The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me Review Summary

Last updated: 2026-02-23
  • Engaging and well-written story
  • Improved gameplay and graphics
  • Choice-based interactive storytelling
  • Excessive and game-breaking bugs
  • Illogical plot and character decisions
  • Poor character development and dialogue
The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me header

Emotions

Archetypes

What players like:

Common complaints:

Gameplay feedback:

Performance notes:

Recommendations:

Other player notes:

Review evidence

Why players say this

What players like

Engaging and well-written story: The game features an interesting and lively plot with well-written storytelling. Players found the story entertaining, intriguing, and engaging, with good characters and a great premise.

Improved gameplay and graphics: The game offers better gameplay, exploration, and enhanced graphics. Players appreciated the interactive and enjoyable gameplay, along with superior visuals and improved controls.

Best in the series: Many players consider this game to be the best or one of the strongest entries in its series. It is seen as a great addition with lots of gameplay.

Suspenseful and tense atmosphere: The game keeps players in suspense and on the edge of their seats with its thrilling and tense atmosphere, well-built tension, and scary moments.

Enjoyable experience: Players found the game enjoyable, especially when played with a friend. The overall experience was fun and engaging despite some issues.

Common complaints

Excessive and game-breaking bugs: Players report a high number of bugs, including game-breaking ones, that significantly disrupt the gameplay experience. These bugs affect various aspects of the game, such as lighting, characters, and multiplayer functionality.

Illogical plot and character decisions: The game's plot is criticized for being incoherent and filled with plot holes. Additionally, characters often make illogical decisions that do not make sense within the context of the story.

Poor character development and dialogue: Characters are found to be uninteresting, poorly developed, and often unlikable. The dialogues are also criticized for being weak and uncharismatic.

Unsatisfying and poorly written ending: The game's ending is described as horrible, unsatisfying, and unclear. The overall writing is criticized for being poor and lackluster.

Clunky and unresponsive controls: The controls are reported to be clunky, unresponsive, and inconsistent. This includes issues with movement, platforming, and camera controls.

Gameplay and performance

Choice-based interactive storytelling: The game features a narrative-driven experience where player choices significantly impact the story and endings. This includes branched narratives and consequences based on decisions made throughout the game.

Horror and psychological elements: The game is a horror experience with psychological thriller elements, jumpscares, and a dark narrative. It aims to create a tense and frightening atmosphere for players.

Co-op gameplay: The game offers a co-operative gameplay experience, allowing players to work together to progress through the story and overcome challenges.

Exploration and interaction: Players can explore various environments, interact with objects, solve puzzles, and engage in survival elements. This adds depth to the gameplay and encourages thorough investigation of the game world.

Quick Time Events (QTEs): The game incorporates Quick Time Events, requiring players to perform specific actions quickly. These moments are used liberally and can affect the outcome of certain sequences.

Numerous bugs and glitches: The game is filled with numerous bugs and glitches, ranging from graphical issues to gameplay-affecting bugs, which detract from the overall experience.

Performance and FPS issues: Players report various performance issues such as FPS drops, frame rate dips, and overall lag, indicating a need for better optimization.

Frequent game crashes: The game experiences frequent crashes, including issues during launch and gameplay, which significantly disrupt the player experience.

Texture loading problems: There are significant issues with texture loading, including low-quality textures and constant reloading, which affect the visual quality of the game.

Animation delays and issues: Players have noted long animation delays and broken animations, which affect the smoothness and realism of the game.

Recommendations

Worth it only on sale: Many players suggest that the game is only worth purchasing if it is available at a steep discount or on sale, indicating that the full price may not be justified based on its current condition.

Worth playing: Several reviews indicate that the game is worth playing, especially if you enjoy the genre or are a fan of the series.

Recommended for fans of the series: The game is often recommended for fans of The Dark Pictures Anthology or Supermassive Games, suggesting it caters well to those already familiar with and enjoying the series.

Recommended for horror fans: Fans of horror and mystery, particularly those who enjoy narrative-driven horror games, are likely to appreciate this game.

Skip if new to the series: New players are advised to start with other games in the series rather than this one, indicating it might not be the best introduction.

Buying context

Community fair range: $1.00 - $2.00.

Game completion: 7.3h.

Story completion: 4.0h.

The game initially suffers from technical issues and slow pacing but becomes enjoyable once players reach the deathtraps and overcome the initial hurdles.

Reported time to anchor: 2h.

Friction: Technical issues; Clunky mechanics; Slow pacing initially; Unresponsive controls; Hidden menus; Bugs in co-op mode.

Unlock drivers: Reaching the deathtraps; Unlocking achievements; Compelling narrative.

Player profiles

Story-Driven Enthusiast: Explores thoroughly to find hidden items and understand the story fully. Motivation: Engaging story and graphical beauty. Stance: sale.

Frustrated Co-op Player: Prefers playing with friends but is hindered by bugs and synchronization issues. Motivation: Seeking a smooth and enjoyable co-op experience. Stance: deep sale.

Casual Horror Fan: Plays on easier difficulties to enjoy the story without stress. Motivation: Enjoying a good story and interactive experience without stress. Stance: sale.

Platform notes

Steam Deck: The analysis of user feedback reveals significant issues with the Steam Deck experience for this game. Key problems include poor controller support, numerous bugs and stability issues, graphical problems, and overall gameplay experience issues. These factors contribute to a frustrating and less enjoyable gaming experience on the Steam Deck.

Extra review signals

External guides: The primary issues identified from user feedback revolve around the game's repetitive and confusing navigation, which significantly detracts from the overall gameplay experience. Additionally, there are notable concerns regarding the game's design and the clarity of its story, leading to user frustration and dissatisfaction.

Other review notes

Controller and cloud save support: The game supports controllers and cloud saves, which enhances the gaming experience for many players.

Free DLC available: Players appreciate that the game offers free downloadable content.

Request for Russification: Some players have expressed a desire for the next part of the game to be Russified, indicating a demand for localization.