Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl 2 Review Summary

Last updated: 2026-02-15
  • Fun and enjoyable gameplay
  • Innovative slime mechanic
  • Improved sequel with enjoyable characters
  • Stable netcode with rollback
  • Frequent bug complaints and crashes
  • Control and mechanics issues
Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl 2 header

Emotions

What players like:

Common complaints:

Gameplay feedback:

Performance notes:

Recommendations:

Other player notes:

Review evidence

Why players say this

What players like

Fun and enjoyable gameplay: Players consistently describe the game as fun and enjoyable, particularly when played with friends. The unique characters and varied techniques add to the excitement and interest.

Innovative slime mechanic: The slime mechanic is highlighted as a unique and strategic addition that enhances the gameplay. It adds depth and makes combos more interesting without complicating the game too much.

Improved sequel: The game is seen as a significant improvement over its predecessor, with better graphics, visuals, and overall gameplay quality.

Enjoyable characters: Players appreciate the fun and well-designed characters, each with unique movesets that make the gameplay more enjoyable.

Best platform fighter: Many players consider this game to be one of the best platform fighters available, often comparing it favorably to other popular titles in the genre.

Common complaints

Frequent bug complaints: Many players have reported encountering numerous bugs in the game, which significantly affects the gameplay experience and enjoyment.

Control and mechanics issues: Players have reported issues with game controls, including the inability to change controls and problems with hit stun mechanics.

Game overpriced: Many reviews mention that the game is not worth its current price, suggesting that it is overpriced for the content and experience it offers.

Small player base: The game has a small player base, which is attributed to its high price and low recognition, particularly in Japan.

Disappointing character roster: Players have expressed dissatisfaction with the character roster, citing strange choices and a lack of desired characters.

Gameplay and performance

Arcade and Campaign Modes: The game features both an arcade mode and a campaign mode, providing varied single-player content including boss fights and a rogue-like campaign.

Platform Fighter with Cross-Play: The game is a platform fighter similar to Smash Bros, featuring online multiplayer with cross-play functionality.

Unique Slime Mechanic: The game includes a unique slime mechanic that affects combos and can be used to enhance special moves, improve recovery, enhance shields, cancel moves, and taunt with slime effects.

Enhanced Fighting Mechanics: The game features improved fighting mechanics with fast gameplay, simple combos, and non-monotonous action design.

Diverse Character Roster: The game offers a roster of unique characters with distinct abilities and reworked movesets.

Stable netcode with rollback: The game features rollback netcode and dedicated regional servers, ensuring a stable online experience with low lag.

Optimization issues on other platforms: The game needs better optimization and performance varies significantly depending on the platform.

Frequent crashes and glitches: Players report constant game crashes and various glitches, affecting the overall gameplay experience.

Optimized for Steam Deck: The game runs well on Steam Deck, providing a smooth experience on this platform.

Server issues and downtime: Servers are frequently down, leading to disconnections and an unreliable online experience.

Recommendations

Recommended on sale: Many players suggest buying the game only when it is on sale, indicating that the game's value is significantly higher at a discounted price.

Good alternative to Smash Bros: The game is often compared to Smash Bros and is recommended for fans of platform fighters looking for a similar experience.

For fighting game fans: The game is recommended for fans of fighting games, indicating it has appeal within this specific genre.

Overall positive reception: Despite some criticisms, many players consider the game to be great overall and worth checking out.

Best with friends: The game is more enjoyable and recommended when played with friends, highlighting its multiplayer aspects.

Platform notes

Steam Deck: The analysis of user feedback for the Steam Deck experience reveals significant issues with controller support and the lack of cloud saves. These technical barriers impact the user experience negatively. However, there are also reports of positive experiences, with users finding the game fun and running well on the device.

Extra review signals

Monetization: The game is criticized for its high base price of $50 and expensive DLC characters, which significantly increase the total cost. Many users feel that the game is overpriced and some perceive it as a cash grab. Despite these criticisms, some users acknowledge the game's quality and improvements over its predecessor.

Other review notes

Request for Catdog Return: Players are requesting the return of a feature or character named Catdog from a previous version of the game.

Playtime Comparisons: Some reviews mention the playtime of the first game, possibly comparing it to the current version.