
What players like:
Common complaints:
Gameplay feedback:
Performance notes:
Recommendations:
Other player notes:












Review evidence
Engaging and Emotional Story: The narrative is described as immersive, emotionally resonant, and well-paced, with multiple twists and a satisfying conclusion. The DLC 'Human World Like Dream' is particularly noted for enhancing the story.
Outstanding Music and Soundtrack: The game's music, including collaborations with artists like Zhou Shen and Chen Zhiyi, is frequently mentioned as emotionally impactful and top-tier. Tracks like '相守' and '人间如梦' are standout examples.
Stunning Visuals and Art Design: The game is praised for its high-quality visuals, detailed environments, and beautiful Chinese-style aesthetics. Specific locations like the Xianxia Sect and character models are highlighted as exceptional.
Innovative Real-Time Combat: The transition from turn-based to real-time combat is seen as a major improvement, offering fluid and dynamic gameplay. The combat system is praised for its responsiveness and visual feedback.
Nostalgic Easter Eggs and Lore: The game includes numerous references to previous installments, such as characters, music, and lore, which evoke nostalgia and add value for long-time fans of the series.
Frustrating Puzzles and Platforming: Puzzles are poorly designed, confusing, and often feel like padding to extend playtime. Platforming mechanics are described as clunky, frustrating, and poorly implemented, particularly in the DLC.
Poor Side Quest Design: Side quests are described as repetitive, overly long, and lacking meaningful content. Many feel like filler or 'toilet cleaning' tasks with no substantial narrative or gameplay value.
Inconsistent and Unbalanced Difficulty: The game suffers from inconsistent difficulty, with some boss fights being overly easy while others are unfairly difficult due to poor mechanics, long animations, or lack of save points.
Excessive Bugs and Glitches: Numerous technical issues, including game-breaking bugs, crashes, and poor optimization, are reported. Players frequently encounter frame drops, stuttering, and unresponsive controls, particularly in specific areas.
Forced and Unskippable Content: Players express frustration with unskippable cutscenes, forced dialogue, and mandatory mini-games that disrupt gameplay flow. Some content, like the DLC, is criticized for locking key story elements behind a paywall.
Story-driven cinematic focus: The game emphasizes narrative with frequent cutscenes, detailed character dialogues, and a three-act plot structure. Some players felt the story overshadowed gameplay, especially in DLC.
Diverse mini-games and puzzles: Mini-games (e.g., card games, platforming, stealth) and puzzles are integrated throughout the game, though some are criticized as poorly designed or repetitive. DLC content often focuses on these elements.
Real-time combat overhaul: The game replaced its traditional turn-based combat with a real-time action system, including cooldowns, combos, and character-switching mechanics. Players noted stiffness, poor hit detection, and unresponsive controls as key issues.
Character progression and variety: Four playable characters with unique combat styles, skill trees, and progression systems (e.g., spirit bonds, equipment crafting) are featured. Players appreciated the variety but noted balancing issues.
Movement and platforming flaws: Jumping, traversal, and platforming mechanics (e.g., Leaf Spirit puzzles) are inconsistent, with issues like poor collision detection and forced walking segments frustrating players.
Cutscene performance problems: Cutscenes frequently cause stuttering, audio desyncs, and crashes, with some users reporting black screens or visual glitches during transitions. These issues disrupt immersion and narrative flow.
High system requirements: The game demands significant GPU and VRAM resources, struggling to maintain stable performance on mid-to-high-end systems. Users report needing DLSS or lower settings for smooth gameplay.
Hardware-specific instability: High-end GPUs (e.g., RTX 3080/4070) experience unstable frame rates, often dropping below 30 FPS despite running other games smoothly. VRAM spikes and memory leaks exacerbate crashes.
Visual and lighting glitches: Users report blurry textures, overexposure during lighting transitions, and inconsistent anti-aliasing (TAA). Character models and grass textures appear pixelated in certain scenes.
