Braid, Anniversary Edition

Players frequently cite overly difficult or unintuitive puzzle design as a major source of frustration, particularly in star collection, hidden secrets, and timing-based mechanics. Many also highlight poor controls, punishing level design, and a lack of hints or clear communication, which exacerbate the challenge and create repeated failures.

Players appreciate the game's artistic design, minimalist aesthetic, and clever puzzle mechanics, which are often described as innovative and thought-provoking. The developer commentary is also praised for providing unique insights into the game's creation, storytelling, and design philosophy, adding educational and historical value.

Disappointment stems from the game's outdated graphics, repetitive or trivial puzzles, and a lack of meaningful new content in the Anniversary Edition. Players also express frustration with the narrative's confusing or unsatisfying elements, as well as perceived design flaws like tedious time mechanics and poorly integrated commentary.

Players feel a strong sense of satisfaction from solving the game's challenging puzzles, often describing moments of realization or 'AHA' insights as deeply rewarding. The progressive learning curve, high-quality art and music, and the ability to complete the game without external help also contribute to this positive emotion.

Admiration is directed toward the game's creativity, depth, and craftsmanship, particularly its ability to transform simple mechanics into complex and meaningful experiences. Players also praise the developer's passion, attention to detail, and the game's philosophical and artistic qualities, which elevate it to the status of a masterpiece.