| Unique Templar Perspective Narrative DescriptionThe story is highly praised for its innovative approach, allowing players to control Shay Patrick Cormac, an ex-Assassin who becomes a Templar. This shift provides a fresh and morally complex perspective on the Assassin-Templar conflict, blurring the traditional 'good vs. evil' lines and offering deeper insight into both factions' motivations.Importance76%
 | The story is highly praised for its innovative approach, allowing players to control Shay Patrick Cormac, an ex-Assassin who becomes a Templar. This shift provides a fresh and morally complex perspective on the Assassin-Templar conflict, blurring the traditional 'good vs. evil' lines and offering deeper insight into both factions' motivations. | 76% | 
| Best in Series, Underrated Gem DescriptionMany reviewers consider this game one of the best in the Assassin's Creed franchise, frequently calling it an 'underrated gem.' It is highly regarded for its compelling story, refined mechanics, and unique contribution to the series' lore, often preferred over newer titles.Importance60%
 | Many reviewers consider this game one of the best in the Assassin's Creed franchise, frequently calling it an 'underrated gem.' It is highly regarded for its compelling story, refined mechanics, and unique contribution to the series' lore, often preferred over newer titles. | 60% | 
| Engaging and Refined Gameplay DescriptionPlayers consistently found the core gameplay enjoyable, fluid, and well-polished. Many noted significant improvements and optimizations over previous entries, particularly regarding character movement and overall technical performance, making it a satisfying experience even years after its release.Importance56%
 | Players consistently found the core gameplay enjoyable, fluid, and well-polished. Many noted significant improvements and optimizations over previous entries, particularly regarding character movement and overall technical performance, making it a satisfying experience even years after its release. | 56% | 
| Refined Naval Combat & Exploration DescriptionThe naval combat system, inherited and improved from Black Flag, is a major highlight. Players enjoyed sailing the Morrigan through icy North Atlantic waters, engaging in thrilling battles, and utilizing new mechanics like ice-breaking and rapid-fire cannons, which made the ship gameplay dynamic and satisfying.Importance37%
 | The naval combat system, inherited and improved from Black Flag, is a major highlight. Players enjoyed sailing the Morrigan through icy North Atlantic waters, engaging in thrilling battles, and utilizing new mechanics like ice-breaking and rapid-fire cannons, which made the ship gameplay dynamic and satisfying. | 37% | 
| Strong Protagonist Character Arc DescriptionShay Patrick Cormac is consistently highlighted as a charismatic, complex, and well-written protagonist. His journey from Assassin to Templar, driven by internal conflict and moral dilemmas, resonated strongly with players, making his motivations understandable and his story captivating.Importance35%
 | Shay Patrick Cormac is consistently highlighted as a charismatic, complex, and well-written protagonist. His journey from Assassin to Templar, driven by internal conflict and moral dilemmas, resonated strongly with players, making his motivations understandable and his story captivating. | 35% | 
| Seamless Franchise Lore Integration DescriptionThe game excels at connecting narratives and characters from Assassin's Creed III, Black Flag, and Unity. It fills crucial lore gaps and provides a coherent bridge between these installments, offering a richer understanding of the overarching Assassin-Templar conflict for franchise fans.Importance24%
 | The game excels at connecting narratives and characters from Assassin's Creed III, Black Flag, and Unity. It fills crucial lore gaps and provides a coherent bridge between these installments, offering a richer understanding of the overarching Assassin-Templar conflict for franchise fans. | 24% | 
| Immersive Cold-Themed Environments DescriptionThe game's setting in the icy North Atlantic, River Valley, and colonial New York is highly praised for its unique and immersive atmosphere. The beautifully rendered snowy landscapes, icebergs, and diverse climatic areas contribute significantly to the game's distinct grim and cold ambiance.Importance13%
 | The game's setting in the icy North Atlantic, River Valley, and colonial New York is highly praised for its unique and immersive atmosphere. The beautifully rendered snowy landscapes, icebergs, and diverse climatic areas contribute significantly to the game's distinct grim and cold ambiance. | 13% | 
| Engaging Assassin Hunting Mechanic DescriptionA key innovation is the anti-assassination mechanic, where the player, as a Templar, is hunted by Assassins. This creates a fresh and dynamic gameplay tension, with Assassins using familiar stealth tactics, making encounters unpredictable and exciting.Importance13%
 | A key innovation is the anti-assassination mechanic, where the player, as a Templar, is hunted by Assassins. This creates a fresh and dynamic gameplay tension, with Assassins using familiar stealth tactics, making encounters unpredictable and exciting. | 13% | 
| Excellent PC Optimization DescriptionThe PC port is well-regarded for its incredible optimization, running smoothly on a wide range of systems, including weaker PCs. Players reported stable performance with high frame rates and minimal bugs or crashes, ensuring accessibility and a pleasant experience.Importance10%
 | The PC port is well-regarded for its incredible optimization, running smoothly on a wide range of systems, including weaker PCs. Players reported stable performance with high frame rates and minimal bugs or crashes, ensuring accessibility and a pleasant experience. | 10% |