Players are largely disappointed by the game's technical issues, including poor optimization, low frame rates (especially on Steam Deck), frequent crashes, and outdated graphics. Many also feel the game is a significant downgrade from previous titles in the series, lacking charm, key features like character creation and online lobbies, and exhibiting poor design choices and slow progression.
Frustration stems from a combination of poor performance, clunky controls, and distracting in-game elements. Players are annoyed by camera issues, repetitive and noisy NPC dialogue, slow progression, and various bugs that hinder gameplay, making it difficult to enjoy or even play the game effectively.
Many players express satisfaction with the game's core gameplay, finding it to be a faithful return to the classic Hot Shots Golf/Everybody's Golf experience. Smooth performance on their specific systems, enjoyable single-player content, and familiar controls contribute to a positive overall experience for these players.
Excitement is primarily driven by the game's release on PC and the return of the beloved Hot Shots Golf/Everybody's Golf series. Players are thrilled by the prospect of new modes, character systems, and the overall addictive nature of the gameplay, especially when it runs smoothly.
Players enjoy the game for its engaging multiplayer and story modes, as well as its overall fun and interesting gameplay mechanics. The ability to level characters and the solid arcade-style golf experience contribute to a positive and entertaining time for many.
Verdict
Mostly negative
Summary
Positive 52% · Negative 48%. Score: 48 / 100
Positives:
The game is widely celebrated as a faithful and successful return to the classic 'Everybody's Golf' / 'Hot Shots Golf' formula, now available on PC. Many players express gratitude for its release on the platform and appreciate its nostalgic feel.
Players consistently praise the game's core gameplay as fun, engaging, and offering surprising depth despite accessible mechanics. It provides a satisfying challenge and high replayability, making it enjoyable for both new players and veterans.
The game generally runs very well on PC, with many players reporting smooth performance, high frame rates, and no significant bugs or crashes. It supports features like Ultrawide and performs well even on mid-range systems.
Players appreciate the game's cute and lively character designs, which contribute to its overall charming and upbeat atmosphere. The art style is well-received, with improved textures noted by some.
The game offers enjoyable single-player content, including a fun story mode for each character and various game modes. Players find the progression systems engaging, with a good amount of content and fast loading times.
Negatives:
Players report widespread performance issues, including low and inconsistent frame rates, frequent stuttering, and crashes, especially on Steam Deck and other portable devices. Many feel the game is poorly optimized, running heavily despite its dated graphics, and is a significant downgrade from previous titles.
The game's core mechanics, including shot timing and physics, feel off and less rewarding than previous entries. Players are frustrated by a tedious progression system that locks most characters and courses behind a significant grind, making the early game feel unengaging and difficult.
Players are highly annoyed by repetitive and frequent character dialogue, caddy chatter, and generic music. Distracting character animations during shots, combined with poor camera angles and UI issues, further hinder concentration and gameplay immersion.
The camera system is widely criticized for being inflexible, overly sensitive, and poorly positioned, making it difficult to aim shots and navigate courses. Control customization is limited, and button mappings are often inconsistent or unintuitive, contributing to a frustrating user experience.
Many players feel the game is a significant step backward from earlier 'Everybody's Golf' or 'Hot Shots Golf' titles, citing degraded graphics, less charm, missing features, and a general lack of polish. The game fails to live up to the quality and enjoyment of its predecessors.
Gameplay:
New characters, items, and content are primarily unlocked through playing Story Mode, Challenge Mode, and tournaments. This progression system provides a sense of achievement and expands the available roster and features.
Players start with a small selection of characters (2 out of a larger roster of 30+), and these initial characters generally have lower stats. This encourages progression to unlock more options.
The game features a new pre-hit spin system, allowing players to add various spins before taking a shot. Curve shots are performed using the D-pad during the shot, adding depth to ball control.
Players can significantly boost character stats, including reaching A-rank, by feeding them special food. This system allows for permanent stat increases, which is particularly noted as important for competitive play.
The game offers both new and classic control modes, allowing players to customize their preferred scheme. Many players appreciate the option to revert to classic controls, especially if they are familiar with previous titles in the series.
Performance:
Performance on the Steam Deck is inconsistent, with some users reporting decent playability at lower settings, while others experience significant stuttering, low frame rates (around 20-30 FPS), and issues with the shot meter.
Players found that adjusting V-sync and setting an unlimited FPS cap helped improve frame rates and reduce stuttering, allowing for smoother gameplay at higher refresh rates on PC.
Despite many positive reports, some players encountered significant performance problems, including frequent crashes, freezing, stuttering, and low frame rates, even on systems that meet recommended specifications. These issues sometimes required restarts or setting adjustments to mitigate.
The game appears to run well on Linux systems using Proton, with players reporting flawless performance and no frame rate issues.
Some players reported visual anomalies such as background ghost textures with depth of field off, transparent character heads in night mode, and black shadowy textures on certain courses, though these generally did not impact gameplay.
Recommendations:
Player sentiment is highly divided, with many recommending the game for its core gameplay and content, especially fans of the series. However, a significant portion cannot recommend it at launch due to severe bugs, performance issues, and a perceived lack of polish, often suggesting waiting for patches or sales.
The game is primarily recommended for fans of arcadey, skill-based golf games, particularly those familiar with the 'Everybody's Golf' or 'Hot Shots Golf' series. Players expecting a pure golf simulation or a different style of golf game may be disappointed.
Some players suggest alternative golf games like 'Switch Sports', 'Super Video Golf', 'Pangya', or older 'Everybody's Golf' titles, implying that this game does not always meet their expectations or offers less value.
Miscellaneous:
Many players report significant performance issues and bugs, particularly on PC and Steam Deck, which hinder the overall experience. There's a strong expectation and hope for immediate patches to address these problems and improve game stability.
A large segment of the player base consists of long-time fans of the 'Minna no Golf' or 'Hot Shots Golf' series, spanning from PS2 to PS4. These players often compare the new title to their beloved predecessors, influencing their expectations and reception.
Players are anticipating and hoping for future DLC, including new maps, characters, and potentially minigolf. There's also a suggestion for a different pricing model, with a cheaper base game and separate season passes or character unlocks.
Players appreciate comfortable operation with PC and Xbox controllers. There are also specific instructions provided by players on how to exit the game and change camera settings, indicating some initial UI discoverability issues.
Players note that the game's graphics appear uniform across platforms, suggesting it might have been developed with the Nintendo Switch in mind. There's also mention of cross-platform play capabilities.