Sonic Colors: Ultimate Review Summary

Last updated: 2026-02-03
  • Nostalgic and charming story
  • Creative use of Wisps
  • Engaging and fluid gameplay
  • Technical issues and bugs
  • Bad cutscenes and dialogue
  • Uninspired level design
Sonic Colors: Ultimate header

Emotions

What players like:

Common complaints:

Gameplay feedback:

Performance notes:

Recommendations:

Other player notes:

Review evidence

Why players say this

What players like

Nostalgic and Charming Story: The game holds a special place in the hearts of many reviewers due to nostalgia. The story is lighthearted, straightforward, and charming, with good voice acting.

Creative Use of Wisps: The Wisps add variety and fun to the gameplay. They introduce unique mechanics and abilities that enhance the overall experience.

Engaging and Fluid Gameplay: The gameplay is described as very fluid, fun, and unique. It includes enjoyable level exploration and a variety of levels with unique mechanics.

Unique Level Design: The level design is praised for its creativity and variety. It includes a mix of 2D and 3D gameplay with intuitive mechanics and interesting platforming sections.

Vibrant and Fun Soundtrack: The game features an original soundtrack that is vibrant, fun, and highly praised. It includes options to switch between new and classic music, enhancing the overall experience.

Common complaints

Technical issues and bugs: The game suffers from various technical issues, including crashes, stuttering, and bugs. These problems are widespread and significantly impact the gameplay experience, making the game frustrating to play at times.

Bad cutscenes and dialogue: Cutscenes are often criticized for their poor quality, AI upscaling, and childish dialogue. The writing is seen as cheesy and unremarkable, with many players finding the humor and jokes unfunny and irritating.

Uninspired level design: Level design is frequently described as uninspired, bland, and repetitive. Many levels are criticized for being too short, overly reliant on 2D sections, and lacking in creativity or challenge.

Poor controls and physics: Controls are often described as clunky, imprecise, and poorly optimized for modern gamepads. The physics, especially in underwater sections and with Wisps, are criticized for feeling broken and unresponsive.

Underwhelming bosses: Boss fights are frequently criticized for being too easy, repetitive, and unmemorable. Many players find them lacking in challenge and innovation, contributing to an overall underwhelming experience.

Gameplay and performance

Wisp mechanics enhance gameplay: The game introduces Wisps, which provide unique abilities and add variety to the gameplay. These Wisps include different types like the Jade Ghost Wisp, each offering distinct powers that can be used to navigate levels and solve puzzles.

Mixed level design quality: The level design in the game is a mix of well-designed stages and questionable layouts. Some levels are praised for their design and variety, while others are criticized for being too puzzle-oriented or having poorly implemented sections.

Excessive 2D platforming: A significant portion of the game is dedicated to 2D platforming, which some players find excessive. The controls in these sections can feel stiff and less responsive compared to 3D segments.

Controls and mechanics: The game's controls are a mixed bag, with some players finding them smooth and others feeling they are stiff and clumsy. The homing attack system has been updated, adding a new specification that can be both helpful and problematic.

High replay value: The game offers high replay value with multiple strategies for levels, collectibles like red star rings, and challenges for achieving S ranks. These elements encourage players to revisit levels and improve their performance.

Performance issues on various platforms: The game suffers from performance issues across different platforms, including stuttering, frame rate drops, and loading times. These issues are particularly notable on modern hardware and the Steam Deck.

Graphical and audio problems: Players have reported various graphical issues, such as low-resolution cutscenes, visual glitches, and poor upscaling. Audio problems include inconsistent sound mixing, audio desyncs, and sound effects cutting out.

Frequent bugs and crashes: The game is reported to have numerous bugs, crashes, and performance issues. Players have experienced frequent stuttering, graphical glitches, and audio problems, which significantly impact the gameplay experience.

Control and optimization issues: The game has been criticized for its poor optimization and control issues. Players have reported that controls feel less responsive and that the game could be better optimized for modern gamepads.

Specific level and gameplay bugs: Certain levels and gameplay mechanics have specific bugs, such as camera issues, crashes at particular points, and characters getting stuck. These issues can make the game unplayable at times.

Recommendations

Emulate the Wii version: Several reviews suggest that emulating the Wii version of the game on Dolphin provides a better experience than the current release. This is often recommended as an alternative to purchasing the game.

Recommended for Sonic fans: The game is frequently recommended for fans of the Sonic series, especially those who are familiar with and enjoy the franchise. It is seen as a worthwhile experience for dedicated fans.

Buy on sale with mods: Many players recommend purchasing the game only when it is on sale and suggest using mods, particularly the Re-Rainbow mod, to enhance the gaming experience. This is due to the game's perceived shortcomings in its original state.

Wait for discounts: Many reviews suggest waiting for discounts or sales before purchasing the game, indicating that the full price may not be justified for the experience provided.

Avoid console versions: Some reviews advise against purchasing the game on certain consoles, particularly the Switch, due to issues with the port and lack of modding capabilities.

Platform notes

Steam Deck: The analysis of user feedback reveals significant issues with the Steam Deck experience, particularly related to Denuvo DRM, performance on the Steam Deck, graphical problems, and control issues. These factors contribute to a less than optimal user experience, with Denuvo DRM and performance issues being the most impactful.

Other review notes

Mod recommendations for enhancement: Several players suggest using mods like Colors Re-Rainbow and Project Re-Rainbow to improve the game experience. These mods are highly recommended and can be installed using the Hedgehog Mod Manager.

Easy to achieve platinum: The game is considered relatively easy to platinum, making it accessible for players looking to achieve this milestone without significant difficulty.

Accusation of false advertising: A player accuses the game's store page of false advertising. This feedback is in Korean and suggests dissatisfaction with the game's marketing.

Mention of Steam Deck: There is a mention of Steam Deck, but without additional context, it is unclear how it relates to the game experience.