Info about Citadels:

Official game description:
**The Legend Of King Arthur Reborn!**  
A vast army has gathered in front of the castle gates and is preparing to attack King Arthur! How has it come to this?  
Witness important events in the history of the legendary king and accompany him and his army on the path to an uncertain future. It is up to you to restore the honor, the glory and the reign of the Arthurian line, and rewrite the course of history!  
Good or evil? The decision is entirely yours! Two extensive campaigns give you insight into both sides of the war.
Key Features
------------
*   Construct impregnable fortresses, equip them with units, ditches and palisades and crush the hordes of enemies with your defense structures!  
*   A fortress alone does not mean victory! Build a dependable infrastructure and manage your resources.  
*   Your strategy will decide between victory and defeat! Only with the right combination of defense structures, units, extraction of raw materials, and production, will you emerge victorious from the sieges.  
*   Experience epic battles with realistic destruction! Assemble your army from a multitude of different units. But beware of falling rubble and take geographical conditions into account in your battle plan.  
*   Unlock legendary characters! Complete specific tasks and gain the support of famous heroes, granting you strategic advantages in battle.

Release date: Jul 25, 2013

Categories: Real-time Strategy, City Builder, Castle Construction, Resource Management, Base Building, Medieval Setting, Campaign and Skirmish Modes, Castle Defense


- Hardware Profile: No data
Feature extractions:
- Community Price:
  - Community fair range: $5.00 - $20.00
  - Reasoning: The reviews consistently reject the $40 asking price and cite much lower fair values. Explicit anchors cluster between $5 and $19.99: one reviewer suggests around $11, another calls $40 overpriced, one says it should be a $19.99 game with a $5 sale price, and another says it is worth $5 at most. This supports a fair base-game range of roughly $5-$20, with most evidence pointing below the current $40 price.
- Playtime Metrics:
  - Game completion: N/A
  - Story completion: N/A
  - Session length: 0.8h
  - Endgame: N/A
  - Reasoning: Reports cluster around play windows of roughly 20 to 60 minutes, with multiple mentions of crashes after about half an hour to an hour. I therefore estimated a practical session length of 0.75 hours as a midpoint. No review provides a reliable time for completing the full game, the campaign/story, or endgame content; several players report being unable to finish due to bugs, so those metrics are null.
- Time-to-fun:
  - Summary: Some players report fun after getting past glitches and learning the systems, but many others never reach that point because of missing tutorial, poor UI, and technical issues.
  - Stance: Clicks after
  - Anchor: Getting the hang of the game
  - Time to anchor: N/A
  - Friction: No tutorial or explanations for mechanics; Bugs and glitches; Poor UI and cursor issues; Steep learning curve; Repetitive audio
  - Unlock drivers: Getting past problems and glitches; Getting the hang of the game; Learning the systems despite missing tutorial
  - Conditions: Once the player gets past bugs and glitches; Once the player gets the hang of the game; Tolerance for missing tutorial and poor UI; Ability to progress past early levels or tutorial without freezes; Multiplayer or deeper customization for lasting enjoyment; Tolerance for repetitive audio
- Player Archetypes:
  - Old-School RTS Veteran (no buy)
    - Motivation: To relive and evaluate familiar classic RTS and base-building mechanics
    - Playstyle: Compares mechanics against genre classics and expects stable, complete RTS features
    - Experience: veteran
    - Purchase stance: no buy
    - Labels: N/A
    - Reference games: Age of Empires II: HD Edition; Civilization; StarCraft; Rise of Nations; Stronghold Crusader 2
  - Medieval Citadel Builder (buy)
    - Motivation: To build and manage a medieval walled city or citadel
    - Playstyle: Focuses on construction, city management, and wall defenses while working around bugs
    - Experience: mixed
    - Purchase stance: buy
    - Labels: N/A
    - Reference games: N/A
  - Multiplayer-Seeking RTS Player (no buy)
    - Motivation: To play RTS matches with other players and extend replayability through multiplayer or customization
    - Playstyle: Seeks multiplayer skirmishes, map editors, and social or competitive RTS play
    - Experience: familiar
    - Purchase stance: no buy
    - Labels: N/A
    - Reference games: N/A
  - Polish-First Value Buyer (no buy)
    - Motivation: To get a complete, stable, and usable game that justifies its price
    - Playstyle: Expects reliable launch performance, functional UI, and finished features before investing time
    - Experience: mixed
    - Purchase stance: no buy
    - Labels: N/A
    - Reference games: N/A


