Medieval Blacksmith
Last updated: 2025-04-17
- Addictive, realistic blacksmithing experience.
- Addictive and relaxing gameplay.
- Intuitive and engaging core mechanics.
- Engaging story with impactful player choices.
- Extensive weapon customization options.
- Game is buggy and unpolished.
- Reviews
(sample size) - 362
- Helpful reviews
- 76%
- Unhelpful reviews
- 23%
- Protest reviews
- 1%
- 77%Helpful reviews with positive sentiment
- 23%Helpful reviews with negative sentiment
- Positive points
- 510
- Negative points
- 447
- Gameplay points
- 73
- Perf. points
- 17
- Rec. points
- 150
- Misc points
- 27
| Point | Description | Importance |
|---|---|---|
| Addictive, realistic blacksmithing experience | The core blacksmithing gameplay is highly engaging and satisfying. Players enjoy crafting weapons from scratch, using various tools and techniques, and find the process both realistic and rewarding. Many reviewers consider it the best blacksmithing simulator available. | 93% |
| Addictive and relaxing gameplay | The game is widely praised for being addictive, relaxing, and enjoyable. Players find it easy to lose hours in the game, with many highlighting its stress-relieving qualities and satisfying gameplay loop. The game is considered well worth its price. | 82% |
| Intuitive and engaging mechanics | The game mechanics are intuitive and well-designed, making it easy to learn but offering depth for those who want to master it. Players appreciate the smooth gameplay and the freedom to play at their own pace. The game strikes a good balance between accessibility and engagement. | 57% |
| Engaging story with impactful choices | The game features a surprisingly well-developed and engaging story. Player choices have meaningful consequences, impacting character fates and the overall narrative. The story often exceeds expectations for a simulator game. | 38% |
| Extensive weapon customization options | The game offers extensive weapon customization options, allowing players to design unique blades and influence weapon stats. Players appreciate the creative freedom and the ability to craft weapons tailored to their specific needs. The variety of blade parts and materials adds depth to the crafting process. | 35% |
| Responsive and active developers | The developers are highly responsive and actively improve the game based on community feedback. They are quick to address bugs and implement suggestions, demonstrating a strong commitment to the game's development. This is especially appreciated given the game's early access status. | 27% |
| Enjoyable mining and hammering mechanics | The game includes mining mechanics for resource acquisition, which players find surprisingly enjoyable. While hammering can be tedious initially, the skill tree offers upgrades like auto-hammering to alleviate this. The core gameplay loop, even just hammering, can be satisfying. | 19% |
| Unique NPCs with engaging interactions | The game features unique NPCs with diverse backgrounds and motivations. Interactions with NPCs are often surprising and can lead to interesting weapon crafting scenarios. This adds depth to the game world and reduces the feeling of monotony. | 12% |
| Accurate and well-designed crafting system | The crafting system is accurate and well-designed, potentially setting a new standard for simulators. The game offers a surprising amount of writing depth for a simulator, enhancing the overall experience. The crafting aspect is initially relaxing and the weapon crafting system is enjoyable. | 10% |
| Humorous tone and fun references | The game includes fun references and has a lighthearted tone. The developers care about the community and have an awesome sense of humor. The game's profanity translation is amusing, adding to the overall enjoyment. | 8% |