Middle-earth™: Shadow of War™ Story Expansion Pass Review Summary

Last updated: 2026-06-01
  • Desolation of Mordor highly praised
  • Unique characters and engaging gameplay
  • Enjoyable story and cinematics
  • DLCs criticized as overpriced and lackluster
  • Frequent game crashes and technical issues
  • Blade of Galadriel heavily criticized
Middle-earth™: Shadow of War™ Story Expansion Pass header

Emotions

Archetypes

What players like:

Common complaints:

Gameplay feedback:

Performance notes:

Recommendations:

Other player notes:

  • -

    No data available

Review evidence

Why players say this

What players like

Desolation of Mordor praised: The Desolation of Mordor expansion is frequently highlighted for its significant changes to gameplay, new elements, and overall quality. Players find it enjoyable and worth the investment.

Unique characters and gameplay: Characters like Eltariel and Baranor bring unique gameplay elements and dynamics. Players enjoy the variety and different playstyles offered by these characters.

Engaging story and cinematics: Many players enjoyed the story and cinematics, finding them engaging and fun to play along with. The narrative is a strong point that enhances the overall experience.

Positive overall reception: The game and its expansions are generally well-received, with players describing them as good content and a great bundle for story DLC.

New battles and enemies: The introduction of new fights against the Nazgûl and other unique enemies adds excitement and variety to the gameplay.

Common complaints

DLCs are overpriced and lackluster: Many players feel that the DLCs are too expensive for the amount of content provided. They also believe that the DLCs do not enhance the main game experience and are too short.

Blade of Galadriel criticized: The Blade of Galadriel DLC is widely criticized for feeling rushed, lackluster, and not offering much new content. It is also seen as not complementing the main story well.

Gameplay and technical issues: Players report various technical issues such as game crashes, long loading times, and installation problems with the DLCs.

Story and character criticisms: The story elements and characters in the DLCs are criticized for being weak, cringy, or not well-integrated with the main game. Some characters are seen as unlikable or wooden.

Game mechanics and design flaws: Several gameplay mechanics and design choices are criticized, such as the lack of certain tools, dependency on specific armor sets, and insufficient skills against certain enemies.

Gameplay and performance

Expansion content with new characters: The expansions introduce new characters, missions, and abilities, adding fresh gameplay elements and storylines.

Baranor's mortality and abilities: Baranor is a mortal character who can die permanently, ending his story. He lacks special powers like a ring but has an instant heal ability and health potions.

New mechanics in expansions: Expansions introduce new mechanics such as grapple hooks, parachutes, and crossbows, enhancing gameplay variety.

Gameplay changes in Desolation of Mordor: The Desolation of Mordor expansion introduces different gameplay styles and mechanics, offering a fresh playstyle.

Fortress Assaults: Gameplay includes fortress assaults, providing large-scale battles and strategic challenges.

Frequent game crashes: The game experiences crashing issues, particularly near the end. This significantly disrupts the gameplay experience.

Long loading times: Players report extended loading times, which affects the overall gaming experience and flow.

Recommendations

Wait for sale prices: Many reviews suggest that the game is only worth purchasing when it is significantly discounted. Full price is often considered too high for the content provided.

Definitive Edition preferred: The Definitive Edition is frequently recommended as the better choice for purchase. It offers more value and content compared to the standard edition.

Consider bundle purchases: Buying bundles that include multiple games or all DLCs is often seen as a better deal. These bundles provide more content and better value for money.

Recommended for fans: The game is highly recommended for fans of specific series or genres, such as 'Lord of the Rings' or action-adventure RPGs. These players are likely to enjoy the game more.

Specific DLC recommendations: Certain DLCs like 'A Desolação de Mordor' and 'Blade of Galadriel' are highlighted for their story and new mechanics, making them worth considering.

Buying context

Community fair range: $5.00 - $20.00.

Game completion: 10.0h.

Story completion: 6.0h.

The game offers immediate fun with its new story and unique gameplay styles, but some players experience a drop in fun due to repetitive or lacking elements.

Friction: Repetitive gameplay elements; Lack of certain features like the grapple hook and parachute.

Unlock drivers: New story and characters; Unique gameplay and progression systems.

Player profiles

Gameplay Connoisseur: Seeks out fresh and interesting gameplay mechanics, critical of repetitive tasks. Motivation: Enjoyment of challenging and varied gameplay. Stance: sale.

Franchise Fan: Enjoys expansions that provide more of the same or enhanced experiences. Motivation: Enjoyment of the main game and its expansions. Stance: buy.

Value-Conscious Critic: Critical of monetization practices, prefers complete experiences. Motivation: Getting the best value for their money. Stance: deep sale.

Extra review signals

Monetization: The user reviews indicate a mixed reception regarding the DLC pricing and value. While some users find the DLCs worth the price, others feel they are overpriced unless purchased in a bundle. The overall quality of the DLCs is rated positively, with users appreciating the additional story and gameplay elements. Bundles are seen as a more economical and worthwhile purchase.