Below are summaries of things people say about the game per category.
Each point is assigned a weight that represents how often it is mentioned across all reviews.
What players like:
- Overall positive reception (weight 0.21): Many reviewers find the game cool, interesting, fun, and well made. It is generally regarded as a good and enjoyable experience.
- Good concept and potential (weight 0.17): The game's idea and concept are praised as great, excellent, and having much potential. Reviewers see it as a strong foundation that could become a classic.
- Good graphics and art style (weight 0.13): The graphics are visually appealing, excellent at max settings, and the art style is enjoyed by many. Buildings are beautiful and well designed.
- Castle building and fortifications (weight 0.12): Players enjoy building their own fortified city and placing buildings with orientation freedom. The castle and fortress theme is particularly appealing.
- Fun but flawed gameplay (weight 0.09): The gameplay is considered okay or good but with some issues. Reviewers enjoy it and see potential despite the flaws.
- Medieval RTS with depth (weight 0.09): The game offers a simple yet fun medieval RTS experience with strategic depth. It encourages digging in and careful planning rather than rushing.
- Engaging campaign and story (weight 0.09): The campaign is enthralling, with an interesting plot and decisions that affect the story. The narrative backdrop adds to the experience.
- Smooth and unique gameplay (weight 0.07): The gameplay is described as smooth, flawless in its unique way, and enjoyable. It offers a unique experience for players.
- Interesting resource and economy system (weight 0.07): The economy is simple yet interesting, with unique mechanics like wood processing and storage logistics. These systems add depth to the gameplay.
- Easy to learn and pick up (weight 0.07): The game is very easy to pick up and the mechanics are not too difficult for RTS fans. It gets better as you learn.
- Good for fans of old-school RTS (weight 0.07): The gameplay is fun for those who like old-school RTS and building games. It appeals to fans of the genre.
- Enjoyable for short sessions (weight 0.05): The game is fun for short spare-time sessions and provides quick entertainment. It is easy to jump into.
- Strategic supply and logistics (weight 0.05): Protecting supply routes affects military strength, adding a strategic layer. The storage logistics system is interesting.
- Interesting maps and modes (weight 0.05): The maps are very interesting, and the duel map was more fun. Game modes are relatively good.
- Unit variety and control (weight 0.04): There is a lot of variety in units within a soldier class, and players can control each warrior. This adds tactical depth.
- More choices and resources (weight 0.04): Reviewers want more building choices and resources to gather. This suggests room for expansion.
- Enjoyable micro-management (weight 0.04): The micro-management is enjoyable, including switching workers between jobs. It adds a layer of engagement.

Common complaints:
- Frequent game crashes (weight 0.23): Players report that the game crashes constantly, often within minutes of starting, making it unplayable. Some crashes occur at startup or after extended play sessions.
- Pervasive bugs and glitches (weight 0.21): Bugs and inconsistencies affect nearly every aspect of gameplay, with players reporting the game is full of glitches that interfere with play.
- Buggy UI and interface (weight 0.1): The user interface is clunky, not user-friendly, and fundamentally flawed with broken programming, hurting the overall experience.
- Game fails to launch (weight 0.09): The game does not launch or open at all on Windows for many players, rendering it completely broken from the start.
- No multiplayer mode (weight 0.09): Players are disappointed that there is no multiplayer or online play of any kind, contrary to expectations.
- Mouse and cursor issues (weight 0.08): Mouse control does not respond properly and the cursor may not appear at all, making the game unplayable for some.
- Wall and tower building bugs (weight 0.08): Bugs affect wall-building, including inability to place walls between close towers and needing to rebuild towers repeatedly for connections.
- Citadels.exe crash errors (weight 0.08): The game displays a 'Citadels (Not Responding)' or 'citadels.exe has stopped working' error before shutting down. This occurs even during the tutorial.
- Bad AI behavior (weight 0.08): The artificial intelligence is described as stupid, not clever, and horribly dumb, negatively impacting gameplay.
- Wall placement is frustrating (weight 0.08): Players find walls very difficult to place due to steep terrain, unspecified restrictions, and positioning issues.
- Unplayable due to freezes (weight 0.07): Freezes, lag, and bugs make the game impossible to play, with players describing constant freezing during gameplay.
- Not worth the price (weight 0.06): Reviewers state the game is not worth the money, citing lack of functionality for the price charged.
- Bad combat system (weight 0.05): The combat system is implemented poorly and considered bad by players.
- Sluggish gameplay pace (weight 0.05): The game functions very slowly and feels sluggish, making gameplay extremely slow.
- Inconvenient and clumsy design (weight 0.05): The game is described as inconvenient in all aspects and very unfriendly to the user.

