- Engaging story and effective psychological horror
- Beautiful art style and visuals
- High quality and enjoyable experience
- Insufficient game length and depth
- Unsatisfying and confusing endings
- Short playtime with multiple endings
Emotions
Players felt satisfied due to the game's overall high quality, encompassing its engaging story, well-designed gameplay, beautiful art, and immersive atmosphere. The experience of achieving 100% completion, unlocking multiple endings, and finding the game to be a rich, polished, and often free experience significantly contributed to this positive emotion.
Excitement stemmed primarily from the game's role as a promising prologue, generating strong anticipation for future chapters and the full release of 'Paper Lily'. Players were also thrilled by the engaging story, unique world-building, impactful choices, and the overall high quality that hinted at an even greater experience to come.
Anticipation was a direct result of the game being a prologue, with players eagerly looking forward to the next chapters, particularly 'Paper Lily Chapter 1', and the full release. The desire for more content, continuation of the story, and future works from the developers fueled this emotion.
Admiration was frequently expressed for the game's exceptional quality, especially considering it was often free. Players praised the stunning visuals, captivating music, detailed atmosphere, impactful choices, and the developers' dedication to crafting such a polished and engaging experience.
Players found enjoyment in the game's fun gameplay, interesting story, and appealing mix of genres. The overall experience, including captivating puzzles, varied mechanics, and the satisfaction of unlocking all achievements and endings, contributed to a generally pleasant and entertaining time.
Verdict
Mostly positive
Summary
Positive 96% · Negative 4%. Score: 4 / 100
Positives:
- Players consistently praise the game's rich, unique, and immersive story, noting its captivating plot, well-developed world, and effective atmosphere. The narrative is described as engaging, mysterious, and thought-provoking, with player choices significantly impacting the outcome.
- The game is widely regarded as a high-quality, polished, and enjoyable experience, often exceeding expectations, especially for a free title. Players found it fun, entertaining, and well-crafted, with smooth gameplay and good controls.
- The game excels at creating a creepy, unsettling, and genuinely scary psychological horror atmosphere without relying on cheap jumpscares or gore. It builds tension slowly, making players question the world and leaving a lasting impression.
- Reviewers consistently highlight the game's beautiful and detailed art style, including exquisite pixel art, charming character illustrations, and effective use of visuals to enhance the atmosphere. The aesthetic is praised for its ability to transition between cute and creepy.
- Despite being a short prologue, the game is lauded for its completeness, rich content, and effectiveness as a teaser for the main game, Paper Lily. It successfully builds a compelling world and leaves players eager for the full release.
Negatives:
- Players consistently found the game to be too short, often finishing within an hour or two. This brevity contributed to a feeling of incompleteness, a lack of deep storytelling, and insufficient character development, leaving many wanting more content and substance.
- Many players expressed dissatisfaction with the game's endings, describing them as lackluster, sad, or confusing. The 'True Ending' was particularly criticized for being disappointing and harsh, with some feeling it didn't provide enough resolution or explanation.
- Players were confused about the game's relationship to 'Paper Lily,' finding the story largely unrelated and the game itself feeling less substantial in comparison. It failed to provide meaningful context for understanding the other title.
- Some players encountered minor bugs that necessitated restarting the game, and found the controls, particularly inventory interaction, took some getting used to.
- A significant concern among players is the prolonged wait for the full game, with the prologue having been available for several years without a clear release date for the complete experience.
Gameplay:
- A single playthrough of the game is very short, typically ranging from 40 minutes to an hour. Even achieving 100% completion, including all endings and achievements, generally takes only 1.5 to 4 hours, making it a concise experience.
- The game features numerous endings (around 8), including a 'true' ending and various 'dead end' scenarios, which are influenced by player choices and puzzle solutions. This design encourages multiple playthroughs to explore all story branches and unlock achievements, though some players may need guides to discover all paths.
- Players control Kat, a curious and sarcastic high school girl fascinated by the occult. The core gameplay revolves around her performing a mysterious ritual at school, with player choices influencing her relationships and the story's outcome.
- The game is a story-driven puzzle game, combining point-and-click adventure elements with exploration. Puzzles are generally simple and logical, often involving item gathering, deciphering clues, and can sometimes be solved in multiple ways, contributing to the non-linear design.
- The horror elements are primarily atmospheric, relying on suspense, eerie music, and subtle clues rather than frequent jump scares. While it contains some pixelated gore and occasional tricky jump scares, the overall horror level is considered medium or slight.
Performance:
- Players consistently report that the game runs smoothly across various hardware configurations, including 4K displays and integrated graphics. This indicates strong optimization and a stable technical foundation.
- The game demonstrates excellent compatibility and performance on non-Windows platforms, specifically Linux with Proton-GE and the SteamDeck. This broadens accessibility for a significant segment of the PC gaming community.
- Players frequently mention a lack of bugs and glitches, contributing to a polished and enjoyable gameplay experience. This suggests a high level of quality assurance.
- The game is noted for its low system requirements, even mentioning compatibility with mobile devices (though this might be a misunderstanding of 'cell phone' for 'low requirements'). This makes it accessible to a wider audience with less powerful hardware.
Recommendations:
- Players overwhelmingly recommend this game, citing its engaging nature and value, especially given it's a free and relatively short experience. Many consider it a must-play and a great way to spend an hour or two.
- There is significant excitement for future chapters and the full release of the game. Players are eager to continue the story and are willing to pay for subsequent content, indicating strong engagement with the narrative.
- Many players recommend playing Project Kat in conjunction with Paper Lily, either as a prologue or a complementary experience. There's a clear interest in the connection between the two games and how they enhance each other's narratives.
- The game is highly recommended for fans of psychological horror, narrative-driven games, RPG Maker horror, and those who appreciate interactive narratives with meaningful choices. It's noted for its immersive atmosphere and story depth.
- Players are encouraged to seek out all the different endings and achievements to fully experience the game's depth. This suggests a rewarding replayability factor and appreciation for its multi-ending system.
Miscellaneous:
- This game serves as a prologue or prequel to 'Paper Lily', with many players discovering it after playing 'Paper Lily: Chapter 1'. There's a strong connection between the two titles, with players often playing one to prepare for or follow up on the other.
- The game is identified as an RPG Maker horror title, appealing to fans of this genre. It features pixel art visuals with hand-drawn elements, creating a unique world of mystery and psychological horror.
- There are mixed reports regarding language support, particularly for Chinese. While some players note unofficial or community-provided localizations, the official Steam page may not always reflect available language options.
- Players show a particular interest in the character Kat, expressing a desire for more content and clarification regarding her story and what happened after her death.
- The short length of the game is understood as typical for a prologue, which functions as a demo to capture player attention and potentially iron out bugs before the full release.
