The Witcher: Enhanced Edition Director's Cut

Players felt satisfied primarily due to the game's engaging and immersive story, rich lore, and well-developed characters. The atmosphere, music, and impactful choices also contributed significantly to a fulfilling experience, often leading to multiple playthroughs and a sense of value for money.

Frustration stemmed mainly from the game's clunky and often buggy combat system, which many found difficult to adapt to. Technical issues like frequent crashes, poor autosave mechanics, and slow movement/lack of fast travel also significantly hindered the player experience, leading to repeated progress loss and tedious backtracking.

Disappointment was frequently caused by outdated gameplay mechanics, particularly the combat system, and dated graphics that did not age well for many players. Technical issues, poor optimization, and a perceived lack of RPG depth or inconsistent pacing also contributed to the game not meeting expectations, especially for fans of later Witcher titles.

Players found enjoyment in the game's captivating story, rich lore, and the overall immersive experience it offered. The impactful choices, unique quests, and the charm of its world, despite dated mechanics, kept players engaged and entertained, often leading to long play sessions.

Admiration was expressed for the game's status as a classic RPG, its incredible and epic story, and its deep moral complexity. Players lauded its captivating atmosphere, impactful choices, and its foundational role in the Witcher series, often considering it a masterpiece for its time and an enduring work of art.