Gameplay feedback:
- Wall and castle building (weight 0.19): Building walls and castles is a core mechanic, with clusters describing walls, towers, and fortifications as central to gameplay. Players can construct and upgrade these structures.
- Skirmish and campaign modes (weight 0.16): The game offers both campaign and skirmish modes, with skirmish providing sandbox play and multiple game types. Campaign missions include story elements and progress saving.
- Medieval RTS setting (weight 0.16): The game is a real-time strategy title set in medieval Europe, often compared to Age of Empires. It features a medieval theme with castles and siege weapons.
- Resource gathering and economy (weight 0.12): Players gather resources such as minerals using villagers and manage an economy system, though some find it oversimplistic. Base building and resource gathering are core mechanics.
- Base building and unit recruitment (weight 0.09): The game involves constructing buildings, recruiting units, and directing them in real-time strategy fashion. Building placement and upgrades are part of the mechanics.
- Campaign maps and missions (weight 0.09): The campaign features multiple maps and story missions with progress saving. Scenarios follow King Arthur's story.
- Castle defense and siege (weight 0.08): There is a castle defense mode and a focus on siege weapons like catapults and defense towers. The gameplay involves defending and attacking fortresses.
- AI opponents in skirmish (weight 0.04): Skirmish matches against AI-controlled opponents are available, providing solo play options.
- Confusing building placement (weight 0.04): The building placement system is confusing, which can hinder the building experience.

Performance notes:
- Frequent game crashes (weight 0.31): Many players report the game crashing frequently, often after specific play durations or during missions. This is the most common and severe issue, affecting gameplay significantly.
- Game fails to launch (weight 0.18): Multiple reports indicate the game does not start at all, sometimes showing error messages or black screens. This prevents any gameplay.
- Poor performance and optimization (weight 0.17): The game runs poorly even on high-end hardware, with low FPS, stutters, and lag. Optimization is widely criticized.
- Frequent freezes and hangs (weight 0.15): Players experience frequent freezes or hangs, sometimes even on high-end systems, making the game unplayable. Freezes occur randomly or at specific points.
- Crashes on specific levels (weight 0.11): Crashes are particularly common on certain levels, such as mission 4 or level 3, and during skirmish mode. This suggests level-specific bugs.
- Windows compatibility issues (weight 0.05): The game has issues on Windows, including crashes on Windows 10 and broken functionality on some systems. ALT-Tab can trigger crashes.
- Save game corruption and crashes (weight 0.05): Loading save games can cause crashes, and saved games may become corrupted. The lack of auto-save exacerbates progress loss.
- Graphics and texture glitches (weight 0.05): Players report glitches such as unloadable objects and textures, and blue screen glitches. The game is described as very glitchy overall.
- Exits to desktop randomly (weight 0.02): The game sometimes exits to Windows without warning, often during campaign matches. This is a form of crash.
- GPU overheating (weight 0.02): The game can cause the GPU to overheat severely, indicating poor hardware optimization.
- Plot-stopper bug (weight 0.02): A bug halts gameplay progression, preventing players from continuing. This is critical but isolated.
- Cursor not showing (weight 0.02): The mouse cursor may not appear, hindering interaction. This is a less common but impactful issue.
- Korean username crash (weight 0.02): The game crashes if the Windows username is in Korean, a specific but reproducible issue.

