Blacksmith Master
Last updated: 2025-05-19
- Relaxing and addictive shop management gameplay.
- Engaging crafting and rewarding progression system.
- Stable early access with Tavern Master improvements.
- Generally smooth performance with scalable options.
- Repetitive gameplay, shallow, and lacks depth.
- Resource and crafting systems are imbalanced.
- Reviews
(sample size) - 428
- Helpful reviews
- 85%
- Unhelpful reviews
- 14%
- Protest reviews
- 0%
- 75%Helpful reviews with positive sentiment
- 25%Helpful reviews with negative sentiment
- Positive points
- 639
- Negative points
- 533
- Gameplay points
- 154
- Perf. points
- 32
- Rec. points
- 267
- Misc points
- 30
| Point | Description | Importance |
|---|---|---|
| Relaxing, addictive, and easy gameplay | The game is praised for its relaxing and addictive gameplay loop, making it easy to lose track of time. Players find it enjoyable for both active and passive play, with a good balance of challenge and relaxation. The game is also accessible and easy to learn, making it suitable for casual play and chill sessions. | 81% |
| Engaging crafting and shop management | Players enjoy the core gameplay loop of crafting, managing, and expanding their blacksmith shop. The game offers a variety of crafting options, customization, and building freedom, allowing players to create and personalize their workshop. The ability to manage workers and optimize production lines adds depth and engagement. | 46% |
| Rewarding and satisfying progression | The game provides a rewarding sense of progression as players unlock new items, features, and abilities. Completing orders and upgrading the forge leads to meaningful advancements, keeping players motivated and engaged. The game's progression system is well-paced and satisfying. | 39% |
| Improved and expanded "Tavern Master" | Many reviewers compare the game favorably to "Tavern Master", noting that it offers more depth, new mechanics, and improvements. Players who enjoyed "Tavern Master" are likely to appreciate this game as well. The game expands upon the formula of its predecessor with new features and content. | 22% |
| Stable and polished early access | The game is noted for its stability and lack of bugs, especially considering its Early Access status. The UI and controls are polished, and the developers are responsive to feedback. The game feels complete and well-executed, exceeding expectations for an early release. | 20% |
| Relaxing and fitting music | The game's music is relaxing, beautiful, and fitting for the medieval setting, enhancing the overall atmosphere. The sound effects are also rewarding, contributing to a pleasant and meditative gameplay experience. The music and graphics work together to create a relaxing and enjoyable environment. | 11% |
| Strategic management and planning | The game incorporates elements of strategy and management, including resource management, shop layout planning, and staff hiring/upgrading. The game is intuitive and rarely overwhelming, even when managing staff across multiple floors. The game offers flexibility in business size and allows for active participation through direct worker control. | 11% |
| Immersive medieval atmosphere and visuals | The game features an immersive medieval atmosphere with appealing visuals, charming art style, and a cozy feel. The environment is lifelike, with attention to detail in the town, sound effects, and overall look and feel. The game's ambience contributes to an engaging and captivating experience. | 10% |
| Responsive and attentive developer | The developer is praised for paying attention to details, being active in the community, and responding to feedback. This suggests a commitment to improving the game and addressing player concerns. The developer's responsiveness is a positive sign for the game's future development. | 3% |
| Clear and straightforward UI | The game features a clear and straightforward user interface, making it easy to understand and navigate. The build UI is simple and logical, contributing to a smooth and intuitive gameplay experience. The user-friendly interface enhances the overall accessibility of the game. | 3% |