: The DLC and game are favorably compared to titles like The Witcher 3, Skull and Bones, Black Flag, and FF14, often surpassing them in specific aspects.
Developer Pearl Abyss praised: Reviewers commend Pearl Abyss for their dedication, listening to player feedback, and consistent improvements. They are seen as attentive and reliable.
Map significantly expanded: The DLC introduces a map that is three to four times larger than the base game's, with a massive ocean added. Reviewers repeatedly mention the scale of the new areas.