Recommendations:
- Strong negative purchase advice (weight 0.36): The overwhelming majority of reviewers strongly advise against buying the game under any circumstances, often using emphatic language and citing poor value. This sentiment spans many clusters and represents the dominant opinion.
- Better alternatives exist (weight 0.21): Reviewers frequently suggest playing other games instead, particularly the Stronghold series, Age of Empires, Banished, or Tetris, indicating the game fails to compete with established titles in the genre.
- Not recommended by reviewers (weight 0.18): Many reviewers explicitly state they do not recommend the game, with some specifying it is not recommended even if free. This is a broad consensus against the game.
- Recommended for genre fans (weight 0.15): A minority of reviewers recommend the game specifically to fans of RTS, city-building, or medieval themes, suggesting niche appeal. This contrasts with the general negative sentiment.
- Wait for sale or discount (weight 0.15): Some reviewers suggest buying only on sale or at a significantly reduced price, indicating the game may be worth trying only at a low cost. This is a common conditional recommendation.
- Poor value for money (weight 0.14): Many reviewers feel the game is not worth its price, especially at full price, and some would not buy it even at a deep discount. This highlights perceived low quality relative to cost.
- Positive recommendations exist (weight 0.09): Some reviewers positively recommend the game, calling it a great acquisition or fun to play. These are isolated against the overall negative trend.
- Wait for fixes before buying (weight 0.07): Some reviewers suggest waiting until issues are resolved or a year passes before purchasing, reflecting hope for future improvement.
- Avoid due to bugs and incompleteness (weight 0.07): Reviewers warn against buying because the game is broken, incomplete, or abandoned by developers, with some comparing it to a tech demo. This is a specific quality concern.
- Publisher/developer criticism (weight 0.04): A few reviewers advise against buying from the publisher or producer, indicating distrust in the company. This is a niche but notable sentiment.
- Hardware requirements a concern (weight 0.03): Some reviewers conditionally recommend the game only if the player has the necessary hardware, suggesting performance issues on lower-end systems.
- Multiplayer lacking (weight 0.03): A couple of reviewers do not recommend the game due to lack of multiplayer, which is a specific missing feature for some players.
- Only for hardcore Stronghold fans (weight 0.03): A few reviewers mention the game will appeal to hardcore Stronghold fans or those who played Stronghold 3, indicating a very specific audience.
- Not for base-building fans (weight 0.02): One reviewer notes the game is not recommended for those expecting a base-builder or town management experience, indicating a mismatch in genre expectations.
- Short play sessions enjoyable (weight 0.02): One reviewer finds the game enjoyable for short 20-minute sessions, suggesting it can be fun in small doses.
- Not worth download time (weight 0.02): One reviewer states the game is not worth the money or the time to download and install, emphasizing low value.
- Free games are better (weight 0.02): One reviewer claims free games are better than this paid game, underscoring poor quality.
- Buy from Amazon instead (weight 0.02): One reviewer recommends buying from Amazon rather than Steam to avoid problems, hinting at issues with the Steam version or platform.
- Only for first-time designers (weight 0.02): One reviewer suggests the game is suitable only for first-time game designers, implying it is a learning project rather than a polished game.

Other player notes:
- Unfavorable Age of Empires comparison (weight 0.22): Reviewers repeatedly compare the game to Age of Empires and find it lacking in flavor, originality, and depth. Many recommend playing Age of Empires instead.
- Unfavorable Stronghold comparison (weight 0.19): The game is often compared unfavorably to Stronghold and its sequels, with reviewers stating Stronghold offers more enjoyable gameplay and better value.
- Abandoned by developers (weight 0.17): Reviewers report that the game is no longer in development, receives no updates or DLC, and has been left to die by its creators.
- Overpriced for its content (weight 0.14): Reviewers feel the game is not worth its price (often $40-50) given its technical level and lack of content, though some bought it on sale.
- Feels like an unfinished beta (weight 0.12): Reviewers describe the game as a beta version with basic bugs, and some note that multiple patches have not improved it.
- Compared to Settlers and other games (weight 0.11): Reviewers also compare the game to The Settlers, Empire Earth, and other RTS titles, generally finding it inferior.
- Developer and publisher history (weight 0.11): The original developer went defunct, the publisher does not support the game, and the CEO allegedly took profits leaving employees unpaid.
- Other negative comparisons (weight 0.1): Reviewers also compare the game unfavorably to Lord of the Rings: Battle for Middle-earth 2, Warcraft 3, StarCraft 2, and XCOM, among others.
- Positive comparisons and recommendations (weight 0.09): Some reviewers compare the game favorably to Stronghold and Age of Empires in terms of potential, and recommend alternatives like Islanders or Banished.
- Patches improved the game (weight 0.09): Several major patches since release have significantly improved the game's stability and performance, though some remain unsatisfied.
- Dated graphics (weight 0.08): Many reviewers note the graphics resemble games from the 1990s or early 2000s and are not up to modern standards.
- Refund and purchase warnings (weight 0.07): Reviewers warn about the game's refund eligibility, purchasing from unofficial key resellers, and Amazon's no-refund policy for digital purchases.
- Misleading store page and marketing (weight 0.07): The Steam page and other advertising make the game look better than it is, with heavily edited screenshots and visuals that misrepresent the actual product.
- Bland and boring gameplay (weight 0.07): The game is described as bland, with comparisons to playing CS:GO with bots or online checkers, and a slow start that is hard to get into.
- Potential but wasted (weight 0.07): Some reviewers see potential in the game but feel it was wasted due to poor execution and lack of polish.
- Setting and story details (weight 0.06): The game is set in Arthurian times, loosely inspired by the collapse of Arthurian Britain, with a story about King Arthur dying and surviving knights trying to save everyone.
- Lacks voice acting and story (weight 0.05): The game has no voice acting in the campaign, lacks dynamic sequences, and offers almost no story or heroes.
- Missing multiplayer and skirmish modes (weight 0.05): The game lacks multiplayer and has only one skirmish map, which limits replayability.
- No map editor (weight 0.02): The absence of a map editor is seen as a shortcoming compared to other games in the genre.