Limited graphics customization: The game lacks key settings like DLSS toggles, custom FPS limits, or internal resolution scaling, forcing players to rely on external tools or hardware upgrades for performance.
Recommended for story-driven RPG fans: The game is highly recommended for players who enjoy narrative-heavy experiences, Chinese mythology, and emotional storytelling. Fans of the series or wuxia genre will find it particularly appealing, especially if purchased at a discount.
DLC strongly recommended for completeness: The DLC is frequently cited as essential for a complete story experience, including post-main-story content. It is recommended to purchase alongside the base game, especially for fans of the characters and narrative.
Best for fans, not newcomers: The game is primarily recommended for fans of the series or Chinese RPGs, with nostalgia and cultural appreciation cited as key motivators. Non-fans or those seeking fast-paced action may find it less appealing.
Discount purchase advised: Many reviewers recommend buying the game only at a discounted price, citing its flaws in writing and design. It is positioned as a worthwhile experience for its value, especially during sales.
Puzzle and side content improvements: Players suggest redesigning puzzles for better flow and exploring side content for deeper character development. Optional lore entries (e.g., like 'Xian 5’s' library) are proposed for Wanxiang.
Steam Deck: The game suffers from critical technical flaws, including frequent crashes, GPU errors, and black screens (High severity), alongside pervasive optimization issues causing frame drops and stuttering even on high-end hardware (High severity). Visual fidelity and UI readability are also problematic, with users reporting blurry textures and poorly animated characters (Medium severity). While Steam Deck compatibility is noted as a positive, it is overshadowed by the broader stability and performance issues. The lack of forced Proton/launcher workarounds prevents a lower score, but the game's technical shortcomings are severe enough to warrant a 'Broken' verdict.
Monetization: The game employs aggressive monetization tactics centered around its DLC, 'Dreamlike World Expansion.' The most critical issue is the locking of the *complete ending* behind a paid DLC, which users widely condemn as a predatory 'Day-1 DLC' strategy. The base game is frequently described as incomplete or flawed, with the DLC acting as a narrative patch to address these shortcomings. This creates a 'create problem, sell solution' dynamic, where players are pressured to purchase the DLC to experience the full story. Additionally, the DLC introduces gameplay mechanics that feel disjointed or poorly integrated, further detracting from the user experience. While the DLC improves the game's narrative and emotional impact, the monetization strategy is exploitative and significantly impacts the game's perceived fairness.
External guides: The primary user pain points revolve around **external data dependency** to compensate for in-game shortcomings. The most severe issues include poor quest guidance (forcing wiki reliance), hidden collectibles requiring spatial data, and bug-induced progression blocks. While lore context is appreciated, it is not a critical barrier. The game’s design inadvertently pushes users toward external resources, particularly for instructional and spatial data.
High industry and nostalgic value: The game is praised for its nostalgic appeal to long-time fans and its significance in the Chinese gaming industry, often compared to other major franchises like 'Gu Jian' and 'Xuan-Yuan Sword.' It is seen as a benchmark for domestic single-player games.
Critique of writing and romance subplots: Some players criticize the game's writing quality and specific romantic subplots, such as those involving Wang Xiaohu and QiQi. There are suggestions that the series should not continue due to these issues.
Strong cultural and historical inspiration: The game draws heavily from Chinese mythology, particularly 'Journey to the West,' and incorporates historical elements like Song Dynasty architecture and Qin-Han armor. This cultural depth is a standout feature in the Chinese single-player market.
Fan service and nostalgia-driven experience: The game leverages fan service and nostalgia for the IP, creating a strong personal connection for players who have followed the series. This includes appreciation for character designs like '二师姐.'
Comparisons to other games and series: Frequent comparisons are made to other games in the series (e.g., 'Gu Jian 3,' 'Xuan-Yuan Sword 7') and previous installments like 'The Legend of Sword and Fairy 5,' highlighting expectations and benchmarks for quality.