The Basement Collection
Last updated: 2026-02-13
- Rich collection of games and extras
- Highlights of individual games
- Diverse game collection
- Performance and lag issues
- Meat Boy control issues
- Inconsistent game controls
Emotions
Players are frustrated by a variety of technical and design issues. These include input lag, control problems, performance issues such as memory leaks and unresponsiveness, and the difficulty of achieving certain goals. Additionally, the physical discomfort and the tedious nature of some levels contribute to this frustration.
Players enjoy the unique and fun gameplay mechanics that the collection offers. The variety and creativity of the games provide a satisfying experience, making the gameplay engaging and entertaining.
Players appreciate the depth and thought put into the games, as well as the historical significance of the collection. They admire the developer's work and the progression of skills shown throughout the games.
Players feel disappointed due to performance issues, mediocre gameplay, and controls that need improvement. The games do not match the quality of the developer's more famous works, leading to a sense of letdown.
Players feel nostalgic about the early indie games and their impact. The collection brings back memories of Flash games and the golden era of indie games, evoking a sense of nostalgia.
- Sample precision
- Helpful reviews
- 52%
- Unhelpful reviews
- 48%
- Protest reviews
- 0%
- 81%Helpful reviews with positive sentiment
- 19%Helpful reviews with negative sentiment
- Positive points
- 261
- Negative points
- 169
- Gameplay points
- 205
- Perf. points
- 36
- Rec. points
- 78
- Misc points
- 4
| Point | Description | Importance |
|---|---|---|
Highlights of individual games
| Specific games like Meat Boy, Spewer, Time Fcuk, Aether, Grey Matter, Triachnid, and Coil are highlighted for their unique qualities and gameplay experiences. Meat Boy is noted for its challenge, Spewer for its puzzles, and Time Fcuk for its unique style. | 96% |
Rich collection of games and extras
| The collection includes a variety of games, unlockable content, concept art, Q&As, bonus levels, and other additional materials like soundtracks and comics. This provides a comprehensive package for fans. | 68% |
Insight into developer's work
| The collection provides a deep dive into Edmund McMillen's early work, art, and creative process, including unreleased prototypes and concept sketches. This is valuable for fans interested in the evolution of his games. | 31% |
Appeal to fans of Edmund McMillen
| The collection is particularly appealing to fans of Edmund McMillen, offering a look into his older work and creative path, making it a worthwhile purchase for his followers. | 28% |
Positive reception of the collection
| The overall reception of the collection is highly positive, with many reviewers recommending it for its variety and quality of games and additional content. | 27% |