Emotions:
- Frustration (weight 0.35): Players are frustrated by pervasive technical problems, especially constant crashes that occur within minutes, prevent progression, and make the game unplayable. Many also cite a lack of developer support, with the game abandoned and never patched, leaving bugs unresolved. Poor AI, unintuitive controls, and broken building mechanics further compound the frustration.
- Disappointment (weight 0.31): Disappointment stems from a strong initial premise and potential that was squandered by bugs, crashes, and unfinished features. The game was abandoned by developers, lacks promised content like multiplayer, and fails to deliver the experience suggested by its marketing. Poor graphics, AI, and design flaws compound the letdown.
- Anger (weight 0.06): Anger is driven by the perception of being scammed: paying full price for a broken, abandoned game with no fixes since launch. Frequent crashes, missing features, and poor quality for the price lead to feelings of being ripped off. The lack of autosave and unplayable states exacerbate the rage.
- Regret (weight 0.05): Players regret spending money on a game that doesn't work, often bought on impulse or sale, only to find it unplayable due to crashes and poor optimization. Many describe it as their worst purchase on Steam, feeling ripped off and foolish for ignoring negative reviews.
- Boredom (weight 0.03): Boredom arises from repetitive gameplay, slow pacing, and a lack of challenge, with players losing interest after an hour. The low unit cap and bland campaign contribute to a sense that battles feel small and unimportant. Frequent crashes also disrupt any engagement.
- Enjoyment (weight 0.02): Despite flaws, some players enjoy the micro-management, resource system, and strategic freedom. Building defenses and varied strategies provide fun, especially for short sessions. The game is fun despite negative reviews and offers engaging gameplay.
- Annoyance (weight 0.02): Annoyance is caused by small but persistent issues: repetitive whistling audio, stuck units, fiddly wall building, and lost progress due to crashes. Overwhelming worker sounds and poor combat further irritate players.
- Dissatisfaction (weight 0.02): Dissatisfaction comes from the game's bad points outweighing good ideas, with outdated graphics, poor sound, lack of multiplayer, and bugs. Mechanics feel outdated and uninnovative, and the overall experience is not fun.
- Enthusiasm (weight 0.01): Enthusiasm is fueled by interesting maps, the ability to build castles, and strategic city management. Excellent graphics, playability, and campaign difficulty excite players, who see potential for a remaster and appreciate components missing from the Stronghold series.
- Satisfaction (weight 0.01): Satisfaction comes from smooth and unique gameplay, high-quality graphics at max settings, and a fun experience worth the patience. For some, it is their favorite version of this gameplay style.
- Confusion (weight 0.01): Confusion arises from unclear objectives, broken UI, and a lack of tutorial. Players don't know what to do with resources or how to play, leading to an inexplicable playstyle and uncertainty about the game's purpose.
- Disgust (weight 0.01): Disgust is triggered by extremely poor menus, graphics, sound, and gameplay, as well as odd visual details like trumpet sounds in the Civil War and motionless flags. A company charging a high price for a technically outdated game is seen as appalling.
- Disappointed (weight 0.01): Disappointed players find the game too simple, bringing nothing new, and failing to start with an error. Combat is not as refined as early Stronghold games, making the game fall short of expectations.
- Distrust (weight 0.01): Distrust stems from suspicion that developers abandoned the game after taking the money. The poorly constructed game reinforces beliefs that the developers are not committed to fixing it.
- Sadness (weight 0.01): Sadness is felt because a game with potential fell short due to abandonment. It disappoints compared to its Stronghold inspiration, evoking a sense of loss for what could have been.
- Frustrated (weight 0.01): Frustrated players experience freezing that loses an hour of progress, crashes when adding wall attachments, and numerous bugs like farmers building themselves into walls. These issues make the game deeply irritating.
- Disinterest (weight 0.01): Disinterest occurs because players cannot get into the storyline and find the game uninteresting overall.
- Abandonment (weight 0): Abandonment is felt because developers left the game to die, with no updates or support, leaving it in a broken state.
- Rage (weight 0): Rage is caused by crashes and disobedient lumberjack AI, which disrupt gameplay and lead to intense anger.
- Insanity (weight 0): Insanity results from clicking on units selecting something nearby instead of the intended target, making controls maddening.}